VAR thread 2022/23

[Alan Harper's Tash]

You are correct. Yet again the PL decided they were bigger than uefa and they would interpret the law differently.
I have posted before, if the PL stop kow towing to the media and constantly changing laws and interpretations, it would be so much better.
Last night was a straight penalty. That is why VAR did not intervene.

Do you think that a ricochet off your own body onto your arm should be a penalty, or do you think that’s an incredibly harsh decision?

Handball had always had an element of subjection, hence why it’s such a mess at the moment.

Whenever ex-pros use the “need to know the game” narrative, what they mean is it’s against the laws of the game, but shouldn’t be a foul.

 

[BlueHammer85]

The ref did give the penalty VAR just didn’t overturn it

indeed, but why did the Ref give it if there is a conspiracy to benefit Man Utd , it's an extremely dubious penalty in my opinion and the ref could easily ignored it - and it's quite a big defeat for them (which i'm happy about by the way)

Man Utd fans livid as VAR gives another contentious call

MANCHESTER UNITED hosted Real Sociedad in the Europa League on Thursday night,

www.express.co.uk

 

[Manc Born & Bred]

Do you think that a ricochet off your own body onto your arm should be a penalty, or do you think that’s an incredibly harsh decision?

Handball had always had an element of subjection, hence why it’s such a mess at the moment.

Whenever ex-pros use the “need to know the game” narrative, what they mean is it’s against the laws of the game, but shouldn’t be a foul.

Harsh or not those are the LOTG as things stand. Stupid twat really shouldn't have gone diving in with his arms out though

 

[Gorton_Tubster]

The ref did give the penalty VAR just didn’t overturn it

That's the way it should be, the ref decides.

 

[RobinHood]

That's the way it should be, the ref decides.

Always.

 

[andyhinch]

indeed, but why did the Ref give it if there is a conspiracy to benefit Man Utd , it's an extremely dubious penalty in my opinion and the ref could easily ignored it - and it's quite a big defeat for them (which i'm happy about by the way)

Man Utd fans livid as VAR gives another contentious call

MANCHESTER UNITED hosted Real Sociedad in the Europa League on Thursday night,

www.express.co.uk

I’m just not sure why you think this has anything to do with VAR ?

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Harsh or not those are the LOTG as things stand. Stupid twat really shouldn't have gone diving in with his arms out though

Lol. The partisan rhetoric always amazes me.

It was definitely a penalty because Micah Richards did the same thing tbe best part of a decade ago and it was a penalty then.

If it happened in our next PL match and didn’t get overturned on VAR, you’d be the first on here crying corruption.

 

[BlueHammer85]

I’m just not sure why you think this has anything to do with VAR ?

' Lisandro Martinez's back was turned, his arms taut and the ball deflected onto his hand. Penalty, but surely one that had to be overturned. Inexplicably, the continental VAR system upheld a call as egregious as some in the Premier League last week. ''

 

[Manc Born & Bred]

Lol. The partisan rhetoric always amazes me.

It was definitely a penalty because Micah Richards did the same thing tbe best part of a decade ago and it was a penalty then.

If it happened in our next PL match and didn’t get overturned on VAR, you’d be the first on here crying corruption.

It's the LOTG you muppet. Harsh maybe but it's still a penalty regardless of who is playing. You argue, as always, but if you have any issues you need to speak to the lawmakers. Give yourself a day off maybe, I am concerned for your wellbeing

 

[BlueHammer85]

Always.

so like pre VAR, Salah does a blatent dive, zero contact and the ref points to the spot - that's the right way to go ? just accept it ?

fair enough honestly if you prefer that, but i'd rather he takes a second look at the monitor and books Salah

 

[BlueHammer85]

It's the LOTG you muppet. Harsh maybe but it's still a penalty regardless of who is playing. You argue, as always, but if you have any issues you need to speak to the lawmakers. Give yourself a day off maybe, I am concerned for your wellbeing

Or just debate rationally like he does without the petty insults ?

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

It's the LOTG you muppet. Harsh maybe but it's still a penalty regardless of who is playing. You argue, as always, but if you have any issues you need to speak to the lawmakers. Give yourself a day off maybe, I am concerned for your wellbeing

It is an interpretation of the laws of the game.

I’ll refrain from giving you a personal insult as it helps nobody.

Why is it that when somebody on social media disagrees with another that the former is “concerned for their well-being”.

 

[BlueHammer85]

Next week it’ll be Spurs or Arsenal or whoever calling corruption to a decision going against them , every fanbase feels their is a ‘agenda’ against them

 

[arbabarshad]

Next week it’ll be Spurs or Arsenal or whoever calling corruption to a decision going against them , every fanbase feels their is a ‘agenda’ against them


View attachment 55327

Wasnt pool's penalty in Community shield similar? Hit dias on the chest/head and then arm?

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Next week it’ll be Spurs or Arsenal or whoever calling corruption to a decision going against them , every fanbase feels their is a ‘agenda’ against them


View attachment 55327

To be fair, in European competition, they tend to be given. We had one with Laporte against Madrid last season.

It’s the differing in interpretation that causes this difference.

I think the PL interpretation is the better of the two, in this scenario.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Wasnt pool's penalty in Community shield similar? Hit dias on the chest/head and then arm?

No.

 

[BlueHammer85]

To be fair, in European competition, they tend to be given. We had one with Laporte against Madrid last season.

It’s the differing in interpretation that causes this difference.

I think the PL interpretation is the better of the two, in this scenario.

yep fair enough, I thought it looked harsh but if that's the European rules on handball then so be it

what I'm highlighting is how many think Man Utd never get any contentious decisions go against them and that all fanbases feel aggrieved that there is a agenda against them when things don't go their way

 

[arbabarshad]

No.

Thanks for that.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Thanks for that.

No worries. I wasn’t trying to dig you out, just stop pages of “one rule for them…”

 

[halfcenturyup]

' Lisandro Martinez's back was turned, his arms taut and the ball deflected onto his hand. Penalty, but surely one that had to be overturned. Inexplicably, the continental VAR system upheld a call as egregious as some in the Premier League last week. ''

Just out of interest, would it have been a penalty if the ball hadn't been deflected onto his arm, but hit it directly? And why?