VAR Discussion Thread

Offside should be subjective and the only question should be whether the attacker is gaining a clear advantage by being in an offside position.

An attacker whose big toe is just in front of the last-but-one man's elbow is not gaining a clear advantage. Even if someone isn't in an offside position when the ball is played could have been gaining an advantage if they were waiting well upfield while play developed but were just behind the ball when it was last played.
 
"BBC Sport understands that the discrepancy lies in the choice of frame by the broadcaster.

The VAR selected the frame when Bradley first made contact with the ball, not when it left his foot.

The broadcaster froze the picture one frame later which gave the impression Wirtz was more obviously offside."

Sure sure. When you can select the frame, it's just another chance to manipulate a result. Honestly, it's seemingly impossible to ruin something so fucking good as football - and yet here they are...
Another BS quote that Ive never heard of before in our game "semi auto offside didnt work because of too many players in the box" wtaf ??
 
Both Haaland and arsenal player deemed to be offside but, in our case, they claim Haaland was interfering in play
BBC article suggests Jared Giblet on VAR last night didn't dally in his decision, maybe in view of what happened the night before,so....
Switch the games, so Gooners played Tues, and both goals the same - bet the 2 decisions would've been exactly as they panned out
 
A subjective, human based decision will always be that, whether it's in real time or slowed down. Video replays maybe provide more evidence but slowing things down sometimes over exaggerates contact. VAR (should) help with the more factual decisions, like ball crossing the line and offsides (within a small degree of tolerance).

Although there are more natural breaks in these sports, football should maybe follow the example in cricket and the NFL, that the coaches / captains should have (say 2) number of VAR appeals per half. Once they are used up, everyone has to abide by the on-field decisions.

IMO this endless checking has destroyed the natural flow of the sport and even with the VAR, we still get outrageous cock-ups.

It works seamlessly with a very high degree of accuracy in, Rugby, Tennis and Rugby. But none of those sports have remotely the same level money bet on outcomes of there events.
 
Offside should be subjective and the only question should be whether the attacker is gaining a clear advantage by being in an offside position.

An attacker whose big toe is just in front of the last-but-one man's elbow is not gaining a clear advantage. Even if someone isn't in an offside position when the ball is played could have been gaining an advantage if they were waiting well upfield while play developed but were just behind the ball when it was last played.

Whereas coming in so recklessly as to threaten a players ability to walk again is okay if the shot has already been taken.
 
From BBC and The Guardian

"SAOT technology uses in-stadium cameras to build a live picture of the position of players on the field, before generating a 3D image that can be used by video assistant referees to assess offside calls. It is understood the system, the same as used in the Premier League, was unable to locate the position of the ball in the buildup to the Semenyo goal because it was obscured by surrounding players. Without a 3D image, VAR operatives were forced to revert to manually applying offside lines to video footage"

Did the BBC really say that? As I understand it the "3d" image is just for show after the event. SAOT chooses the frame and draws lines and that is what is checked by VAR. Unless I am wrong, which can happen :)

It would be madness to determine offside on a recreation when they have the actual images in front of them, wouldn't it?
 
Did the BBC really say that? As I understand it the "3d" image is just for show after the event. SAOT chooses the frame and draws lines and that is what is checked by VAR. Unless I am wrong, which can happen :)

It would be madness to determine offside on a recreation when they have the actual images in front of them, wouldn't it?

"It took more than five minutes for a check to determine that Erling Haaland was offside and had interfered with play by holding defender Malick Thiaw, with referee Chris Kavanagh disallowing what would have been a second goal of the night for City’s new signing Antoine Semenyo.

The Press Association news agency understands the check would have been significantly quicker if semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) had been available, but the number of bodies in the box at the time of the incident meant it could not be used.

Officials instead had to revert to the old system of drawing crosshairs because of the number of bodies in the box. The Premier League website refers to such incidents where SAOT cannot be used as “edge cases”.
 
"It took more than five minutes for a check to determine that Erling Haaland was offside and had interfered with play by holding defender Malick Thiaw, with referee Chris Kavanagh disallowing what would have been a second goal of the night for City’s new signing Antoine Semenyo.

The Press Association news agency understands the check would have been significantly quicker if semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) had been available, but the number of bodies in the box at the time of the incident meant it could not be used.

Officials instead had to revert to the old system of drawing crosshairs because of the number of bodies in the box. The Premier League website refers to such incidents where SAOT cannot be used as “edge cases”.
I have a better term . Complete cock up cases .

If the technology is not fit for purpose with an incident just say so at the time and the in field decision stands

What really pisses me off is the immediate impact of the disallowed goal on subsequent games . There's a media shitstorm ( especially if you play in red ) meaning that next time something similar happens , in this case the very next night , the referee / VAR awards a goal. without delay . Fans understandably call out the inconsistency and loose faith in the whole system .

The reaction by referees is driven by outrage from the media instead of proper scrutiny and review in the cold light of day. That's no way to improve a system or review it's limitations .

I can't help but think the VAR team are heavily influenced by the commentator in real time and by the media afterwards .
 
The BBC being extremely disingenuous (to put it politely) to suggest that the Haaland offside was "technically correct." It was a subjective offside decision and therefore cannot be stated as being objectively correct, technically or otherwise
Let’s assume that it was ‘technically correct’. That must mean that the Arsenal goal last night was ‘technically incorrect’ but I’ve not seen that anywhere…
 
BBC article suggests Jared Giblet on VAR last night didn't dally in his decision, maybe in view of what happened the night before,so....
Switch the games, so Gooners played Tues, and both goals the same - bet the 2 decisions would've been exactly as they panned out
Mind you Gillet has previous for just picking up his money and not really doing his job looking at the VAR screen.
 
Offside should be subjective and the only question should be whether the attacker is gaining a clear advantage by being in an offside position.

An attacker whose big toe is just in front of the last-but-one man's elbow is not gaining a clear advantage. Even if someone isn't in an offside position when the ball is played could have been gaining an advantage if they were waiting well upfield while play developed but were just behind the ball when it was last played.
This is where I get confused
Fans - why is VAR calling offside on a toenail? It's supposed to be for clear and obvious errors
PiGMOL - offside is a matter of fact therefore clear and obvious doesn't apply
VAR - we can't really tell if Alfies lad is offside ref, can you have a ganders at the telly and make a subjective decision
Ref - Oh OK (thinks - I'll give him off cos VAR must think he is to ask me to check, even though I gave the goal in the first place)
Fans - wait a minute, if it's a subjective decision, then surely clear and obvious applies?
PiGMOL - ...........................
 
"It took more than five minutes for a check to determine that Erling Haaland was offside and had interfered with play by holding defender Malick Thiaw, with referee Chris Kavanagh disallowing what would have been a second goal of the night for City’s new signing Antoine Semenyo.

The Press Association news agency understands the check would have been significantly quicker if semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) had been available, but the number of bodies in the box at the time of the incident meant it could not be used.

Officials instead had to revert to the old system of drawing crosshairs because of the number of bodies in the box. The Premier League website refers to such incidents where SAOT cannot be used as “edge cases”.

Yes, that's fair enough. The technology struggles when there are too many limbs in the same place. I remember one in Holland where they attached a defender's leg onto an attacker and then said the attacker was offside.....

I was questioning whether the BBC said the VAR makes the offside decision based on the simulation rather than the actual images. Dale Johnson may be a complete referee patsy but he generally understands what happens.
 
"It took more than five minutes for a check to determine that Erling Haaland was offside and had interfered with play by holding defender Malick Thiaw, with referee Chris Kavanagh disallowing what would have been a second goal of the night for City’s new signing Antoine Semenyo.

The Press Association news agency understands the check would have been significantly quicker if semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) had been available, but the number of bodies in the box at the time of the incident meant it could not be used.

Officials instead had to revert to the old system of drawing crosshairs because of the number of bodies in the box. The Premier League website refers to such incidents where SAOT cannot be used as “edge cases”.
Who knew when a team would be attacking there’d be lots of bodies in the box! What a total farce
 
Tribalism and paranoia aside, the initial attraction of VAR was that it would increase consistency and remove the whole concept of "these poor decisions balance out over a season" which we all knew was bollocks anyway
It was part of an understanding that the good fortune of referee decisions might come around if you show toughness when there is a bad decision against you, that how you conduct yourself on the pitch is important. The saying was said to describe how many times bad decisions might even out over the course of a season. It's not meant to be taken literally, as in it always evens out, which I'm guessing is what you mean by bollocks, i.e. there's been times it hasn't surely. But that it's a valuable saying to take a step back from every decision and understand that it would have a tendency to swing back and forth throughout a season. That if you add up all the bad decisions against you and for they might be even or close to even by the end of the season. That's the idea anyway, and most of the time it work out that way, to some extent at least.

Of course all this has been turned on its head with VAR but the idea that poor decisions even out over the course of a seasons, there's plenty of empirical evidence to support this. There's plenty of seasons when a team was hard done in one match but then benefitted from a decision in other matches or even in that same match.

To your larger point, what VAR set out to do has not only not happened, but they've made everything worse. It really is a wonder this still exists, as fed up with it as everyone is. They've made such an investment in it and spread it around the world, it's been the wrong kind of investment. But the longer this goes, the complaints over VAR's use and application will continue to grow. It's an ever present problem.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top