de niro said:AntonDonJuan said:Joe Hart should be our number one.
Does what Given does just as well, but can command his area a bit better and his distribution is better. And he's only young so will only improve with each game
joe has everything except experience, his decision making is below par, when he gets that right he has every tool in the box.
de niro said:AntonDonJuan said:Joe Hart should be our number one.
Does what Given does just as well, but can command his area a bit better and his distribution is better. And he's only young so will only improve with each game
joe has everything except experience, his decision making is below par, when he gets that right he has every tool in the box.
OrigamiNinja said:de niro said:joe has everything except experience, his decision making is below par, when he gets that right he has every tool in the box.
Give me Harts decision making over Givens every time! Given always takes the safe option where he doesn't get shown to have dropped an almighty clanger! I would much rather have a keeper who comes for crosses and misses the odd one than a keeper who is fucking glued to his line and sees countless headers from 6 yards out go flying past him whilst numpties in the crowd say "poor given, he had no chance with that header from 3 yards out"!
m27 said:OrigamiNinja said:Give me Harts decision making over Givens every time! Given always takes the safe option where he doesn't get shown to have dropped an almighty clanger! I would much rather have a keeper who comes for crosses and misses the odd one than a keeper who is fucking glued to his line and sees countless headers from 6 yards out go flying past him whilst numpties in the crowd say "poor given, he had no chance with that header from 3 yards out"!
To be fair though, and I want Hart installed as No.1 immediately for the record, when we signed Given Hart was doing ok but not winning us any matches or saving us points. Given comes in and immediately wins us the game against Boro.
Hart's time at Brum has been brilliant for him and it's now time to get him as our first choice for club and country.
OrigamiNinja said:de niro said:joe has everything except experience, his decision making is below par, when he gets that right he has every tool in the box.
Give me Harts decision making over Givens every time! Given always takes the safe option where he doesn't get shown to have dropped an almighty clanger! I would much rather have a keeper who comes for crosses and misses the odd one than a keeper who is fucking glued to his line and sees countless headers from 6 yards out go flying past him whilst numpties in the crowd say "poor given, he had no chance with that header from 3 yards out"!
calculated said:If Hart is so good why didn't he start in the WC? If Given was English do you think David James would have started ahead of him? Mancini has labelled Given top 5 in the world. Hart's a good keeper with lots of potential but hasn't got the experience yet to be resting our champions league qualification and potential title hopes on. Given our no.1 for the league for me, Hart for the cups.