prestonibbo_mcfc
Well-Known Member
You're still wrong today, as you were yesterday.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
World Cup VAR
- Thread starter stonerblue
- Start date
You're still wrong today, as you were yesterday.
Hart of the Matter
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 Jul 2011
- Messages
- 5,180
Quoting commentators only ever weakens your argument.After watching it again, with commentary that says and I quote “the French attacker missed the header” I’m confident in saying there was no contact
quiet_riot
Well-Known Member
It's telling who has never played the sport. People who think you can jump like a robot, the ball is a massive entity which requires a full on whack to change course....and those who listen to commentators.
asahartford1
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Nov 2016
- Messages
- 8,833
I was accused of being blind yesterday when i said the ball didn't come off a French players head just before (which it still didn't) so forgive me for questioning this but "it didn't change the trajectory of the ball"? Are you serious, it was going across the face of the goal. His movement (out of a natural position) hit it out of play instead.
Ridiculous. If that is handball there are 5 pens every game. I believe you are either a Wum or football is not for you. The decision has been widely criticised throughout the world today. If you are so needy, I am sorry for you.
What you and some others fail to understand is that it is so difficult to score a goal. If penalties are given for this then the aim of the game will be to hit the arm of the opponent in the penalty area, much easier than trying to score a goal, but equally rewarding.
Bless xx
Last edited:
BlueHammer85
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Oct 2010
- Messages
- 36,762
Ridiculous. If that is handball there are 5 pens every game. I believe you are either a Wum or football is not for you. The decision has been widely criticised throughout the world today. If you are so needy, I am sorry for you.
What you and some others fail to understand is that it is so difficult to score a goal. If penalties are given for this then the aim of the game will be to hit the arm of the opponent in the penalty area, much easier than trying to score a goal, but equally rewarding.
Bless xx
Sorry but I and many others saw it as a penalty aswell. I think he instinctively put he’s arm down a lot quicker than needed to be and blocked the ball going across face of goal with his hand for a corner.
There is simply no way of telling if it’s accidental or not. Either way, it’s a good thing the Ref was allowed another look and make a decision, rather than the blind guessing before VARs existence.
asahartford1
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 15 Nov 2016
- Messages
- 8,833
Sorry but I and many others saw it as a penalty aswell. I think he instinctively put he’s arm down a lot quicker than needed to be and blocked the ball going across face of goal with his hand for a corner.
There is simply no way of telling if it’s accidental or not. Either way, it’s a good thing the Ref was allowed another look and make a decision, rather than the blind guessing before VARs existence.
A fair opinion.
My response would be: if that decision were the norm, I would be instructing players to be hitting an opponent's arm in the penalty box at all times, much easier then trying to score a goal.
There is a precedent, happened in Brazil, when refs were instructed to give more " handball" pens. The players immediately started to play for them.
In my view, a ball hitting an arm when the players view is obstructed , or and deflected is not a pen. Especially if the defender is stood in a natural position.
If the arm is either above the head or the defender has gone to ground different questions need to be asked.