One of the things I find so intriguing about United post-Ferguson is they almost always hire a manager at the wrong time.
Mourinho would have been a success IMO if he was appointed after Ferguson. He comes in an dominates a club from top to bottom just like Ferguson did at United. He would have gotten the best out of that old squad and bullied Woodward into making the signings he wanted, not dawdled like Moyes who'd never spent big before.
Moyes would have been a success if he'd come after someone like Mourinho or van Gaal to calm things down.
van Gaal I actually think was a great appointment but they still had such delusions of grandeur that they bailed on him before his rebuild was complete and then they threw 2 years of work away by going for the complete opposite in Mourinho. So the timing was wrong. If he'd come in 2018 then I think United would be contenders by now.
It seems really apparent to everyone except United that what they need right now is a massive name with huge authority to control the egos in the dressing room and win now. Conte, Zidane etc.
Brendan Rodgers is clearly not that person. Rodgers is the guy you hire in 18 months when Conte has come in done well and fucked off. Or he's the guy you hire 2 years ago to build.
He's not going to come into a dressing room and make them win immediately while Ronaldo, Pogba and Varane are there. He doesn't have the necessary status to make someone like Ronaldo put the team before himself, or bench him.
It would be a terrible move for everyone, I hope he can resist it for his sake because the money, and chance to manage someone like Ronaldo and another chance at a giant club might be too appealing for him, especially with Leicester looking like this might be a year where progress stalls.