The most under & over rated players in the prem

[blue dallas]

Over-rated: Gareth Bale, John Terry, Javier Hernandez, Rory Delap, Steven Ireland, Shaun Wright-Phillips, Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney.

Under-rated: Kevin Davies, Jon Elmander, Clint Dempsey, Phil Jones, Darren Fletcher and Charlie Adam.

gareth bale ?? pmsl.<br /><br />-- Sun Nov 21, 2010 1:39 pm --<br /><br />

The wolves trio,Milijas,Doyle and Jarvis,also underrated.

doyle.........1 prem goal all season. occupation..centre forward.

 

[kun]

Under Rated:

C. Y. Lee
Zenden
Mikel
Hutton
Agger
Fletcher
Collins
Gabbidon
Carrick
Kompany
Zabaleta
Diaby
Kalou

Over Rated:

Barry
G. Johnson
Rooney
Chamakh
J. Cole
Clichy
Cech
N'Gog
Pineaar
Baines
Lennon
Walcott
Gomes


Under Rated: 1 English
Over Rated: 7 English

 

[lee-mcfc]

Over rated: NDJ, Bale

Underated: Lucas

What is your issue with De Jong. How is he overrated. Do you have some sort of personal issue with him or something? I swear you only came on this thread to have a pop at De Jong. I don't get it.

de jong bummed his bird

 

[MCFC BOB]

Over-rated: Gareth Bale, John Terry, Javier Hernandez, Rory Delap, Steven Ireland, Shaun Wright-Phillips, Steven Gerrard and Wayne Rooney.

Under-rated: Kevin Davies, Jon Elmander, Clint Dempsey, Phil Jones, Darren Fletcher and Charlie Adam.

gareth bale ?? pmsl.

Yes, I think he is over-rated. He played three good games and David Ginola said he was as good as Messi.

 

[KentBlue]

Big Nigel overated? Are you on meths or something?

 

[stavros]

under rated: jarvis, downing

over rated: hernandez, ireland, ashley young, henderson

 

[thewatchman]

over rated - Torres
under rates - Vincent Kompany

 

[Seosa]

Underrated: James Collins

Overrated: Dunne, Lampard, Ireland

As for Rag Fletcher, he's in the unique bracket of "Overrated by Rags, Underrated by Everyone else"

 

[irishblue59]

underrated
richards
barry
gary neville
downing
fletcher
kevin davis

overrated
barry bannon
gibbs
clichy
gerrard
lampard
albrighton

 

[HellasLEAF]

stop the spurs hate lads, Gareth Bale is not overrated.

he's rated appropriately

underrated I would say Phil Jones of Blackburn

overrated I would say RVP