The FTSE

  • Thread starter Thread starter worsleyweb
  • Start date Start date
That's what I was saying, is that your pot will continue to grow once you retire, so you arent just going to take a hit of 20 years of inflation are you?

Does the 4% drawdown rule take into account the state pension, i assume not

A lot of people with decent pension pots can probably live off the state pension whilst dipping into their private pension to top it up; id probably use the state for general living, and my private for holidays etc

Thats assuming your mortgage has been paid off of course
The 4% rule is very American centric and uses investment in the US stock market as its base. It is however mightily pessimistic but does bring into perspective how sequence of returns in early retirement can swing outcomes.

For instance, if you retired in 1973 over a 30 yr period you could have had a withdrawal rate of around 4% which would have been just about safe.

Retire 2 yrs later in 1975 over a 30 yr period and you could have had a withdrawal rate of 8% and still been perfectly safe.

What it shows is that interest rates and stock performance in your first few years of retirement has the biggest impact on outcomes. Its amplified the further away from state pension age you are. Thats why building a cash buffer alongside your pension is important and even more so if you want to retire late 50s or very early 60s.

Yes the state pension gives some protection and as a couple assuming you are mortgage free you would probably be fine in terms of covering your living expenses it does however become significantly more challenging if your partner passes away not long after the start of retirement. Yes I know thats a morbid thought but it does happen and more frequently than most people think.

Obviously if you have final salary pensions as well then that changes things significantly, but just defined contribution, you need to think about it a bit more carefully.
 
Last edited:
The 4% rule is very American centric and uses investment in the US stock market as its base. It is however mightily pessimistic but does bring into perspective how sequence of returns in early retirement can swing outcomes.

For instance, if you retired in 1973 over a 30 yr period you could have had a withdrawal rate of around 4% which would have been just about safe.

Retire 2 yrs later in 1975 over a 30 yr period and you could have had a withdrawal rate of 8% and still being perfectly safe.

What it shows is that interest rates and stock performance in your first few years of retirement has the biggest impact on outcomes. Its amplified the further away from state pension age you are. Thats why building a cash buffer alongside your pension is important and even more so if you want to retire late 50s or very early 60s.

Yes the state pension gives some protection and as a couple assuming you are mortgage free you would probably be fine in terms of covering your living expenses it does however become significantly more challenging if your partner passes away not long after the start of retirement. Yes I know thats a morbid thought but it does happen and more frequently than most people think.

Obviously if you have final salary pensions as well then that changes things significantly, but just defined contribution, you need to think about it a bit more carefully.
A friend of mine has a very substantial SIPP pot he's been drawing on for nearly 10 years. It's got £400k more than when he started drawing down. He's taken £300k out in the last tax year to enjoy otherwise he just knows at this rate he'll die with a phenomenal amount.
 
A friend of mine has a very substantial SIPP pot he's been drawing on for nearly 10 years. It's got £400k more than when he started drawing down. He's taken £300k out in the last tax year to enjoy otherwise he just knows at this rate he'll die with a phenomenal amount.
Just looking at my own pension this morning, and over the last 12 months, the growth from interest has just about beaten the growth from contributions

I know thats a very simplistic view, but does go to show how much leg work compounding is doing for you, and that even with no contributions at retirement, your pot will still tick away even with a sensible drawdown
 
Just looking at my own pension this morning, and over the last 12 months, the growth from interest has just about beaten the growth from contributions

I know thats a very simplistic view, but does go to show how much leg work compounding is doing for you, and that even with no contributions at retirement, your pot will still tick away even with a sensible drawdown
My mate was taking £100k but it was getting a yield of £125k-£135k so he decided to bite the bullet and pay the tax which will have to paid at some stage anyway.
 
My mate was taking £100k but it was getting a yield of £125k-£135k so he decided to bite the bullet and pay the tax which will have to paid at some stage anyway.
Incredible!

That was my basic assumption, was that in the first few years of retirement, if you've got a decent pot, your return will probably be greater than your drawdown; and that was before factoring in the state pension

Its all relative though, as a bit of quick maths tells me your mates pot is over £1m comfortably, and at that level you'd assume the mortgage is paid off etc so unless they've got a crazy hobby, or an incredibly lavish lifestyle, then their pot will probably continue to grow
 
Incredible!

That was my basic assumption, was that in the first few years of retirement, if you've got a decent pot, your return will probably be greater than your drawdown; and that was before factoring in the state pension

Its all relative though, as a bit of quick maths tells me your mates pot is over £1m comfortably, and at that level you'd assume the mortgage is paid off etc so unless they've got a crazy hobby, or an incredibly lavish lifestyle, then their pot will probably continue to grow
It is. I think he's got a bit more than that and is a cautious investor as only a 5-6% return is enough to drawdown and still build the pot. Jammy sod!!
 
That's what I was saying, is that your pot will continue to grow once you retire, so you arent just going to take a hit of 20 years of inflation are you?

Does the 4% drawdown rule take into account the state pension, i assume not

A lot of people with decent pension pots can probably live off the state pension whilst dipping into their private pension to top it up; id probably use the state for general living, and my private for holidays etc

Thats assuming your mortgage has been paid off of course

2 full state pensions is just under £2100 a month. Not too shabby.
 
Thoughts on borrowing more on my mortgage to fund a one-off investment into my SIPP to give my pension fund a boost? I know there are risks attached, etc, but if done over the medium term I'm thinking the growth - when taking the tax relief into account - should outstrip my mortgage interest rate?
 
Thoughts on borrowing more on my mortgage to fund a one-off investment into my SIPP to give my pension fund a boost? I know there are risks attached, etc, but if done over the medium term I'm thinking the growth - when taking the tax relief into account - should outstrip my mortgage interest rate?
Christ I'm not sure and its just an opinion, but we've just borrowed a bit more as were moving house, and we are looking at 5.3%

Depends on how much you're borrowing, but as a guide, our advisor said every 10k will probably cost you about £50 a month
 
Christ I'm not sure and its just an opinion, but we've just borrowed a bit more as were moving house, and we are looking at 5.3%

Depends on how much you're borrowing, but as a guide, our advisor said every 10k will probably cost you about £50 a month
Ok, cheers. Was looking at an extra £50k but over 15 years as that's how long my present mortgage has left to run. I do actually have just shy of £70k in savings and ISAs but I don't want to plough too much of that into my pension in case things go tits up at work or with my health
 
Ok, cheers. Was looking at an extra £50k but over 15 years as that's how long my present mortgage has left to run. I do actually have just shy of £70k in savings and ISAs but I don't want to plough too much of that into my pension in case things go tits up at work or with my health
I'm far from an advisor, but id imagine you're looking at more than £50 per 10k given the duration, but having said that, your LTV will likely be a lot lower than mine

Speak to an advisor mate as its not a decision you want to take lightly
 
I'm far from an advisor, but id imagine you're looking at more than £50 per 10k given the duration, but having said that, your LTV will likely be a lot lower than mine

Speak to an advisor mate as its not a decision you want to take lightly
Yeah, I think it would add around an extra £400 per month to it. As you say, it's not a decision to be taken lately and I certainly won't be rushing into it!
 
Thoughts on borrowing more on my mortgage to fund a one-off investment into my SIPP to give my pension fund a boost? I know there are risks attached, etc, but if done over the medium term I'm thinking the growth - when taking the tax relief into account - should outstrip my mortgage interest rate?
I would not do that. Maybe pay off the mortgage quicker if you have spare cash. Especially with current rates.
 
I would not do that. Maybe pay off the mortgage quicker if you have spare cash. Especially with current rates.
Appreciate the advice mate. Although mortgage interest rates have been creeping up, I can still get decent-ish rate with my current lender.

I'm parking the idea for now and seeing how things go with work over the next 12 months or so
 
The 4% rule is very American centric and uses investment in the US stock market as its base. It is however mightily pessimistic but does bring into perspective how sequence of returns in early retirement can swing outcomes.

For instance, if you retired in 1973 over a 30 yr period you could have had a withdrawal rate of around 4% which would have been just about safe.

Retire 2 yrs later in 1975 over a 30 yr period and you could have had a withdrawal rate of 8% and still been perfectly safe.

What it shows is that interest rates and stock performance in your first few years of retirement has the biggest impact on outcomes. Its amplified the further away from state pension age you are. Thats why building a cash buffer alongside your pension is important and even more so if you want to retire late 50s or very early 60s.

Yes the state pension gives some protection and as a couple assuming you are mortgage free you would probably be fine in terms of covering your living expenses it does however become significantly more challenging if your partner passes away not long after the start of retirement. Yes I know thats a morbid thought but it does happen and more frequently than most people think.

Obviously if you have final salary pensions as well then that changes things significantly, but just defined contribution, you need to think about it a bit more carefully.
Was listening to a discussion with Bill Bengen this week which was recorded about 18 months ago. He's still doing modelling and reckons 5% had only failed in one year and in many starting years, much higher percentages worked. Issue is, you can only confirm it in retrospect, which isn't ideal...

The one note of caution he did have is that there's never been a period with higher inflation and stock market valuations, so none of the models reflect the current situation. His suggestion was if you're starting point is with stock markets at a high, you use a lower percentage, whereas around a bear market, you can probably start higher as it's most likely the portfolio will recover i.e. the sequence risk has already happened.

With annuity rates looking better than they did for a long time, I'm tempted to cover the absolute basics through that and then can draw down on the pot at any rate, as it's basically entertainment money. Heat don't like the idea of an annuity and then not living longer than they expect. Might move to Blackpool and take up smoking before I apply!
 
Was listening to a discussion with Bill Bengen this week which was recorded about 18 months ago. He's still doing modelling and reckons 5% had only failed in one year and in many starting years, much higher percentages worked. Issue is, you can only confirm it in retrospect, which isn't ideal...

The one note of caution he did have is that there's never been a period with higher inflation and stock market valuations, so none of the models reflect the current situation. His suggestion was if you're starting point is with stock markets at a high, you use a lower percentage, whereas around a bear market, you can probably start higher as it's most likely the portfolio will recover i.e. the sequence risk has already happened.

With annuity rates looking better than they did for a long time, I'm tempted to cover the absolute basics through that and then can draw down on the pot at any rate, as it's basically entertainment money. Heat don't like the idea of an annuity and then not living longer than they expect. Might move to Blackpool and take up smoking before I apply!
Im reasonably fortunate that I have a couple of decent final salary pensions that will pretty much cover my base outgoings from 57 onwards so everything in mine and my wife's DC pensions/SIPP is fun money.

Just need to make it to 57, 3 yrs and 10 months to go, not that I'm counting ;-). To be fair I'm not desperate to retire, but it will be nice to know I can pull the trigger when i want or at least drop a few days or do something a bit less stressful.
 
Last edited:
The 4% rule is very American centric and uses investment in the US stock market as its base. It is however mightily pessimistic but does bring into perspective how sequence of returns in early retirement can swing outcomes.

For instance, if you retired in 1973 over a 30 yr period you could have had a withdrawal rate of around 4% which would have been just about safe.

Retire 2 yrs later in 1975 over a 30 yr period and you could have had a withdrawal rate of 8% and still been perfectly safe.

What it shows is that interest rates and stock performance in your first few years of retirement has the biggest impact on outcomes. Its amplified the further away from state pension age you are. Thats why building a cash buffer alongside your pension is important and even more so if you want to retire late 50s or very early 60s.

Yes the state pension gives some protection and as a couple assuming you are mortgage free you would probably be fine in terms of covering your living expenses it does however become significantly more challenging if your partner passes away not long after the start of retirement. Yes I know thats a morbid thought but it does happen and more frequently than most people think.

Obviously if you have final salary pensions as well then that changes things significantly, but just defined contribution, you need to think about it a bit more carefully.
Unreal how much of a difference those 2 years made. This is the worry as none of us can predict the future. Imagine retiring in the late 90s, drawing a significant percentage in the early years, then 9/11 happens? That would’ve royally screwed up everyone’s pot. Granted, the markets recovered eventually but it took a while from memory.

Of course, that’s a rare extreme scenario so I suppose we can only go off average growth over the long term. To that end, 5%-6% is what I’d be looking at.
 
Im reasonably fortunate that I have a couple of decent final salary pensions that will pretty much cover my base outgoings from 57 onwards so everything in mine and my wife's DC pensions/SIPP is fun money.

Just need to make it to 57, 3 yrs and 10 months to go, not that I'm counting ;-). To be fair I'm not desperate to retire, but it will be nice to know I can pull the trigger when i want or at least drop a few days or do something a bit less stressful.
I’m in a similar situation. We’ve got a baseline income of 2/3 our final salaries that is linked to inflation. Also have some property income and a significant sum invested in equities that is growing faster than we can spend it although the missus is doing her best.Planning to give the kids a handout to help them get on the property ladder.
However health is more important. Since taking early retirement in 2022, I’ve had a brain haemorrhage and the wife’s had liver cancer. Luckily and thanks to fantastic treatment from the NHS we’ve both made good recoveries but either of us could be dead with a pile of cash unspent.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top