The Album Review Club - Week #145 - (page 1923) - Tellin' Stories - The Charlatans

[Coatigan]

If I write out the songs, and a few of who might be what, it seems to group the same people together for a few numbers of songs.

 

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

If I write out the songs, and a few of who might be what, it seems to group the same people together for a few numbers of songs.

I've got you on 3, and some others are lumped together too, and yet there's a few I simply have no idea on. I just don't have the history together that some of you have here being the newest of the selectors.

I've got 3 pegged for sure, unless the Clarkie has been raised to a level even I didn't see. Even then, that would have required some advanced coordination and someone else actually owning the same song, which I don't think this lot is capable of. ;-)

 

[Coatigan]

bennyboy - arctic monkeys
BimboBob - aztec camera
Black&White&BlueMoon Town - Silversun pickups / CH
BlueHammer85 - dog eye view
Coatigan - Matilda May
FogBlueInSanFran - don Henley
GoatersLeftShin - cohen
GornikDaze - Metallica
journolud - junip
LGWIO - pale fountains
mancity111 - ian mcnabb
mancity2012_eamo - joni mitchell
Mancitydoogle - kevin mcdermott
OB1 - carpenters
Out on blue 6 - the big special
RobMCFC - crowded house
Saddleworth2 - allison russell
southamptonblue - kurt vile
stoneblue - nick waterhouse
threespires - The Bad Plus

 

[Coatigan]

I've got you on 3, and some others are lumped together too, and yet there's a few I simply have no idea on. I just don't have the history together that some of you have here being the newest of the selectors.

I've got 3 pegged for sure, unless the Clarkie has been raised to a level even I didn't see. Even then, that would have required some advanced coordination and someone else actually owning the same song, which I don't think this lot is capable of. ;-)

Ha I am similar. I've got too many for a few, and not enough for others.

I had you down for 3 including a clarkie. In the end, I kind of randomised it and see what happens.

 

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

Coatigan - Matilda May

Well played, and no, not one of the 3 I had for you. It will make my Top 10 assuming I'm allowed to submit it! ;-)

 

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

Black&White&BlueMoon Town - Silversun pickups / CH

I only submitted one song despite once having 10 on my shortlist! ;-)

 

[Coatigan]

I only submitted one song despite once having 10 on my shortlist! ;-)

I trust rob to pick my first answer. Just wanted it there so if it turns out to be you framing him, I can j'accuse you.

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

I’m pretty sure on about 3-4 of them and think I have a good shot on 3-4 more. After that it was quite random. Obviously have switched my actual with someone else’s. Credited one of my favo(u)rite posters (in terms of album choices) with the song I liked best. Had a hard time with the poster whose taste most aligns with mine ironically! Excellent subterfuge attempt by one poster but I think I’ve got him sussed. Another I am pretty sure picked one of his two favo(u)rite songs. We shall see!

bennyboy You must be prepared to dream - Ian McNabb

BimboBob Goodbye To Love - The Carpenters

Black&White&BlueMoon Town And here we test our powers of observation - The Bad Plus

BlueHammer85 First We Take Manhattan - Leonard Cohen

Coatigan Old Place - Nick Waterhouse

FogBlueInSanFran Breathe - Imelda May

GoatersLeftShin Woodstock - Joni Mitchell

GornikDaze Escape - Metallica

journolud We Could Send Letters - Aztec Camera

LGWIO Palm Of My Hand - The Pale Fountains

mancity111 Instinct - Crowded House

mancity2012_eamo Substitution - Silversun Pickups

Mancitydoogle One Trick Ponies - Kurt Vile

OB1 The Boys of Summer - Don Henley

Out on blue 6 Black Dog/White Horse - Big Special

RobMCFC For Those In Peril From The Sea - Kevin McDermott Orchestra

Saddleworth2 The Runner - Allison Russell

southamptonblue Line of Fire - Junip

stoneblue Everything Falls Apart - Dogs Eye View

threespires Mardy Bum - Arctic Monkeys

 

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

I trust rob to pick my first answer. Just wanted it there so if it turns out to be you framing him, I can j'accuse you.

Nice, an extra layer of picking the framers too. As if I'm capable of such! ;-)

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

First time through I thought this playlist was rather pedestrian, including my own pick TBF. Second time through I liked it a lot more.