PistonBlue
Well-Known Member
Will headline the Sunday at Glastonbury 2015 I'm hearing.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The Stone Roses/Ian Brown
- Thread starter PistonBlue
- Start date
billfromthehill
Well-Known Member
Absolutely shite live imo
Chancy Termites
Well-Known Member
billfromthehill said:Absolutely shite live imo
Didn't see them in their heyday but I did go to Heaton Park a couple of years ago. I agree that Ian Brown's not much of a singer but I thought that the rest of the band were good instrumentally, given how long they'd been retired. John Squire's up with the best guitarists around, other than the giants of the early seventies.
billfromthehill said:Absolutely shite live imo
Granted Brown would never win X Factor (is that a bad thing??)
For me, the vibe the Roses create outweighs the "quality" of Ian Brown's vocals.
Squire, Mani and Reni have all been mentioned in the "Manchester Supergroup" thread
101toMR
Well-Known Member
The Stone Roses are no Bee Gees are they?
It's hard to describe bands and music in general as shite.
Unless it's Kanye West that is.
It's hard to describe bands and music in general as shite.
Unless it's Kanye West that is.
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
101toMR said:The Stone Roses are no Bee Gees are they?
It's hard to describe bands and music in general as shite.
Unless it's Kanye West that is.
It would be a tragedy if they were.
Cellarite
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Jan 2010
- Messages
- 26,763
- Team supported
- Manchester City
Whatever happened to their promise of new material?
glad someone else is thinking that , i was starting to think that id dreamt they had said that in their press conference , although the gap between the first album and second coming suggests they dont tend to rush these thingscitykev28 said:Whatever happened to their promise of new material?
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
Mad Eyed Screamer said:stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
The music aside, my opinion of TSR will be forever tarnished by Ian Brown behaving like a complete cock on live TV when the power went out.
He acted like a complete ****. I remember watching it live and feeling embarrassed.
It was somewhat ironic that he shouted "amateurs" considering his voice wasn't even worthy of a spot at the local karaoke venue.
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
stony said:Mad Eyed Screamer said:stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
The music aside, my opinion of TSR will be forever tarnished by Ian Brown behaving like a complete cock on live TV when the power went out.
He acted like a complete c**t. I remember watching it live and feeling embarrassed.
It was somewhat ironic that he shouted "amateurs" considering his voice wasn't even worthy of a spot at the local karaoke venue.
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wK9on_AL-k[/video]
Mad Eyed Screamer said:stony said:Mad Eyed Screamer said:To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
The music aside, my opinion of TSR will be forever tarnished by Ian Brown behaving like a complete cock on live TV when the power went out.
He acted like a complete c**t. I remember watching it live and feeling embarrassed.
It was somewhat ironic that he shouted "amateurs" considering his voice wasn't even worthy of a spot at the local karaoke venue.
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wK9on_AL-k[/video]
Haha, what an utter fucking ****. He was secretly grateful of that power cut, because it spared his blushes from his dogshit vocals.
EL APACHE TEVEZ
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Sep 2008
- Messages
- 23,366
Never liked squire always thought he was a ****, a glorified johnny marr.
carlos tevez is a blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2010
- Messages
- 16,121
stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
I used to like you.
Mad Eyed Screamer said:stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
i actually think second coming is a pretty good album but its judged against the stella first album so was always going to be downgraded
songs like breaking into heaven and tears are great songs in my opinion, most of the madchester vibe had dissipated into a more rockier sound with more squire solos on it
maybe the change of style was too much and thats why its doesn't get the plaudits it could of got
Mad Eyed Screamer
Moderator
tonea2003 said:Mad Eyed Screamer said:stony said:A couple of decent songs and that's it. I honestly don't understand the cult following they have.
To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
i actually think second coming is a pretty good album but its judged against the stella first album so was always going to be downgraded
songs like breaking into heaven and tears are great songs in my opinion, most of the madchester vibe had dissipated into a more rockier sound with more squire solos on it
maybe the change of style was too much and thats why its doesn't get the plaudits it could of got
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLquz4Iz-30[/video]
1 min 25
liamctid
Well-Known Member
Be relatively surprised if they do it. Heard from a decent-ish source that they wouldn't be doing anything ever again last year.
Mad Eyed Screamer said:tonea2003 said:Mad Eyed Screamer said:To be fair, it was a couple of great singles / b sides followed by a fantastic album, Fools Gold and one great song on the 2nd album (Ten Story Love Song)
i actually think second coming is a pretty good album but its judged against the stella first album so was always going to be downgraded
songs like breaking into heaven and tears are great songs in my opinion, most of the madchester vibe had dissipated into a more rockier sound with more squire solos on it
maybe the change of style was too much and thats why its doesn't get the plaudits it could of got
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLquz4Iz-30[/video]
1 min 25
i think you don't agree?
manimanc
Well-Known Member
Go on 'don't stop' roses forum and there's a couple of interesting posts on there regarding the Glastonbury rumours..
If it is true then they must have some new material and an album to follow...
I for one am getting giddy about it, bear in mind when they had their conference for getting back together it only broke on the morning of it, and Michael eavis is supposed to be announcing the Sunday night headliners tomorrow....
Fingers crossed, they have unfinished business.
If it is true then they must have some new material and an album to follow...
I for one am getting giddy about it, bear in mind when they had their conference for getting back together it only broke on the morning of it, and Michael eavis is supposed to be announcing the Sunday night headliners tomorrow....
Fingers crossed, they have unfinished business.