Didn't they do the same earlier in the season at OT? Ronaldo (the Savior) came on and with Brighton leading 1-2 they were denied an obvious penalty for a push on Welbeck.
VAR thread 2022/23
- Thread starter Ric
- Start date
- Status
metalblue
Well-Known Member
Just a reminder, this wasn't given.
At the other end …. that’s given
Gorton_Tubster
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 16,362
- Location
- Riding the blue tidal wave.
- Team supported
- Manchester City
There's no question about it. Though VAR has made us question it, doubt it, be confused, believe their interpretation of it.
VAR has allowed them to find stuff, (or ignore it).
With no VAR utd are not getting that penalty!
We're probably not getting our penalty. But
It feels fairer even though that might be wrong.
So let’s get it right….
VAR was bought in so that if the ball hits someone on the finger tips who isn’t looking at it, doesn’t mean it intentionally and doesn’t prevent any chance on goal you can give a penalty as it’s ‘clear and obvious’
Whereas if a player deliberately kicks another player with no attempt to play the ball and prevents the player having a shot on goal inside the area then it’s ‘not clear and obvious’
Also if a player goes in studs up and over the ball on the ankle of another player in a dangerous manner and the ref gives the free kick the wrong way….it still isn’t classed as clear and obvious
The only thing in the FA cup final that was ‘clear and obvious’ was the incompetent (blatant cheating) VAR official
But Because we win it gets ignored again
VAR was bought in so that if the ball hits someone on the finger tips who isn’t looking at it, doesn’t mean it intentionally and doesn’t prevent any chance on goal you can give a penalty as it’s ‘clear and obvious’
Whereas if a player deliberately kicks another player with no attempt to play the ball and prevents the player having a shot on goal inside the area then it’s ‘not clear and obvious’
Also if a player goes in studs up and over the ball on the ankle of another player in a dangerous manner and the ref gives the free kick the wrong way….it still isn’t classed as clear and obvious
The only thing in the FA cup final that was ‘clear and obvious’ was the incompetent (blatant cheating) VAR official
But Because we win it gets ignored again
ganganvince
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Oct 2014
- Messages
- 6,674
What's Dermots view?
At last someone who understands the LOTG. Perfectly summed up.
Trevor Morley's Tache
Well-Known Member
Dermot's opinion will be given to him by the PiGMOL/PL through his employers, who have a vested interest in controlling the narrative.
Bazzmand Show
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 17 Jun 2009
- Messages
- 5,058
The ruling on handballs needs to be changed back to deliberate and subjective.
Giving penalties like the Grealish one is a fucking joke and I would be saying the same if it was given for us.
Giving penalties like the Grealish one is a fucking joke and I would be saying the same if it was given for us.
Trevor Morley's Tache
Well-Known Member
The fact that Casimero should 100% have walked for that challenge aside, in what universe is that a foul by Akanji?
I'm not sure who is more guilty of cheating here; the Rag or the Ref?
- Status