Who Should Be The Biased Manchester City TV Pundit?

[mixer]

Richard Dunne

 

[bobmcfc]

Trevor Sinclair

 

[Deleted member 77198]

Given is always quality and Dickov is the go to City man on Talkshite and loves the club.

Sometimes it can be a bad thing. Some of the stuff former Liverpool players come out with is embarrassing. Aldridge most recently. Neville was the most hated rag around yet has become an excellent pundit that retains balance to his opinions. Does he hate City still, of course he fucking does, but his assessments are generally spot on. If the quality of pundits improved we wouldn't need former City players around.

They sound like idiots.

Danny Murphy said the other day on MOTD2 “if Liverpool don’t win it, they’ve done so well anyway and I don’t get the obsession with winning trophies” the later said “it would be a real shame for van Dijk to have had such a good season for him not to win the league, it’s trophies they need”.

 

[M12Blue]

I was only thinking this after reading the mixed response to Noel Gallagher’s appearance on MOTD2

Personally I don’t mind Carragher and I think Gary Neville talks a lot of sense. However both players are firmly associated with one particular club. So are McManaman, Fowler and Owen, or Scholes, Keane and Schmeichel. (neutrals would never guess that three of those players also played for Manchester City)

You can tell by their choice of pundits for one of our games that Sky are always unsure about City. There’s usually a City connection, but never our equivalent of Paul Merson or Matt Le Tissier.

There are lots of pundits who once played for City, but nobody who the neutrals would associate as a City legend in the same way as Tim Cahill at Everton, Alan Shearer at Newcastle or even Matt Elliott at Leicester.

Objectively, Niall Quinn player more games for City than any other club. However he still comes across as an Arsenal fan with a soft spot for Sunderland.
They’ve tried Steve Howey, but his accent smacks of ex-Newcastle centre half. Paul Walsh wasn’t at City long enough and most of us would rather forget Danny Mills.

Perhaps Goater or Rosler, but their appeal is probably too parochial

Is there anyone who will argue City’s corner or are we best waiting for SWP or Richard Dunne to retire?

Paul dickov

 

[Kompany Car]

Nicky Weaver, albeit he’s a Sheff Wednesday fan, seemed like a sound bloke on the “Were Not Really Here “ documentary that was recently on Sky.

Would be happy though with Richard Dunne or Lescott.

 

[StrangewaysHereWeCome]

He's the left back remember

" 5!"

Don't you just love reading a new thread and as you're already sure on what your reply to the thread would be you scroll to your own post that you made four years previously as this is not a new thread at all.

 

[kiam06]

Has to be Kompany when he retires also Zabaleta.

 

[Franny's toilet roll]

Kompany and Zabaleta will probably have roles at City after playing careers finish. For me currently it would be Paul Dickov

 

[OilBoy2008]

Has to be Kompany when he retires also Zabaleta.

I think Kompany is a bit too intelligent for a media career; no disrespect to the great presenters out there, but I see him moving onto big things whether it's in football, politics or business.

 

[Stoned Rose]

No the Brazilian Messi.

Vocals weren’t up to much but he could dance tbf.