What's the difference between Cancelo's foul and TAA's 'challenge'?

[Alan Harper's Tash]

He's only about 9yds wide of the corner of the goal in that frame about 4.5yds from the touchline which makes it around 10yds from goal. If he shoots left footed there he's still got a lot of goal to aim for and Alison seems to have his weight going in the wrong direction. Without the elbow in his back there is more than a decent chance of him getting a shot on target and every chance of the keeper not getting to it.

Having had a good look at it I think he's just as good a chance of getting to it as the Cancelo foul, but more than willing to have given the Ref the benefit of the doubt if he'd have given the pen and not a red card ;-)

I’d give it up Mr Trevor. No one is even trying to suggest it is a DOGSO outside of a few people on here.

He wasn’t clean through on goal, like Wilson was.

 

[Bournemouth Blue]

The difference is that one was by a City player, and the other by a Liverpool player

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

I’d give it up Mr Trevor. No one is even trying to suggest it is a DOGSO outside of a few people on here.

He wasn’t clean through on goal, like Wilson was.

Let's wait and see how the season pans out shall we?

I'm not ruling out a similar incident in a similar position being given as a pen/red card before this season is out.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

Let's wait and see how the season pans out shall we?

I'm not ruling out a similar incident in a similar position being given as a pen/red card before this season is out.

That’s all we can do.

I won’t rule it in either. ;-)

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

That’s all we can do.

I won’t rule it in either. ;-)

It's the consistency (or lack of it) that bugs the shit out of me.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

It's the consistency (or lack of it) that bugs the shit out of me.

I know mate. I guess I’m lucky that I can let most things slide. I’m still not quite over Taylor vs Chelsea from a few years back though!

Pep’s right when he says we need to be better to negate any decisions that go against us.

 

[afc16]

No he didn’t, it was a penalty! Enough of this narrative

I didn’t say it wasn’t a pen, I said it was an extremely generous pen and it was definitely ‘won’ by kdb.

Given the far more obvious and blatant fouls that I’ve seen arsenal suffer without a pen, and other teams such as spurs/Trent, it was definitely soft. I’d be saying the same if an arsenal player won a pen like that, whilst still being fully happy with it.

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

I know mate. I guess I’m lucky that I can let most things slide. I’m still not quite over Taylor vs Chelsea from a few years back though!

Pep’s right when he says we need to be better to negate any decisions that go against us.

That wasn't so much a lack of consistency though.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

That wasn't so much a lack of consistency though.

There’ll always be difference tolerance levels though. Even with the same referee. A local derby will be reffed differently to a mid table nothing match. You could argue every game should be refereed the same, but it’s impossible.

 

[Trevor Morley's Tache]

There’ll always be difference tolerance levels though. Even with the same referee. A local derby will be reffed differently to a mid table nothing match. You could argue every game should be refereed the same, but it’s impossible.

I was thinking something more sinister in that game to be fair. His 'performance' stank the place out.