The Tottenham Thread 13/14 part 3.

[MJepsenJensen]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

 

[squirtyflower]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

that tells me everything i need to know about you

 

[Dzeko's Right Boot]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

But do you consider that fair value for Johnson and Jones?

 

[jimharri]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

But do you consider that fair value for Johnson and Jones?

Definitely overpriced.

 

[MJepsenJensen]

The English players market has been inflated, Players like Zaha going for £15 mill

 

[The Pink Panther]

The English players market has been inflated, Players like Zaha going for £15 mill

Only English clubs are interested in English players, so which one, in your opinion, would stump up 20 mill for Walker?

 

[daztrueblue91]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

You lost any credibility you may of had when you post ridiculous shite like this.

There is not a single aspect in which Vertonghen is better than Kompany. I get that your a Spurs fan and are biased but your comment is the equivalent of me saying that I value Aguero more than Messi. There are only 3 or 4 genuine world class CB's and Kompany is one of them. Don't get me wrong I do rate Vertonghen and think he is a very good CB but he is nowhere near the level you think he is.

 

[BlueHammer85]

A bit of spare time to kill before the game against Villa, Values of our 1st team (Currently)

Lloris - £30 million (Top 3 GK in the world)

Walker - £20 million (Young, English and RB's are rare)
Vertonghen - £30 million (One of the best in the world)
Dawson - £7 million (Solid PL centre back)
Rose - £9 million (England U21 Left back, Was Sunderland POTY)

Paulinho - £30 million (Very good, Frank Lampard ghosting ability and better than Fernandinho IMO)
Dembele - £17 million (Fantastic player but injury prone)

Townsend - £27 million (21 year old England international)
Eriksen - £25 million (21 and a class act, Was cheap due to his contract)
Sigurdsson - £15 million (Scores goals from midfield and has lots of ability)

Soldado - £18 million (Dropped and needs to improve)

Subs:
Capoue - £19 million (Immense, Strong and like Kompany in a defensive midfield role)
Lamela - £20 million (Dropped and needs to improve)
Defoe - £10 million (Guarantees PL survival, Like Darren Bent but he is old)
Chadli - £5 million (Been crap but plays for Belgium so a decent player and he's young)
Sandro - £20 million (Low value due to injury issues)
Adebayor - £5 million (Wages too high but a good player on his day)
Vlad Chiriches - £8 million (Romanian hero and one for the future)

Squad Value: 325 million

Yet lost and got absolutly battered to a west ham team less than your evaluation of Kyle Walker

Priceless

 

[jimharri]

Phil Jones went for something like £17 million, Glen Johnson went for £18 million so Walker being English and one of the best right back's for England and being only 23, £20 million isn't a bad price.

As for Lloris's price tag, £30 million is a fair price I feel and Monaco and PSG would pay that in an instance if Hugo was interested in going back to France and Lloris's style is unique and it would suit Barcelona down to the ground.

As for Kompany and Vertonghen, I rate them roughly the same but Kompany with an edge due to his PL experience but Vertonghen being a year younger and his body being stronger along with being a left footed centre back; I would give Jan the higher price tag.

I also forgot some other players in my squad list such as Germany U21 captain Lewis Holtby who I would value around £15 million due to his age and potential ability, He was the standout player in the U21 Euro championships.

You lost any credibility you may of had when you post ridiculous shite like this.

There is not a single aspect in which Vertonghen is better than Kompany. I get that your a Spurs fan and are biased but your comment is the equivalent of me saying that I value Aguero more than Messi. There are only 3 or 4 genuine world class CB's and Kompany is one of them. Don't get me wrong I do rate Vertonghen and think he is a very good CB but he is nowhere near the level you think he is.

Spot on. Vertonghen is the best CB at Spurs (not that difficult, to be fair). But better than Kompany? Seriously? I think not.

 

[JoeMercer'sWay]

As I did a honest appraisal of the Spurs "squad" the guy put up and came out at £227.5m, I thought I'd return the favour with our squad and see how much bias rains through:

Hart-£25m.
Panty-£4m.

Zabaleta-£12-15m.
Richards-£8-12m.
Kompany-£40m.
Nastasic-£14-18m.
Clichy-£7-10m.
Kolarov-£6-10m.
Lescott-£2-4m.
Demichelis-£1-2m.

Rodwell-£6-10m.
Milner-£12-14m.
Yaya-£25-30m.
Fernandinho-£16-20m.
Nasri-£18-21m.
Silva-£25-30m.
Navas-£14-16m.
Garcia-£7-10m.

Aguero-£45m.
Dzeko-£25m.
Negredo-£18-22m.
Jovetic-£20-25m.
Guidetti-£5-8m.

That comes out at a max value of £416m, compared to the £227.5m of Spurs. He used 18 players, I used 23, which makes the average values out to be £18.1m for City and £12.6m for Spurs. Just considering the bargaining power we have over players like Kompany, Silva, Hart and Aguero I think we can a higher fee than anything Spurs can get for their players. If you took the estimations out for those 4 & Yaya, you end up with a value of £246m, which is £13.7m per player, much closer to Spurs and that's for maximum valuations imo.