What City player was most over rated by our own fans

[Davs 19]

Uwe Rosler he should have scored more goals. And we got relegated twice.

Sure you mean Uwe not Gio ? ;.)

 

[poh]

Benjani,ah and Benjani,oh and Benjani.wasted a good pair of boots on him

 

[baildon blue]

Uwe Rosler he should have scored more goals. And we got relegated twice.

Sure you mean Uwe not Gio ? ;.)

Lets not forget he left the sinking ship on a free transfer. At least Gio went for quite a bit of dosh.

 

[Davs 19]

Uwe Rosler he should have scored more goals. And we got relegated twice.

Sure you mean Uwe not Gio ? ;.)

Lets not forget he left the sinking ship on a free transfer. At least Gio went for quite a bit of dosh.

A good point well made.

 

[swblue7]

Balotelli !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

Remember when we signed Steve Daley for a then record 1.7 mil? What an overrated tosser he was!

 

[ifiwasarichfan]

Bobby Mac, Gerry Gow and Tommy Hutch.

All three were decent players and proved to be vital pieces of the Jigsaw at the time. None of them though stayed for any length of time and probably get more credit than they deserve.

 

[Shaelumstash]

Milner, Dunne, Bellamy, but without question the most overrated is Dickov

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

Bobby Mac, Gerry Gow and Tommy Hutch.

All three were decent players and proved to be vital pieces of the Jigsaw at the time. None of them though stayed for any length of time and probably get more credit than they deserve.

"More credit than they deserve"?

I doubt many who remember them would agree, but it's all about opinion I suppose, so fair do's.

 

[GornikDaze]

Denis Law... What can we look back on that was any good?

 

[bluewales]

Balotelli !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

this the most overated we have ever had

 

[B\connellblue]

Valeri Bojinov. Even allowing for his injuries.

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Ireland, Tiatto, De Jong, Dickov, Curle, Moulden.

Moulden's a good shout Davs.

 

[carlos tevez is a blue]

Balotelli. Still waiting on him morphing into the new Zlatgod or fat Ronaldo.

12 goals in 13 games since he left seems like a pretty decent start.

About 7 were peno's.

 

[remember arthur mann]

Denis Law... What can we look back on that was any good?

denislawsbackheel!

 

[GornikDaze]

Denis Law... What can we look back on that was any good?

denislawsbackheel!

How could I have forgotten that? ;)

 

[Dr Jacoby]

Elano.

Looked like a world beater in his first dozen or so games, but with the exception of the classic Hamburg game, he offered precisely fuck all else. Definitely one of the laziest players we've had.

 

[baildon blue]

Paul Stewart, Peter Barnes. Was Peter Barnes that good.

 

[blue62]

Niall Quinn. And that's before I hated him as a pundit/ summarizer at which he's equally useless.

 

[gmars]

I find these adverse comment about Dunney quite amazing. What he did for this club simply cannot be disputed. As others have said , without his contribution I doubt we would have had a club that investors would have been interested in. As previously stated his 70 odd caps for his country are a testament to his ability. What has not been stated here (I think) is that the year after he left us, his peers the Premier League players, voted him the best Centre Back in the Premier League. Says a lot doesn't it.