When Tévez handed in that transfer request I lost a lot of respect for him. I actually don't trust him now and think he will be off in the summer. All this has made me look at his game, rather than with a mindset of "oh he fucked off the Rags, hates Fergie and Neville; he's the best!" to a more objective mindset. I've noticed how greedy he can be when better options are on (especially Blackpool at home and Villa away).
But then look at his performance at Newcastle and against Wolves. That goal from Milner's cross at SJP was the best finish I've seen in years (watch it again, it was out of this world good!)Even at his best Torres would have to go some to top that.
So I'd probably say Tévez. But as I say, it wouldn't surprise me if he was playing for Barca or Real next season so maybe we do need to sign Torres?!