What's your all-time Man City & Man Utd combined XI?

[GornikDaze]

Ronaldo = The Brazilian one
Cristiano = The Portuguese one

Calling a player by their first name doesn't make anyone a fanboy. Bobby Charlton recently passed away and loads of people here called him by his surname, I doubt they're actually United fans

I think you’ll find it’s Fat Ronaldo and Fake Ronaldo

 

[jaseisblue]

I am not a prolific poster, but this just brought a bit of sick up. Get rid before it permanently sullies my phone..

 

[RiversideBlue]

1. Colin Bell
2. Colin Bell
3. Colin Bell
4. Colin Bell
5. Colin Bell
6. Colin Bell
7. Colin Bell (capt)
8. Colin Bell
9. Colin Bell
10. Colin Bell
11. Colin Bell

 

[Disco Danger]

Schmeichel

Walker-Ferdinand-Stam-Irwin

Toure-Keane-Scholes

Rooney-Aguero-Ronaldo.

 

[hilts]

We're almost at 3 pages and there's no objective counter-arguments why I'm wrong for choosing Cristiano.

Embarrasing how others are calling a ban because my personal opinion goes against your world view...

Sorry for your loss today:-)

 

[M Gaudino]

Both of these clubs have had amazing players throughout the years, but there's only 11 available selections. As the title says, who do you prefer in an all-time Xi from these clubs.

Here's my choice

Schmeichel
Walker - Dias - Vidic - Evra
De Bruyne - Rodri - Scholes
Rooney - Haaland - Cristiano

football did exist before 2000 you know

 

[M Gaudino]

No Giggsy??

giggs is the james milner of the PL era. longevity does not equal excellence. i remember the 90s and if not injured he was rotated in and out. was never ever a world class player

 

[Kunlover]

Schmeichel
Walker - Ferdinand - Stam - Irwin
Scholes - Keane - Yaya Toure
Giggs - Agüero - Cristiano Ronaldo

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Both of these clubs have had amazing players throughout the years, but there's only 11 available selections. As the title says, who do you prefer in an all-time Xi from these clubs.

Here's my choice

Schmeichel
Walker - Dias - Vidic - Evra
De Bruyne - Rodri - Scholes
Rooney - Haaland - Cristiano

Tellingly every player you’ve picked played for the clubs in this century.

 

[CarlosTevez'sEnglishTutor]

Wash your mouth out. No reds please.