Who now then?...

CBs: Maguire, Laporte, Otamendi and Kompany
DMs: Fernandinho, Stones, Gundogan
Looks good to me

All seven of those players will want regular gametime. Only three spaces. I can't see it working.

Stones as a DM doesn't sound likely to me. He's not as mobile as we'd like and while his passing is good by CB standards I imagine it would fall short compared to Fernandinho, Gundogan or Jorginho.
 
Can't really see Stones at DM. He's good on the ball with a bit of time and facing forward but he won't get as much time at DM and will often be required to play out of tighter positions. He's a CB.
 
Anyone else think Stones could be transformed to a DM, and we buy Maguire? Stones is brilliant on the ball, good passer, he`s intelligent, has decent pace and is a great tackler. His only shortcoming IMO, is his marking and concentration at times, and I don`t think that would be exposed to an equal extent, as if he was playing CB

Yeahhhh I have always thought this! But at the same time I’m sure pep has and for some reason or another he has decided against it
 
All seven of those players will want regular gametime. Only three spaces. I can't see it working.

Stones as a DM doesn't sound likely to me. He's not as mobile as we'd like and while his passing is good by CB standards I imagine it would fall short compared to Fernandinho, Gundogan or Jorginho.
This season we had Otamendi, Kompany, Stones and Laporte as CBs, and Fernandinho, Yaya and Gundogan as DMs. Apart from Yaya, everyone got a lot of playing time, especially Fernandinho since Yaya was shit, and Gundogan had to cover for KDB or Merlin sometimes. Don`t think 6 (Laporte, Maguire, Otamendi, Kompany, Fernandinho and Stones) players would be too much for 3 positions (if Gundogan plays further forward)
 
Move Delph into midfield to compete with Gundogan and Fernandinho and bring in Sandro to compete at LB with Mendy.
 
As good as our squad is, I hope we sign some sort of block-buster player this window - not so much for the P/L but for the Champion's League.

In the one-off C/L matches (and indeed the FA Cup), anything might happen. But if your squad is just so much better than the opposition, talent offsets circumstance, at least partially. To win the C/L (CIty's ambition) requires luck and a good squad (but the better your squad, the less luck required).
 
Sam lee saying Mahrez may be our only signing now Jorginho going Chelsea
On the one hand, it makes sense. People here have thrown out a lot of names that don't really address what Pep wants from the position. On the other hand, it's an area where we're particularly vulnerable against certain tactics. Fortunately, not a lot of teams can play those tactics effectively, but it doesn't look great for Champions League ambitions if I'm honest.
 
Sam lee saying Mahrez may be our only signing now Jorginho going Chelsea

Good to hear. There is no point wasting money on somebody who doesn't fit what we are actually looking for. Bide our time and get the right player in the replace Fern long term
 
I won’t be particularly concerned if Mahrez is our only signing this summer.

But if no further additions are made, we will probably struggle once again against teams of a high quality who deploy the gaegenpress (Liverpool, etc.).

Looking at our squad, you would think that we need either a ball-playing defensive midfielder (Jorginho etc) or someone more combative (Casemiro etc.).
 
Have to say if we don’t sign anothe DM it will be a mistake. It is the only position we don’t have any real cover for and we need a long term replacement for Fernandinho. We have failed to replace players at the right time previously and it has cost us. Hope Sam Lee is wrong about this one.
 
Have to say if we don’t sign anothe DM it will be a mistake. It is the only position we don’t have any real cover for and we need a long term replacement for Fernandinho. We have failed to replace players at the right time previously and it has cost us. Hope Sam Lee is wrong about this one.
Has to be the right player that fits our system otherwise we end up trying to make a square peg fit into a round hole. We've had a fair few of those the past several years, and I doubt Pep is going to be talked into alternative signings that don't fit because some in the club are optimistic he can make it work.
 
Have to say if we don’t sign anothe DM it will be a mistake. It is the only position we don’t have any real cover for and we need a long term replacement for Fernandinho. We have failed to replace players at the right time previously and it has cost us. Hope Sam Lee is wrong about this one.
I agree. I'd personally have done whatever it took to get the jorginho deal over the line.
 
It's piss poor if we decide to continue next season with an ageing Fernandinho as our only holding midfielder. We're weak in that position and we clearly need new blood there.

Our squad is still incredibly strong but not in the most important position on the pitch for Pep.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top