Player topic: David Silva (2014/15)

[Bluewonder]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

Dave is a better playmaker than Iniesta.

yesterday again we missed him as an outet instanly

He absolutely is not. Every non-City fan in the world would rate Iniesta above Silva.

disagree , you are getting confused with achievements versus ability , (the family wrecker has won 10 titles for the rags , it doesnt make him a world class player) , and silva will be judged over next 5 seasons when his career is over , i believe many "non city" fans will consider silva at least on a par with iniesta .There again i wouldnt be stupid enough to believe i know what every "non city" fan is thinking , that would be presumptuous.

1. Giggs was undoubtedly a world-class player.

2. He simply isn't considered as good as Iniesta, you only need to read the perspective of the foreign media to see that.

3. The idea that (arguably) the world's best ever club and country sides being built predominantly around Iniesta's genius doesn't reflect his ability is bizarre.

 

[Proelia]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

He absolutely is not. Every non-City fan in the world would rate Iniesta above Silva.

disagree , you are getting confused with achievements versus ability , (the family wrecker has won 10 titles for the rags , it doesnt make him a world class player) , and silva will be judged over next 5 seasons when his career is over , i believe many "non city" fans will consider silva at least on a par with iniesta .There again i wouldnt be stupid enough to believe i know what every "non city" fan is thinking , that would be presumptuous.

1. Giggs was undoubtedly a world-class player.

2. He simply isn't considered as good as Iniesta, you only need to read the perspective of the foreign media to see that.

3. The idea that (arguably) the world's best ever club and country sides being built predominantly around Iniesta's genius doesn't reflect his ability is bizarre.

Silva has been better then iniesta for two years now

 

[Foe23]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

I wouldn't swap.

Neither would I

I wouldn't swap because Silva is on his way to icon status at City, but that doesn't make him a better player.

Silva fits our system better than Iniesta & he's only just coming into his prime.
He's not been around as long, so we can only make a fair comparison when his career is at the same point. I think they'll be a few iconic moments in Dave's future, hopefully in a City shirt.
I agree, non city fans would take Iniesta before our Dave tho.

 

[pikku]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

Was ok yesterday,he was on fire last season from around december ..still needs to find that level of form..Under performing as of now,going by his standards...

 

[kiam06]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

In my opinion today David Silva is the best footballer in the world there is nobody I enjoy watching more.

 

[kiam06]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

Was ok yesterday,he was on fire last season from around december ..still needs to find that level of form..Under performing as of now,going by his standards...

Nonsense. Sorry to say this to another blue but you haven't got a clue of you cannot see what Silva is doing on the pitch.

 

[FantasyIreland]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

Was ok yesterday,he was on fire last season from around december ..still needs to find that level of form..Under performing as of now,going by his standards...

Nonsense. Sorry to say this to another blue but you haven't got a clue of you cannot see what Silva is doing on the pitch.

Id be surprised if that fella has ever been to England let alone Manchester.The usual bollocks from a JCL.

 

[blueparrot]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

He absolutely is not. Every non-City fan in the world would rate Iniesta above Silva.

disagree , you are getting confused with achievements versus ability , (the family wrecker has won 10 titles for the rags , it doesnt make him a world class player) , and silva will be judged over next 5 seasons when his career is over , i believe many "non city" fans will consider silva at least on a par with iniesta .There again i wouldnt be stupid enough to believe i know what every "non city" fan is thinking , that would be presumptuous.

1. Giggs was undoubtedly a world-class player.

2. He simply isn't considered as good as Iniesta, you only need to read the perspective of the foreign media to see that.

3. The idea that (arguably) the world's best ever club and country sides being built predominantly around Iniesta's genius doesn't reflect his ability is bizarre.

He isn't considered as good as Iniesta by most of the world mainly because most of the world will have seen a lot more of Iniesta because he plays for Barcelona. For me there is very little to choose between them, but going of age and current form I would take Silva.

 

[jimmygrimblesboots]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

He absolutely is not. Every non-City fan in the world would rate Iniesta above Silva.

disagree , you are getting confused with achievements versus ability , (the family wrecker has won 10 titles for the rags , it doesnt make him a world class player) , and silva will be judged over next 5 seasons when his career is over , i believe many "non city" fans will consider silva at least on a par with iniesta .There again i wouldnt be stupid enough to believe i know what every "non city" fan is thinking , that would be presumptuous.

1. Giggs was undoubtedly a world-class player.

2. He simply isn't considered as good as Iniesta, you only need to read the perspective of the foreign media to see that.

3. The idea that (arguably) the world's best ever club and country sides being built predominantly around Iniesta's genius doesn't reflect his ability is bizarre.

1. your personal opinion , which is insignificant to me.

2. the foreign media ? your generalisation is unproven and inaccurate , is this the same "foreign media" that thought mezut ozil , would take the premiership by storm , how wrong could they be ?

3. i think you will find barca and spain were built around several world class players ,neither were a one man team , and iniesta only reached his level of performance because of the outstanding world class players along side him. Casillas, ramos , pique ,puyol , busquets , alonso , xavi , pedro , villa etc etc and yet you state the the team revolved around iniesta , now that is really bizarre.

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Re: David 'Merlin' Silva appreciation thread

disagree , you are getting confused with achievements versus ability , (the family wrecker has won 10 titles for the rags , it doesnt make him a world class player) , and silva will be judged over next 5 seasons when his career is over , i believe many "non city" fans will consider silva at least on a par with iniesta .There again i wouldnt be stupid enough to believe i know what every "non city" fan is thinking , that would be presumptuous.

1. Giggs was undoubtedly a world-class player.

2. He simply isn't considered as good as Iniesta, you only need to read the perspective of the foreign media to see that.

3. The idea that (arguably) the world's best ever club and country sides being built predominantly around Iniesta's genius doesn't reflect his ability is bizarre.

1. your personal opinion , which is insignificant to me.

2. the foreign media ? your generalisation is unproven and inaccurate , is this the same "foreign media" that thought mezut ozil , would take the premiership by storm , how wrong could they be ?

3. i think you will find barca and spain were built around several world class players ,neither were a one man team , and iniesta only reached his level of performance because of the outstanding world class players along side him. Casillas, ramos , pique ,puyol , busquets , alonso , xavi , pedro , villa etc etc and yet you state the the team revolved around iniesta , now that is really bizarre.

Apart from being an appalling thing to say, I'm not sure why you're engaging in a debate with someone whose opinion you don't value.