Var debate 2019/20

cleavers said:
Many flagged it though, many.


....and it shouldn't, but worse still is fiddling with it every week to respond to the outcry its getting, and now discussions about changing the laws (in some cases rightly) to suit VAR.

The tail wagging the dog !
Click to expand...
Yep they did,i argued the toss for months with @greasedupdeafguy i tagged him ages ago to say he was right,it's very disappointing how fucked up it is
 
karen7 said:
That was sky's line that took the 30 mins to make up,it is not a var check,a statement was put out during the game that var had checked it,it was given in a few secs which is not possible for a full var check,the won't show us the check and it was every bit as close as the ones in other games,they were caught in a lie
Click to expand...
That is fair and I don't disagree with any of that.

I posted the pic in response to someone asking for lines, trying to prove that even with lines you can make it conflicting depending on angles. In my opinion, he is well onside. But I shouldn't have acted like it was as obvious as I said it was. I definitely agree that a real VAR check was sorely missing in this instance, and I admitted to that.

My original point is that VAR being "bent" or "corrupt" shouldn't be the main narrative on this forum. People should be allowed to think that, but people that doesn't see it that way, shouldn't have to answer to wum accusations in every discussion they take part in. In my opinion VAR has been a farce. Not because of corruption, because as I have said I don't see any evidence for it. And no one on this forum has evidence, they just have a strong opinion they won't move away from. And that is fine. But I rather read discussions on how to make var better than the same comments about everyone getting favored over us everytime.
 
give it to gordon said:
How about it's only of side if the part of the body that scored the goal is off side ?!. So a players arm pit is off side but the foot he scored with is on side , ......or should I just go back to the sherry hic !
Click to expand...

All the theories of what should and shouldnt be offside are redundant because technology cant absolutely say when the ball left the passers foot.
so daylight, feet only, whatever, it doesnt matter because they have no idea when the ball was passed
 
marcus said:
All the theories of what should and shouldnt be offside are redundant because technology cant absolutely say when the ball left the passers foot.
so daylight, feet only, whatever, it doesnt matter because they have no idea when the ball was passed
Click to expand...

This 100% as Gallagher said yesterday they cant say when the ball started its pass !! I am surprised there hasn't been more made of this in the press after he said that !
 
meltonblue said:
That is how it should look against the grass though
Click to expand...
I think the point really is it was as tight as others that have had the full var treatment,they said they did it,won't produce it with the time stamp and sky took 30 mins to produce their own line which can't be proved to be correct,that and the handball oliver didn't see(bad habit when reffing us) the game stunk,they have the tech,they didn't use it and lied about it,we sent in an official complaint about that game,we are not a club to do something like that,i'm sick of them lying,not to mention the head of var calling rodders a diver,they want a history club to win the title this year,pep and the players have hinted they know they score,we might never have won it this year but i'm betting with pep having done it before we stood a reasonable chance
I'm getting paranoid!

giphy.gif
 
cleavers said:
Many flagged it though, many.


....and it shouldn't, but worse still is fiddling with it every week to respond to the outcry its getting, and now discussions about changing the laws (in some cases rightly) to suit VAR.

The tail wagging the dog !
Click to expand...

Agree.

Best case scenario I can see is that we are stuck with it for this season, and it is fucked off at the end. However, I doubt they will want the dippers' win to be so obviously tainted.
 
ScottSinclair said:
Trust me, while I might be wrong about what I write, i'm pretty fucking far from looking like the most stupid poster in these discussions[/QUOTE]

I beg to differ..!

You are coming across as arguing black is white for the sake of it..

All becoming a bit tiresome..

I'm right, I'm right, I'm right..! Fucking laughable..!

You've been called out on Salads offside and shown up for Eric's handball.!

You seem to be up the dippers arse regarding anything VAR related..

Did you go to the match yesterday?

Good win for your boys, looks like you're winning it this year..!
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.