The perfect fumble
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 3 Jun 2012
- Messages
- 26,100
I suspect this was done deliberately, she'll be off to join her old pal Jeremy once she's milked this for all it's worth.I appreciate that. I used to work in Hackney, alongside plenty of political activists, including people who knew Diane, and that view is not unusual in the slightest. I also wouldn't presume to dismiss, or even discuss, her own experiences, when clearly she's faced abuse, and challenges way beyond anything in my life.
The initial article she replied to, however, was about day to day abuse faced by people from a variety of ethnic groups, and a couple of dismissive paragraphs, was not a nuanced or thoughtful response. Have a look at the hundreds of articles and responses written at the time - even people defending her tended to argue that what she said went too far, and that it was reasonable for her to apologise. The issue yesterday is that she wasn't making a totally separate argument, she clearly linked this to the arguments she made at that time and that's what I found disappointing.
In low politics terms it's a smart move by her.
Of course Starmer has made this all about anti-Semitism.
Folk may not be aware that prior to 1983 Jews were not recognised as an ethnic group in this country. I suspect, though I do not know, that Abbott doesn't see Jews as a distinct ethnic group.