The personnel isn’t even the biggest factor, just the insistence on the high press and playing such a high line against teams that have enough quality on the ball to play past the press and then enough pace up front to get behind us and have 1v1s.
Leicester with Vardy have killed us with it.
Scum have beaten us in 3/4 of the last league matches (the other was a draw).
Chelsea/Tuchel have beaten us three times in a row.
Lyon did it last year (when we had 3 CDMs but still played a high line).
Liverpool did it 3 times in 2018.
Against Spurs twice in 2020 (plus conceding 4 in two UCL legs).
Even Arsenal have done it (FA cup).
But Pep just doesn’t seem to learn. The same mistakes against those teams, over and over and where they have that quality on the ball and pace in attack; they take the risk of letting us play in their half and then take their chances when they inevitably come. Restricting us to chances with 8/9/10 players behind the ball and then getting 1v1 chances in return.
Then there’s his experimentalism. Against Liverpool in 2018 he played Laporte at left back for the first time and we lost.
Against Lyon we played Gundo, Dinho and Rodri in midfield (but still a v high line) and we lost.
This year we had neither Rodri nor Dinho for the first time all season.
He’s talked so many times about the difference between winning and losing being what happens in both boxes, but he insisted on not playing the person who’s expertise is getting it right in the box.
I’ll say it again. That despite all the amazing things he has done for us, it is all about him. All about his ego. He will always take the risk of the club suffering if he could end up being seen as a genius.
He’ll stick to his style even if it keeps defeating us and has been worked out, if there’s a possibility that it will end up looking like his ideas were what won us the game.