Var debate 2019/20

[Blue Maverick]

Who called for Llorenetes goal to be looked at? If it was the VAR ref then he must have seen the angle where it hit his arm, if he did then why wasn’t that shown to the ref? If he didn’t then why would he tell the ref to look At It? If it was the ref who called it was it because of the City protests? If that’s the case he is been led by the players.

 

[purplenose]

I don't agree.

I have seen a lot of offsides called for the same situation without VAR. A player, offside at the moment of the pass, who is tracking back (and don't really benefit from his offside position) is still considered offside when he receives the ball.

Its probably the offside rule that needs looking at.

 

[BlueRockape]

Not offside unless you are in the eighteen yard box would stop a lot of shit

 

[Scaring Europe to Death]

One thing that occurred to me today.

How many times does the linesman flag for offside in open play, and then the cameras prove that he was wrong?
Usually the game has already stopped, but what would happen if the striker (Sterling today on the half way line from an Ederson clearance) just carried on and shot past the keeper, before asking the referee to check with VAR?

 

[The Black Shed]

Anyone else think the PL table next season will look so different to the normal mix of 6? VAR going to have a big say in top and bottom places

 

[moon]

Who called for Llorenetes goal to be looked at? If it was the VAR ref then he must have seen the angle where it hit his arm, if he did then why wasn’t that shown to the ref? If he didn’t then why would he tell the ref to look At It? If it was the ref who called it was it because of the City protests? If that’s the case he is been led by the players.

We were saying today
There must have been some doubt by the VAR ref as this was the only VAR incident the match ref reviewed

 

[cyberblue]

Var is good if used corectly ie a clear obvious mistake .not at every little nit picking incident

 

[MillionMilesAway]

One thing that occurred to me today.

How many times does the linesman flag for offside in open play, and then the cameras prove that he was wrong?
Usually the game has already stopped, but what would happen if the striker (Sterling today on the half way line from an Ederson clearance) just carried on and shot past the keeper, before asking the referee to check with VAR?

I think the point is more that the linesman's flag only makes a difference if the ref blows his whistle.
Until then, it's play on.

At the moment, the ref will usually blow when he sees the flag, although occasionally he will overrule, e.g. if he thinks it came off a defending player and the linesman is wrong.

 

[Parisian]

Hi Pidge/frank ?

Please enlight me. Who are these people ?

Anyway, hi bluealf.

 

[old blue]

This Rossetti edict will it be open to interpretation or written in stone.:-)