chesterbells
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Apr 2010
- Messages
- 26,899
Agreed. There do seem to be a few ‘baby & bathwater’ posts knocking about on here.
Women's Team - 2021/22
- Thread starter MAG
- Start date
- Status
bumbleblue
Well-Known Member
Keep hearing about who might go but nowt about who might arrive..
Cotontoquinn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 2,741
- Team supported
- Manchester City
Was it Sam Mewis and Rose Lavelle?? Joking….but Gareth Taylor has an abysmal record with foreign imports.
If City are serious about the WSL then he has to go….his decision to continue to play that utterly useless French goalkeeper Taieb was madness as was his decision to only use Raso as …. A substitute.
Under Taylor we have gone backwards. Nothing suggests that this will dramatically change next season.
The WSL has 3 clubs that are better than the rest and then the Rags. If Taylor remains in charge it will be “ 3 clubs and then City”.
He used up his “Get out of Jail Card“ this season. Get rid……
better dead than red
Well-Known Member
Just looked one of them up, Alicia Window. She went to America to play for The George Washington University. I can't think of the other who I believe did similar.
Alicia Window - Women's Soccer - George Washington University Athletics
Alicia Window (20) Defense - 2024 Started in all 18 matches for GW as a senior... Tallied seven points on the season, recording three goals and one assist......
Cotontoquinn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 2,741
- Team supported
- Manchester City
If we’re honest there are only a handful of City players that would be the nucleus of a team next season…
Ellie Roebuck, Alex Greenwood, Esme Morgan, Kiera Walsh, Lauren Hemp, Chloe Kelly, Hayley Raso, Jess Park, Ruby Mace, Khiara Keating and Vicky Losada. Not sure about Blakstad or Shaw.
We need a significant number of arrivals……
nmc
Well-Known Member
The big issue for the Women's side is the coach - we have improved as players have returned but I’m still of the view that the job is beyond Gareth Taylor. We need to bring in an established coach - who can enable us to dominate this league. Despite all the departures we can assemble an excellent squad - there’s plenty of opportunity to sign good players in the women’s game but we need to galvanise them and give the squad / team a personality - a way of being - and Taylor simply isn’t able to do that.
Bluesiam
Well-Known Member
What was it, 12 wins on the bounce after a rash of injuries early on. And, very unlucky to lose the Cup Final; yet the manager and most of the players have to go???
Bluesiam
Well-Known Member
Big handful that....glad we're at least keeping some players:)
Cotontoquinn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 2,741
- Team supported
- Manchester City
12 wins against very poor opposition. Not very unlucky to lose the Cup Final and a manager who has proved to be inadequate. Most of the players have underperformed this season.
Most of His decisions have been crap. If MCFC are serious about the womens game then he has to go..
Where is the evidence of Gareth Taylor actually IMPROVING this City squad??
carolinefrances
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 Sep 2013
- Messages
- 122
Hahaha, a millennium of sexism.......
Cotontoquinn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 2,741
- Team supported
- Manchester City
Who would you keep??
Not sure we've been watching the same team if this is what you think she does, from where I sit she's the only one in midfield who can be trusted to be given the ball under pressure, in tight spaces, and keep it going rather than being dispossessed. Weir can do it on her day but hasn't been as consistent this season and likes to go for a dribble anyway which is more risky, Losada has the technique but not the agility, and Stanway falls over. The likes of Coombs etc aren't on the same level and it shows when they try to cover for her.
I'm not sure what more you're looking for in terms of moving forward when she's playing at the base of midfield distributing it to virtually everyone (backwards, sideways and forward) from deep and getting assists. It'd be like criticising Fernandinho for not making KDB-style passes a few years ago or pumping it forward, it's just not part of the job. If they wanted to replace her, they'd either need to change style massively or throw money at someone like Lia Waelti.
I don't entirely disagree with you about tempo being an issue fwiw, but that's that's a team issue, not a Walsh issue, - Alanna Kennedy passing it between herself and Alex Greenwood, the wingers refusing to hit crosses early, strikers holding up the ball rather than facing goal etc. That's where the coaching comes in though, we've never had a top coach and it shows.
Second half of the season, with all the players back, we were as good as anyone.
If all teams stayed injury free next season, I think we'd finish 2nd, behind Chelsea but ahead of Arsenal, and we'd push Chelsea all the way. That's with the side we have right now.
Yes we should want to improve and some changes need making but we don't need to rip it apart and start again.
With the salary cap and wages as they are, it's not always straightforward to get players to join. We could maybe get ambitious players from other lower WSL teams, but they would probably not be our level on day 1. Getting players to uproot from other countries and come here is obviously possible, but never a guarantee as the wages may be better where they are.
We are obviously attractive over here due to our setup. Chelsea and Arsenal have London. It's difficult to get players instantly who are better than White, Stokes, Weir and Walsh. Kennedy came in late notice and isn't perfect, but she's done a good job and we probably wouldn't have made 3rd this season without her.
So. Keep most of them. If Weir, Shaw, Bronze etc want to leave, then they'll leave and along with Stanway, it'll be a big enough job replacing them without having to change others also.
Cotontoquinn
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 19 Jul 2020
- Messages
- 2,741
- Team supported
- Manchester City
The only reason we finished 3rd was the very easy run in and that Manchester United had to beat Chelsea in their final match.
3 home games against Leicester City, Brighton and Birmingham City and a final away game at Reading = 4:0, 7:2, 6:0 and 4:0.
You could not have had a better set of matches.
If we’d had to play Chelsea we’d have lost…….oh we did in the FA Cup Final.
This ageing City squad is going to have to be dismantled and I really worry for next season. Champions League could be a disaster.
3 home games against Leicester City, Brighton and Birmingham City and a final away game at Reading = 4:0, 7:2, 6:0 and 4:0.
You could not have had a better set of matches.
If we’d had to play Chelsea we’d have lost…….oh we did in the FA Cup Final.
This ageing City squad is going to have to be dismantled and I really worry for next season. Champions League could be a disaster.
Protein Junkie
Well-Known Member
I’m gutted to see Georgia Stanway leave. My favourite player.
We won our last 10 league games. That's not "an easy run in", that's beating most of the league. Yes we lost to Chelsea on the FA Cup final, after extra time - but in amongst that run we also beat Chelsea 3-1 in the League Cup final.
We finished above United because we are way better than them. We are attempting to play a Pep-style of football while they are still bothered about being physical, getting stuck-in and winning personal battles. We're a decade ahead of them.
Bloody hell, sometimes I think I'm pessimistic, but I must have a rethink on that... :-D
cleavers
Moderator
Another argument is that we only finished 3rd because of the horrific injury list in the first 1/4 of the season, we might well have finished top had we had everyone available early doors.
HelloCity
Well-Known Member
HelloCity
Well-Known Member
You’re a strange bloke.
Chill. We were ravaged by injuries for most of the season. We’ve probably done will to get top 3 in the end.
Last edited:
- Status