Var debate 2019/20

its grim up north said:
But the ball was not played to him ,it was a shot at goal.
Click to expand...

Not in this case, I agree. I thought the post I was replying to was more generic in nature.

In this case, I think it was a shot, and a block, which would not have played him onside. I'm not convinced that he was interfering with de Gea playing the ball though.
 
MillionMilesAway said:
Not in this case, I agree. I thought the post I was replying to was more generic in nature.

In this case, I think it was a shot, and a block, which would not have played him onside. I'm not convinced that he was interfering with de Gea playing the ball though.
Click to expand...

A block, or a shit attempt at a clearance?
 
blueinsa said:
Slabhead plays the ball, badly as per usual so how you think its accidental i have no idea?

He plays the lad on, he is not in the keepers eye line because he is on the floor and he makes no attempt to play the ball.

Its a goal unless you are PiGMOB or a paid shill trying to explain to the media its a correct decision.
Click to expand...

That,s was my interpretation off the law..
 
Watched the rugby League highlights on tele last night and great example in the LEEDS game I think on how VAR should work

2 scenarios. First one, ref rules out a try on field but asks booth to check it. All audible, all explanations heard. Call over turned, try given

exact opposite happened later and try not given through booth, though ref had ruled try on field. Again, all transparent, etc.

ref fine with being overturned - just seeking best decision. Fans fully informed all the way

take note PIGMOL
 
Pingu the Penguin said:
Watched the rugby League highlights on tele last night and great example in the LEEDS game I think on how VAR should work

2 scenarios. First one, ref rules out a try on field but asks booth to check it. All audible, all explanations heard. Call over turned, try given

exact opposite happened later and try not given through booth, though ref had ruled try on field. Again, all transparent, etc.

ref fine with being overturned - just seeking best decision. Fans fully informed all the way

take note PIGMOL
Click to expand...

Until the scum start a rugby team..
 
Watching the hockey and the use of VAR is as clear as crystal.
they have a one referral/challenge per team which can only be used for incidents within a certain distance of the goal
The ref asks, and the video assistant is heard, just like cricket. the assistant will not discuss what's happened or what the referee has seen or not seen and will respond with "challenge upheld " or "nothing clear for you to change your decision "
And if the referral is not upheld then the team loses their challenge
 
Not impressed at all with VAR in the derby
It wasn't a free kick to the rags, but Martial looked very close to being a shoulder offside, yet the game kicked off almost immediately. It was like they never looked at it

Now the next two decisions were extremely suspicious but not for being corrupt
Dean books Fred for diving, yet its clearly seen on review that Otamendi kicked his shin
Aguero gets put through on goal, the refs assistant flags and Aguero scores
They review it and manufacture that Aguero is offside
To me it seemed like they weren't going to overrule the two very wrong onfield decisions
But fuck me they took a couple of mins to declare Aguero off and no time at all to rule Martial on
 
dickie davies said:
Not impressed at all with VAR in the derby
It wasn't a free kick to the rags, but Martial looked very close to being a shoulder offside, yet the game kicked off almost immediately. It was like they never looked at it

Now the next two decisions were extremely suspicious but not for being corrupt
Dean books Fred for diving, yet its clearly seen on review that Otamendi kicked his shin
Aguero gets put through on goal, the refs assistant flags and Aguero scores
They review it and manufacture that Aguero is offside
To me it seemed like they weren't going to overrule the two very wrong onfield decisions
But fuck me they took a couple of mins to declare Aguero off and no time at all to rule Martial on
Click to expand...

VAR and PiGMOL together are corrupt . This season has clearly demonstrated it.
 
Don Karleone said:
The Aguero and Martial goals looked roughly the same. One was checked and one wasn't.

It's bent
Click to expand...
I thought at the time that the left back played Aguero on and I haven't seen anything to disprove that. I thought all goals were checked so someone must obviously with the naked eye have been playing Martial on otherwise surely all their stupid lines would have been drawn
 
Don Karleone said:
The Aguero and Martial goals looked roughly the same. One was checked and one wasn't.

It's bent
Click to expand...

It's clearly bent as a nine krone note from the Isle of Man. Dean gives a fuckin' soft free kick for what my ERO labelled a dive. My question to Monsignor Dean is: Having worked at a chicken factory for some time, are you not getting genuine contact in a game mixed up with the knee-deep chicken shit in which you oft found yourself? There's one fuckin' certainty of which we have no need to ask St Michael of Tranmere: Had the same 'foul' been perpetrated upon a blue shirt in the Ragamuffin's penalty area would you have given the penalty?
 
Dave Ewing's Back 'eader said:
It's clearly bent as a nine krone note from the Isle of Man. Dean gives a fuckin' soft free kick for what my ERO labelled a dive. My question to Monsignor Dean is: Having worked at a chicken factory for some time, are you not getting genuine contact in a game mixed up with the knee-deep chicken shit in which you oft found yourself? There's one fuckin' certainty of which we have no need to ask St Michael of Tranmere: Had the same 'foul' been perpetrated upon a blue shirt in the Ragamuffin's penalty area would you have given the penalty?
Click to expand...


Not a chance, and even dean didn't initially give the free kick and had turned away to follow the ball and see city in a good position to break so realised he needed to call it back and award the rags a free kick.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top