Another new Brexit thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ric
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's no different to the American way of life.

The EU even wants to become more American, but with a "European" face.
Well, I don't really agree with that.
I find the two places very different. I find the mindset very different.
I think I'd much prefer a European lifestyle. We'll leave it at that.
I'm more of a Caprese salad kind of guy than a Big Mac meal guy.
 
Mate we can’t do any deal with the EU , those are the rules made up by the EU

It’s all pie in the sky until the withdrawal agreement is signed .

I don’t understand remainers refusal to see how this isn’t cake and eat it by the eu . All of this should have been wrapped up in one agreement dealing with exit and future trade .


No ... its contractual law .... you can't negotiate with yourself whilst as a member of the other party.... cos if you don't like what's happening you can block it / vote against it.

Its in place to stop cherry picking ...

applied in every level of business.You have to extracte yourself from the 'Opposition' first before you negotiate.
 
In all serious we are a few weeks away from Halloween and all sides say they want to leave with a deal.

If this was a huge piece of litigation the parties would be seeking to try and resolve differences by way of arbitration.

The eu negotiAtion team should be locked in a hotel room with the uk negotiating team and aided by a skilled arbitrator who is-experienced in dealing with international disputes. The fuckers should not be allowed out of the hotel until a deal has been reached.

I recall the last days of the GFA required a similar push and a sleepless night, as did the bail out deals of the banks.

We need to stop fucking about get in a room and get this thing resolved. Apparently that’s what the parties publicly state they want but this posturing is getting pathetic and boring.


Unfortunately the UK 'Government' has broken up for the holidays
 
Foster of the DUP on the backstop choosing her words with care. She states ‘Unionism’ does not support the backstop. Not NI or the people of NI but just one specific group. If the U.K. Govt proceeds on supporting just this narrow definition of what is acceptable then there is going to be trouble ahead.
 
Agreed - and you guys should have been on these threads pushing that point before the vote

The majority of posts from Remainers commenting on the GFA on these threads are not from people from the island of Ireland though - and yet you would think that they were all scholars on the subject
In fairness, I wasn't on the thread myself and found it late into whatever incarnation of the thread it was at the time.
There are a lot of people on here who speak with authority about subjects they know little about.
I general hold my tongue (figuratively speaking) as I've learned much in here from people who do seem to have a fair understanding of a wide range of things Brexit related.
Where I generally jump in is where I feel there is misinformation being put about regarding the Irish element.
I don't do it to hijack the Brexit debate. It's just the area that most affects me and the area I'm living in and through and the area I know most about.
 
Well, I don't really agree with that.
I find the two places very different. I find the mindset very different.
I think I'd much prefer a European lifestyle. We'll leave it at that.
I'm more of a Caprese salad kind of guy than a Big Mac meal guy.
You don't have to.

Like everything people pick and choose things they find associated with certain places. For example I see America as more of a BBQ flame griled steak than a Big Mac, and Europe as less of a Caprese salad and more like a bratwurst.
 
That's a welcome change of tone.

Just as you mentioned about remainers and the EU, I assure you not every single leave voter "hates" the EU, they are concerned about it's current direction. I'd stay in the EU no problems whatsoever, if only it would cease with this incessant drive for more sovereign powers over it's members. Peace, economy and civil liberties come first, and if Johnson cannot deliver, then I hope a no deal will be avoided, and if that means staying in, then we stay in, BUT it must be OUR decision, the electorates, not Parliaments. I used to care about the EU ignoring it's members and forcing them to comply with the decisions made by a minor few who had assumed positions of power, but not anymore. They'll all do what they always do, and I include our own MP's in that regard.

Just as with your feeling of how you're not arsed about being in the EU on any emotional attachment, I really am not arsed about the UK being a "major player" in the world. I'd rather us be more like a Denmark or a Norway or Australia; just doing it's thing, making the people happy, content with their lives, not trying to police the world or set the course of direction we think others should follow.

Climate change is an important issue as is the energy one, and it's those which needs to be sorted in the UN where every nation (is meant to) have an equal voice. I don't want "the strength of the EU" backing us up, getting us involved in their disputes they want to have; we had that as a poodle of the Bush and Reagan Administrations. The whole "EU" thing, just makes me think of things like the Triple Entente, except now the EU's trying to puff out it's chest to Russia and China whilst snubbing the US. Not only is it embarrassing, it's slightly worrying to me.

The UK power thing isn’t first on my list.

I really care about being able to live in a nice place, have a good job and be able to enjoy my life.

It sounds selfish but I want it for everyone.

I’m paraphrasing here but an old Tory aristocrat and MP wanted to give the entire population of the east end baths over a century ago. A colleague of his said “the poor don’t deserve baths, look at how they riot when they don’t get what they want”, the MP said “its not for their benefit it’s for mine”.

You get what I’m trying to say. I want the economy strong and for business to boom so I can do well. I can then enjoy my life when their isn’t crime or social issues because of people being poor.

Brexit puts the above at risk.
 
Foster of the DUP on the backstop choosing her words with care. She states ‘Unionism’ does not support the backstop. Not NI or the people of NI but just one specific group. If the U.K. Govt proceeds on supporting just this narrow definition of what is acceptable then there is going to be trouble ahead.
Undermining the GFA is a bonus to her.
 
Merkel says that "practical solutions" will be looked at for the border.

I smell movement.
 
No ... its contractual law .... you can't negotiate with yourself whilst as a member of the other party.... cos if you don't like what's happening you can block it / vote against it.

Its in place to stop cherry picking ...

applied in every level of business.You have to extracte yourself from the 'Opposition' first before you negotiate.

What utter shite

And I say that as a former international head of private equity at one of the worlds largest law firms
 
You don't have to.

Like everything people pick and choose things they find associated with certain places. For example I see America as more of a BBQ flame griled steak than a Big Mac, and Europe as less of a Caprese salad and more like a bratwurst.
I see your analogy but I'm not a fan of the American culture that we have been force fed since we were kids. Force fed is probably not the right term.
We lapped it up. We are constantly taking it in subliminally. I blame the common use of the English language in reality. Most of Europe hung onto their culture less diluted as a result of having their own languages. A lot of that culture may seem twee now but I find greater wisdom and respect for traditions. Listen you can put etc etc etc on the end of that.
Truth is we won't agree. That's OK. That's allowed.
 
The UK power thing isn’t first on my list.

I really care about being able to live in a nice place, have a good job and be able to enjoy my life.

It sounds selfish but I want it for everyone.

I’m paraphrasing here but an old Tory aristocrat and MP wanted to give the entire population of the east end baths over a century ago. A colleague of his said “the poor don’t deserve baths, look at how they riot when they don’t get what they want”, the MP said “its not for their benefit it’s for mine”.

You get what I’m trying to say. I want the economy strong and for business to boom so I can do well. I can then enjoy my life when their isn’t crime or social issues because of people being poor.

Brexit puts the above at risk.
Same here, but i'm also realistic that whilst we continue to fund these "projects", there are still people living here that are not enjoying the same lifestyle as others currently do.

I simpyl don't see how the UK being at the forefront for all the political disputes between nations, because it's clinging to it's sense of "relevancy", being backed up by an EU that also wants "relevancy", especially in the face of Russia, China and US, is in my opinion an outdated concept.

This is why I want our relationship with Europe to be first and foremost, economic, not political, and recent language coming from MEP's from the continent suggests that they are not happy with our current setup and demand more involvement from the UK towards their project.
 
I see your analogy but I'm not a fan of the American culture that we have been force fed since we were kids. Force fed is probably not the right term.
We lapped it up. We are constantly taking it in subliminally. I blame the common use of the English language in reality. Most of Europe hung onto their culture less diluted as a result of having their own languages. A lot of that culture may seem twee now but I find greater wisdom and respect for traditions. Listen you can put etc etc etc on the end of that.
Truth is we won't agree. That's OK. That's allowed.
You say that, but people often tend to question why I don't wish to be seen as "European".
In my experience, it is not okay to dismiss Europe, but is wholly acceptible to dismiss America, almost as if it's not allowed. It's these double standards I disagree with. If you disagree with my notion of not being European and more aligned with America, that's fine, you're not a fan of American culture and I am, but then there's also no need to bring it up then, is there.
 
Merkel says that "practical solutions" will be looked at for the border.

I smell movement.

I smell bullshit it reeks and its coming from Boris's mouth, he has no intentions of cutting a deal with the EU this is all about posturing setting the scene Trump style did with the media. The EU will be declared the enemy because they refuse to budge and just want to keep us in because they want our money and it will us against them. There will simply be no choice but to crash out on the 31st October and turn the UK into a backwards bana republic far right gang banging eutopia dreamed up by Dominic Cummings.
 
Yep there is pure opportunism on both sides

And given you view the GFA as badly fractured at the moment anyway - why should the UK population accept that it should be the driving force for deciding key UK policy?
I think the fracturing has a lot to do with the DUP who never wanted it and are propping up your Government.
They vote with when it suits and against when it doesn't.

I've nothing against the UK as a whole having whatever driving force they wish to leave the EU.
My one gripe with it all is that the UK was already in an agreement with us that quite obviously was going to be an issue.
No-one over there paid it a thought. Farage? Rees-Mogg? Boris? They don't give a damn.
Whatever chance you may have had addressing this issue first before a referendum, I can't think of anything worse than any Tory government negotiating the GFA and NI/Ireland under the circumstances of the domestic party-political mess they've created.
Aided and abetted I might add by the rest of your parliament. The opposition seem to be playing the same party-political game.
Britain in general has never considered Ireland as an equal partner in anything.

I know your opinion @mcfc1632 and you are committed and entitled to it. I just can't see how any Irish government could take any other stance than the one we have.
Anything else would not be the will of the vast majority of the republic and a considerable few in the North I would wager.

The DUP scuppered whatever chance you had of compromise on a backstop. They have their own insidious agenda (to use one of your words).
They were the tail wagging the dog. The dog having fleas is purely incidental.
 
Merkel says that "practical solutions" will be looked at for the border.

I smell movement.

Yes. In terms of the political declaration and the future relationship ie a close regulatory alignment then the border issue is eased. But the WA and the backstop remain. We really have to stop clutching at straws and engage with reality because that’s the world we live in and reality is hard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top