Tim Burgess

[Joycee Banercheck]

Still better than Oasis (in my opinion anyway).

Have to agree.

Even the instrumentals are better than Oasis' offerings...in my eyes/ears

 

[peoffrey]

The Charlies weren't from Manc until they got the new guitarist involved (Mark?), and he's a red. Still better than Oasis (in my opinion anyway).

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

The Charlies weren't from Manc until they got the new guitarist involved (Mark?), and he's a red. Still better than Oasis (in my opinion anyway).

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

So we move Manchester's boundaries? I'm not in there. I can also say that I have heard both and that the Charlatans shit all over Oasis, just as Blur did.

 

[peoffrey]

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

So we move Manchester's boundaries? I'm not in there. I can also say that I have heard both and that the Charlatans shit all over Oasis, just as Blur did.

I didn't say that. I didn't even suggest it. Is Tim Burgess supposed to support Northwich Victoria or something? I've got Lads from Oldham and Bolton next to me at City.

Blur also did alot of great stuff but The Charlatans are little more than tag alongs who were every Indie Kids 7th favourite bands. Their albums aren't classics.

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

So we move Manchester's boundaries? I'm not in there. I can also say that I have heard both and that the Charlatans shit all over Oasis, just as Blur did.

I didn't say that. I didn't even suggest it. Is Tim Burgess supposed to support Northwich Victoria or something? I've got Lads from Oldham and Bolton next to me at City.

Blur also did alot of great stuff but The Charlatans are little more than tag alongs who were every Indie Kids 7th favourite bands. Their albums aren't classics.

Sorry no, you didn't. But I don't class any Oasis album as a classic either. They're a bit shit apart from Def Maybe. This aint a 'who's cock's bigger' thread, I just think that charlatans songs mean something more, sound better and live longer. To me anyway.

 

[Carstairs]

I just think that charlatans songs mean something more, sound better and live longer. To me anyway.

And me.

 

[mekonmcfc]

The Charlies weren't from Manc until they got the new guitarist involved (Mark?), and he's a red. Still better than Oasis (in my opinion anyway).

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

Ian Brown moved to timperley when he was young. That's where he met squire

Similar to saying Jay-k is from Stretford. His mum went into labour whilst at a gig I think.

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

So we move Manchester's boundaries? I'm not in there. I can also say that I have heard both and that the Charlatans shit all over Oasis, just as Blur did.

I didn't say that. I didn't even suggest it. Is Tim Burgess supposed to support Northwich Victoria or something? I've got Lads from Oldham and Bolton next to me at City.

Blur also did alot of great stuff but The Charlatans are little more than tag alongs who were every Indie Kids 7th favourite bands. Their albums aren't classics.

I can't say anything without sounding condescending, and that is the last thing I want to do, but just listen to a few Charliues albums from start to fin, then a few Oasis ones and then decide who's put a bit of thought into it and who's after cashing in. And Blur never cashed in, they kept going and doing what they do.

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZI1BQzY-nU[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rl0BGpbrsO8[/youtube]
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itOlgJBsSeY[/youtube]
(soz - opportunity always gets me stopped)

And that's off one album. Just a few tag alongs off one of their 900 albums...

 

[Joycee Banercheck]

The Charlies weren't from Manc until they got the new guitarist involved (Mark?), and he's a red. Still better than Oasis (in my opinion anyway).

Isn't Tim Burgess from Northwich or somewhere? It's only down the road. People easily forget Ian Brown is from Warrington.

The Charlatans aren't better than Oasis. I've heard almost everything they've done and not one of their albums is a patch on Definitely Maybe or Morning Glory. They've got some killer songs but they're pretty much a singles band to me.

Ian Brown moved to timperley when he was young. That's where he met squire

Similar to saying Jay-k is from Stretford. His mum went into labour whilst at a gig I think.

I think you missed my point, bud. But good looking out.

In fact, I may have missed YOUR point. But good looking out all the same!