Var debate 2019/20

domalino said:
It doesn't matter.

As long as both teams are treated the same, then no one gets an advantage, no one has a better chance of getting through.

Last season Aguero's header could have been ruled out, but that's irrelevant because just as likely the linesman could have flagged wrongly and we'd have missed out on a goal we would have got with VAR.
Click to expand...
Both teams can be treated fairly and a mistake can still happen which var could intervene.

Imagine you have a fair and balanced ref who has a great game but sheff wed score a blatant offside goal that gets missed by the ref and linesman and end up winning the match because of it, you won't be bothered because you both have the same advantage/disadvantage.

I'd be pretty pissed off if we got knocked out by a goal that would have certainly been overturned if var was in place.

If the Shrews goal at Anfield was scored at their ground there's a good chance we lose that game or end up going to extra time and possibly pens.
 
Len Rum said:
Experts 'in the know' take great pride in informing us that VAR doesn't rule on goalkeepers being off their line when spot kicks are taken.
As we've been on the wrong end of this twice recently can anyone tell me WHY?
This is one area in which VAR would seem ideally suited to make a ruling on.
Click to expand...

I just cannot understand why a clear aspect of the LotG are ignored when VAR can deliver the answer immediately. How we get a retake in the West Ham game when the first to the ball infringed the distance rule, but goalkeepers are immune to the idea that that can't come off their line. Mind, it's goalkeepers who also seem immune to any sanction re gross time wasting. All part and parcel of the institutionalised cheating,
 
Len Rum said:
Experts 'in the know' take great pride in informing us that VAR doesn't rule on goalkeepers being off their line when spot kicks are taken.
As we've been on the wrong end of this twice recently can anyone tell me WHY?
This is one area in which VAR would seem ideally suited to make a ruling on.
Click to expand...

I thought I read the reason why VAR isnt used to see if keepers are of their line is that VAR cant be 100% sure when the ball is hit. Sure that what Gallagher said, or one of them
 
DeludedRed said:
Both teams can be treated fairly and a mistake can still happen which var could intervene.

Imagine you have a fair and balanced ref who has a great game but sheff wed score a blatant offside goal that gets missed by the ref and linesman and end up winning the match because of it, you won't be bothered because you both have the same advantage/disadvantage.

I'd be pretty pissed off if we got knocked out by a goal that would have certainly been overturned if var was in place.

If the Shrews goal at Anfield was scored at their ground there's a good chance we lose that game or end up going to extra time and possibly pens.
Click to expand...

Yeah it would be annoying but it is fair as both teams are as likely to benefit or suffer from it.
 
domalino said:
Yeah it would be annoying but it is fair as both teams are as likely to benefit or suffer from it.
Click to expand...
Fair enough mate, I personally think it should be at all or none.

I'll tell you what I think we really should have in every ground with var though, just for offsides.

I think there should be a small camera attached to the advertising hoardings every 5 to 10 cm pointing straight across the pitch which can be individually displayed for both the kicker and attacking/defensive line.

So for instance all at exactly the same time, find the moment the ball is passed and then call up the nearest camera to the attacking player at the exact same time.

Surely we have enough money to do something like that.
 
Len Rum said:
Experts 'in the know' take great pride in informing us that VAR doesn't rule on goalkeepers being off their line when spot kicks are taken.
As we've been on the wrong end of this twice recently can anyone tell me WHY?
This is one area in which VAR would seem ideally suited to make a ruling on.
Click to expand...

As it's a dead ball situation and theres two men on the line as well as the ref overseeing the event live they should get a better overall view than a camera (hear the ball being struck while watching the keeper) , any still I've seen of the Keeper being off the line for the Gundogan penalty the ball has already been hit so they might actually have got it ritht?
 
DeludedRed said:
Fair enough mate, I personally think it should be at all or none.

I'll tell you what I think we really should have in every ground with var though, just for offsides.

I think there should be a small camera attached to the advertising hoardings every 5 to 10 cm pointing straight across the pitch which can be individually displayed for both the kicker and attacking/defensive line.

So for instance all at exactly the same time, find the moment the ball is passed and then call up the nearest camera to the attacking player at the exact same time.

Surely we have enough money to do something like that.
Click to expand...
Every 5 to 10 cm?
How long do you think it will take those sat in the viewing room to go through all that?
You really are a deluded red! Lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.