markprendy
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 11 Sep 2008
- Messages
- 806
My dad reckons Trautmann and said the best save he ever saw was by him.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Who is the best City goalkeeper in history?
- Thread starter Hungarian blue
- Start date
Yes, Hart was the best at one on ones I've ever seen....my God he was favourite against most strikers, he just psyched them out.Didn't see enough of TC and I was a touch too young, but Joe Hart is and was seriously over rated. Weak to his left, terrible distribution, average at best on crosses, slow off his line... but world class at shot stopping and brilliant on one on ones. It's probably someone before my time but Ederson has started on fire in spells for a keeper so young, hopefully he kicks on unlike Hart. When he came back from Brum he stopped progressing and I feel his weaknesses never improved.
I should also have said that the rest of your analysis was spot onDidn't see enough of TC and I was a touch too young, but Joe Hart is and was seriously over rated. Weak to his left, terrible distribution, average at best on crosses, slow off his line... but world class at shot stopping and brilliant on one on ones. It's probably someone before my time but Ederson has started on fire in spells for a keeper so young, hopefully he kicks on unlike Hart. When he came back from Brum he stopped progressing and I feel his weaknesses never improved.
Neville Kneville
Well-Known Member
Ederson.
You can see it already.
You can see it already.
gordondaviesmoustache
Well-Known Member
That's bold, but not ridiculously so.Ederson.
You can see it already.
malg
Well-Known Member
No one springs to mind.
Neville Kneville
Well-Known Member
That's bold, but not ridiculously so.
I like to be bold & not quite ridiculous.
cucumberman
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 4 Jul 2009
- Messages
- 5,067
Trautmann, even when he's before my time, highlights of his games really showed how technically and physically gifted he was and he commits to many of his saves and 1v1.
During my time I would say Weaver for the level we were in. Horses for courses, Weaver won't make the no.1 spot now, but he was a joy to watch.
Joe Hart is also a great keeper when he was one of our few stars. When he injured his shoulder and Given came in for the remainder of the season, it became an anticlimax knowing that Given doesn't come out for crosses.
During my time I would say Weaver for the level we were in. Horses for courses, Weaver won't make the no.1 spot now, but he was a joy to watch.
Joe Hart is also a great keeper when he was one of our few stars. When he injured his shoulder and Given came in for the remainder of the season, it became an anticlimax knowing that Given doesn't come out for crosses.
goatersnipple
Well-Known Member
Tc was better than hart.
This new lad looks spot on
This new lad looks spot on