Saddleworth2
Well-Known Member
I'm a Tolkien fan and struggled with it. Still only three episodes into series 2.If you're not a Tolkien fan you will probably won't like it! Loved season one and I'll be starting season 2 soon
So whats good?
The visuals are pretty stunning and a shit load of money has been spent
Its good to see some of the Silmarillion 'come to life' .
Whats bad?
overlapping and confused storyline
dialogue (what say you my commander of the north armies - probably consistent with Tolkien at his worst but still..)
miscasting (difficult when you have such clear ideas from the book and films)
A brave attempt but no better than 5/10