The Squad planning thread

So assuming we are done this window with Nico, what do we still need in the summer?

Cambiaso I think is very likely to come in and I do think he will be the only fullback. The most exciting thing about this transfer window is that in my opinion we have covered enough holes in the squad that it has opened up the possibility of a Wirtz or Musiala in the summer which seemed completely out of the question when you looked at the rebuild needed in december.

No guarantees what so ever that the new players will be good enough of course, but central defence has received good progression planning for relatively cheap because you'd expect both Reis and Khusanov to play big roles already next year alongside Dias and at least one of the Akanji/Stones/Ake trio. Getting clearer by the day that Gvardiol is a left-back that can be a hybrid of a centre-back when we are played low, winger or attacking midfielder when needed and is also class so that position is set. High hopes for Nico, and with Rodri coming back next year we finally have at least cover for him. Marmoush can play across the front-line, in my opinion more effectively than Alvarez did but jury is put whether he is effective as a Haaland understudy in the lone-striker role, but he ticks a lot of boxes.

I think we need to focus on the midfield and and a goalkeeper if Ederson still wants out. Costa seems the obvious target, despite me not personally being a fan. But it could well be we need two if we bring someone in as first-choise because I can see Ortega moving on for first-team football as well. Picking a name out of the hat, I think Benitez at PSV is the type of profile that could ve willing to do the Ortega role for us for a couple of seasons. Maybe Rulli who we have previously owned at one point. In a ideal world our squad looks something like this in August:

-Costa (Benitez/Ortega/Rulli)
-Khusanov (Akanji, Stones/Ake) Dias (Reis)
- Cambiaso (Lewis) Gvardiol (O'Reilly)
-Rodri (Nico) Baleba (Kovacic)
- Foden (Bobb) Wirtz/Musiala/Baena (Marmoush, McAtee/Millot)
- Doku, Savinho, Marmoush (Bernardo/Dibling)
- Haaland (Marmoush)

So expecting one of Ake/Stones to leave. Gundogan and De Bruyne to move on as legends, and Grealish I'd personally like but seems to be done here under Pep. Bernardo and McAtee depends on a lot of factors but they need to be replaced if they go by an extra player capable of playmaking duties


This would be a very healthy place to be 6 months into a rebuild in my opinion

Edit: Completely forgot about Nunes. Maybe for the better. But I don't think he will leave this summer. But if he stays that negates the urgent need for a Dibling/Millot.
 
Last edited:
I would be more than OK if our squad looked like this

Goalkeeper, Ortega
Cambiasso/Akanji
Reis, Khusanov, Dias, another CB (experienced but not ruined by injuries)
Gvardiol/Ake

Rodri, back up DM
Gonzalez, Kovačić

Wirtz/Musiala/Baena/Simmons, Foden

Bobb, Savinho, Doku

Haaland, Marmoush

I'm not even too greedy, it's possible for five players to come in one transfer window.

More important than that would be to find a way out for Stones, Bernardo, Gundogan, Grealish, Nunes. Earn some money from the transfer and save a nice sum of money from their weekly wages.

KDB is the only player I'm not sure what to think about, he's still the biggest offensive force there is, but physically he can't do it anymore.
 
Silva , Stones , KdB , Gundo , Nunes , Jack , Kova all need moving on , also got a feeling well be looking for a new keeper unless Eddy sorts his head out , sorry but Ortega doesnt give us what Eddy does
 
Think it's clear that we have quite a lot of players who due to one of or a combination of age/quality/fitness we need to look to move on.
Don't think it will be possible to do them all in one summer so will be about priorities.

Summer 25
Walker
Gundo
Stones
Bernardo
KDB
Ortega

Summer 26
Kova
Nunes
Ederson
Ake
Akanji
 
What do we still need?

Well considering it extremely likely Gundo, KDB, & Nunes are gone; Bernado & Kovacic are also possibly goners - along with McAtee - we'll need at least 3 more central midfielders. We are basically in the same position Liverpool were at the end of the 2022/23 season, when their midfield was completely clapped out and they rebuilt the lot on the fly. They bought Macallister, Szobozlai, Gravenberch & Endo - looks like they hit on 3/4 as well.

A genuine Right Back to replace Kyle Walker

A goalkeeper if Ederson does want out. Ortega is a solid no2 but will likely want to go to start for a Bundesliga team, which we'd have no qualms with.
 
Last edited:
Think it's clear that we have quite a lot of players who due to one of or a combination of age/quality/fitness we need to look to move on.
Don't think it will be possible to do them all in one summer so will be about priorities.

Summer 25
Walker
Gundo
Stones
Bernardo
KDB
Ortega

Summer 26
Kova
Nunes
Ederson
Ake
Akanji
Agree with most but Id keep Ake
 
Departures
Due to age : KDB, Silva, Gundogan
Due to fitness: Stones,
Due to loss of ability : Akanji, Kovacic,
Grealish.
Just not good enough : Nunes, Lewis

Keep :
Ederson, Ortega, Rodri, Haaland, Dias, Guardiol, Ake, Foden(after a slap)
Savinho, Marmoush, Khusanov, Reis, Doku, Bobb, McAtee

Buy £:
2x Fullbacks, 2x Centre backs 2x Midfield
 
A couple of years down the line I would love to get a peak into what went about our Rodri DM partner search.
A documentary would be lovely.

We signed Kalvin Phillips. From Day 1 Pep said he is not it. So many questions ?
Who signed him then - who approved him- did anyone saw him play
Why was he signed and did Know

Similarly what happened with Rice/Bellingham/BrunoG

Did Rice ever said yes to us. Did Bellingham ever said yes to us because he looks like a proper douche hence a Madrid player. And his father being Liverpool fan and chatting the history shit about us.
Why was Bruno not signed.

And most importantly Did we sign Matheus Nunes as a favour for Mendes. And how DI’s we ever agreed to overpay for Nunes when we were so hesitant to overpay for Rice.

And then the cherry on top - Signing Gonzales on 3rd of Feb when our BalonD’or winning DM has been injured since 4-5 months.

Intriguing bit of business when signing a CM or CDM almost Spurs like!
 
I looked at the players we had and the players who I believe could genuinely make it from the academy and put this together as squad for 2026-2027.

Where I see the gaps are:

GK - I haven't seen anyone coming through so I think we will have to buy.
LCM - Two extreme talents (IMO) in Mukasa and Gorman but they are both very young.
CF - A backup to Haaland as I suspect that Marmoush may play more of a 10 role or possibly where I have Gorman and Mukasa.

I think that those leaving in the next two years will be KDB/Bernardo/Gundo/Stones/Kovacic and Grealish. I suspect the same will be true of Ake because of injury. If so, Braithwaite steps in.

I haven't found space for Nunes but I do think he is a decent squad member and the same with Akanji.



1738653683596.png
 
I looked at the players we had and the players who I believe could genuinely make it from the academy and put this together as squad for 2026-2027.

Where I see the gaps are:

GK - I haven't seen anyone coming through so I think we will have to buy.
LCM - Two extreme talents (IMO) in Mukasa and Gorman but they are both very young.
CF - A backup to Haaland as I suspect that Marmoush may play more of a 10 role or possibly where I have Gorman and Mukasa.

I think that those leaving in the next two years will be KDB/Bernardo/Gundo/Stones/Kovacic and Grealish. I suspect the same will be true of Ake because of injury. If so, Braithwaite steps in.

I haven't found space for Nunes but I do think he is a decent squad member and the same with Akanji.



View attachment 145468
Looking at that we desperately need a right back, maybe even two, and either a number 10 or back up striker depending on where Marmoush settles.

Hopefully an exciting summer ahead.
 
Both Fullbacks, a keeper and another midfielder along with getting rid of the old guard has to be summers priority.
 
Looking at that we desperately need a right back, maybe even two, and either a number 10 or back up striker depending on where Marmoush settles.

Hopefully an exciting summer ahead.
Though that's true, I did leave out Akanji and Nunes in favour of Lewis and Headley (whom I think is a serious talent).

I forgot Echeverri too.
 
Updated with Echeverri and Akanji.

1738657528400.png

I believe that the U18 team features a number of players with an outstanding opportunity to become top drawer professionals. I'd include Reigan Heskey, Divine Mukasa, Ryan McAidoo, Finlay Gorman, Dante Headley, and Stephen Mfuni. IMO, we need to phase them in over the next three years, or lose them. Braithwaite is another in that crop, in my view.
 
A couple of years down the line I would love to get a peak into what went about our Rodri DM partner search.
A documentary would be lovely.

We signed Kalvin Phillips. From Day 1 Pep said he is not it. So many questions ?
Who signed him then - who approved him- did anyone saw him play
Why was he signed and did Know

Similarly what happened with Rice/Bellingham/BrunoG

Did Rice ever said yes to us. Did Bellingham ever said yes to us because he looks like a proper douche hence a Madrid player. And his father being Liverpool fan and chatting the history shit about us.
Why was Bruno not signed.

And most importantly Did we sign Matheus Nunes as a favour for Mendes. And how DI’s we ever agreed to overpay for Nunes when we were so hesitant to overpay for Rice.

And then the cherry on top - Signing Gonzales on 3rd of Feb when our BalonD’or winning DM has been injured since 4-5 months.

Intriguing bit of business when signing a CM or CDM almost Spurs like!
Weirdest January window ever for city. Really seems like pin the donkey stuff tbf. January should be about plugging obvious holes with A proven prem player or two players max. We should have got that in the summer tbf..Jared Bowen would have been perfect pre injury... 100% player, quick..can genuinely cross a ball for Haaland. Seems lije we went on a bit of a panic spree buying 20 yr olds for 3 years time.. seen that fail many times.
 
Departures
Due to age : KDB, Silva, Gundogan
Due to fitness: Stones,
Due to loss of ability : Akanji, Kovacic,
Grealish.
Just not good enough : Nunes, Lewis

Keep :
Ederson, Ortega, Rodri, Haaland, Dias, Guardiol, Ake, Foden(after a slap)
Savinho, Marmoush, Khusanov, Reis, Doku, Bobb, McAtee

Buy £:
2x Fullbacks, 2x Centre backs 2x Midfield
I can’t see us getting rid of that many players, proven winners and experience. It would cost ridiculous amounts of money to replace and probably a season or two to let basically a new team gel together.

I’d also say that keep list looks pretty weak and lacking in any experience
 
We suddenly have the 4th biggest squad and the 8th youngest in the PL and the World’s most valuable.

No more excuses.



 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top