gordondaviesmoustache said:
chris85mcfc said:
Explain further mate?
He was no longer required by a team that were head and shoulders above the team he joined and I imagine he took a pretty big pay cut. Given that he doesn't even need to move home in order to get to work, and is still relatively close to his brother would suggest it was a very good move for him
Apologies. Reading back I didn't make myself clear.
I was speaking in general terms, rather than about Kolo and I should have put the term mercenary in quotation marks as, quite frankly, it's a fucking ridiculous description, as it applies to 99% of footballers.
I meant 'mercenary', in that to those that routinely use that term to describe footballers who don't display the requisite loyalty, it is often those that leave on a Bosman who are the biggest sinners: Owen, Campbell, Ballack.
Personally I don't have a problem with any player that does this,including Jimmy if that's the way things end up. They've completed and complied with the terms of their contract and are free to earn a living where they best see fit. Clubs know the score on this and have plenty of time and opportunity to deal with it if they see fit.
All I meant was someone leaving on a free doesn't exclude them from the accusation of being a mercenary
per se which is what your post was seeming to suggest.
Yeah just looked at my original post again and its a bit vague
I was trying to express the opinion that in Kolo's case there is a narrative that
perhaps he was a 'mercenary' (i cant stand that word either) when he joined City as he was seen to be joining a club slightly below his current club in the pecking order, and the chances are he was doubling his salary.
But his move to Liverpool is different in the respect that he was no longer required by his current club, and he was offered a deal 40 miles down the road which meant he didn't have to move home or move away from close family, whilst taking a reduction in salary
But i do agree with what you're getting at about Bosman players leaving for the biggest pay-day they can possibly get, im talking the transfers of Campo, Hierro, Djorkaeff and Okocha to Bolton (some of those might have been small fees), but there the kind of deals that should be looked at as 'transfers of mercanaries' not when a good footballer goes to a club challenging for trophies, which the likes of Yaya, Silva and Aguero were when they joined City
I might have tied myself in knots a little bit then but its been a long day :)