VAR Discussion Thread

Why does Pep complain and throw tantrums like the red cunts at Emirates Anfield and Rags. I have this problem from quite some time now. The rashford goal the red card in the FA cup this , the tackle on Foden and now this. Also the VAR goal from the newcastle game.

We need to tell people how its not fit for purpose. Every single fucking day. We are already cheats and corrupt. What loss it would be if we started becoming the victims.
Worked out fine for all the red scums.
 
Glancing, eh? So basically it wasn’t going to be red unless Doku needed to be stretchered off and out for 15 months



Funny it wasnt glancing the only thing it was wasn’t a player running in doing that but when has that stopped var not giving a red? They’ve been going of still frames all season that still frame is 100% a red! Always the way when it’s us they come up with any bollocks to not give a pen or not a red or it’s offside
 
Funny it wasnt glancing the only thing it was wasn’t a player running in doing that but when has that stopped var not giving a red? They’ve been going of still frames all season that still frame is 100% a red! Always the way when it’s us they come up with any bollocks to not give a pen or not a red or it’s offside
'Deemed to be glancing'?

Watch Dalot's eyes light up. He has zero intent in getting the ball. 100% focussed on putting a reducer on Doku and knew he'd get away with it. Straight leg on the knee, with force. How can it be 'glancing' when you can see Doku's leg buckle on contact?

We are 100% being fucked over.
 
The Sky Sports panel and Mike Dean all can't believe that Dalot got away with a yellow. Craig Pawson on VAR another dodgy **** not recommending another look at that shocking assault
How often do Taylor or Oliver get called to rage screen?
 
This is the official rule… VAR decided it wasn’t excessive force. The rule says a red card can be given for endangering the safety of an opponent. They chose the wrong rule.

SERIOUS FOUL PLAY

A tackle or challenge that endangers the safety of an opponent or uses excessive force or brutality must be sanctioned as serious foul play.

Any player who lunges at an opponent in challenging for the ball from the front, from the side or from behind using one or both legs, with excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is guilty of serious foul play.
 
Interesting that you use the NFL as a comparison because the NFL have used one version of 'VAR' or another for 40 years. Yet apart from one experimental season, when it was then quickly dropped,


Listen towards the end of the video as to why it was scrapped after the 1991 season. The same thing that happened in 1991 in the NFL should happen with VAR. Essentially it was an owners vote year after year as part of the agreement, they became fed up with it and scrapped it. It stayed scrapped until 1999 in which they implemented the coaches challenge system. I just think it's interesting with this first go around of NFL instant replay was scrapped after 6 seasons, and stayed scrapped for longer than it existed after it was scrapped, only to be repackaged as a challenge system with set guidelines for when "replay officials" (VARers) can interfere. (within the last 2 minutes of a half, at which point the coaches can't challenge)

they do not use video replay on pass interference calls. Coaches can't challenge PI, and although there are some technicalities when it's not strictly true, generally speaking, the video review booth do not get involved in PI. Whatever the call made on the field, stands.
That is true, except in the 2019 season, when for one season only, pass interference was reviewed. It was not retained in the 2020 season.

The reason for this is that PI is the one call in the game that is the most subjective. When two players are fighting for the ball, there is nearly always contact by both players on the other. In a high number of incidents you could make a case for a foul either way, or not at all and have evidence to support it. The NFL feels that by allowing video officials to get involved in PI, you'd simply be replacing one man's subjective view with another man's subjective view. So they choose to leave the call solely to the on field officials.

I'm sure it won't happen, but it would be nice if football could maybe consider learning some lessons from that.
The comparisons between the NFL's use of video replay and the Premier Leagues is unavoidable. However the current VAR situation is more similar in design to the NFL's first go around of video replay between 1986-1991 that was scrapped. Think about that for a moment. The system the NFL has been using since 1999 is a coaches challenge system which is much better received. The American NCAA (NFL Jr. these days) uses a system more similar to VAR, in which the on-field officials (generally) decide what to review (it's very vague and unclear what is reviewed, which is another problem there, sound familiar) rather than a coaches challenge system like the NFL.

So if we're going to be making comparisons between the NFL video review system to VAR in the Premier League, it's important to keep in mind that the NCAA system is more comparable to what is going on in the PL. There are nuanced differences. The NFL coaches challenge system, not relying on VAR-style interventions but coaches challenges, are all reviewed and decided in a central hub in New York, there's no on-field review. Whereas in NCAA (NFL Jr) the Instant Replay Official makes decisions in a secure booth in the stadium (often with input from a conference hub).

As a side note my personal favorite system is Japan's baseball system (NPB) in which decisions are made entirely by the on-field umpires at the stadium, in an area behind home plate. There is no input from a central hub like VAR or the NFL. This may change in the future, but that's how it's been working for many years now.

But to your larger point about football and VAR learning from video replay in the NFL and NCAA, yeah they sure can, like what not to do. Even though NFL and American football is better suited for video review than football, it's still problematic and has caused a lot of problems. In fact, the use of video replay, in both NFL and NCAA, has coincided with major negative changes to each sport, that even go far beyond what VAR has done to football.

It's a very nuanced issue because on the one hand it would be easy to blame the American model for VAR's introduction, on the other hand, VAR was not implemented into football by the Americans, and VAR is in my estimation far more distruptive to football than to American football. Still video replay, was quite disruptive to both the NFL and NCAA Football in America, and the NFL in particular had their first go around scrapped. The excuse there was the older analog TVs, now we have HDs. That's part of the problem with the HDTV. It made sports leagues push for video review, whether it's tennis, TMO in Rugby, the NFL, NCAA, etc etc etc while each of those models have their share of issues, none of those are as disruptive to those respective sports as VAR is to football. But many of the lessons from the failures of those attempts at it (some better than others) can absolutely be used to address the problems of VAR. And frankly many of these glaring issues were foreseen by anyone who even watches the NFL or NCAA occasionally. It's many of those issues combined by the more disruptive aspect of VAR given football's continuous and flowing nature rather than the stop-start style sports like NFL or Rugby.
 
Another game and yet another example of the blatant inconsistencies of the decisions made by officials employed by PiGMOL.

VAR producing a "questionable explanation" for upholding the decision made by the on-fleld referee.

A foul, which in the eyes of many commentators watching the incident, and stating their belief of it being a red card offence, is undermined by the on-field referee's decision which subsequently is upheld by the VAR operative.

So in effect, PiGMOL officials continue to "monitor their own actions", and yet such incidents fail to result in it being called out, and serious questions being raised regarding the organisation, impartiality and integrity of the organisation.
 
When I saw the challenge in real time and the yellow card, for a second I thought thank fuck, VAR will see that the correct decision is made. Fucking lol
I knew they wouldn’t send him off just like I knew Henderson wouldn’t go in the final just like I knew Semenyo’s would be disallowed just like I knew the Fernandes goal a few years ago would be given……the list is endless and it’s clear what is going on. Pep alluded to the club knowing the other day. This isn’t tin foil hat stuff,it’s happening.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top