31 | Ederson - 2022/23 Performances

[Lavinda Past]

You’d go for Ortega over Ederson? I’m glad that Pep makes our team selection

You really don't have a clue about football do you lad?

You're so eaten up by your own argument in defence of a 'favourite' that you don't even try to comprehend what I've written. Your response makes no sense whatsoever.

Some football fans are probably just too thick to understand the game. A reflection of a dumbed down, celebrity inspired society I suppose.

 

[Mr Blue Moon]

You really don't have a clue about football do you lad?

You're so eaten up by your own argument in defence of a 'favourite' that you don't even try to comprehend what I've written. Your response makes no sense whatsoever.

Some football fans are probably just too thick to understand the game. A reflection of a dumbed down, celebrity inspired society I suppose.

…and onto ignore. I’ll leave others to try to have a rational discussion with your condescending crap

 

[mcfcpride]

Unfortunately some City fans want Ederson to have a shit game tonight just to prove their point.

 

[FantasyIreland]

Unfortunately some City fans want Ederson to have a shit game tonight just to prove their point.

Unless you have spoken to such a fucktard,i find that very hard to believe.

 

[David_MCFCx]

That’s all you needed to say. The rest is waffle

Have you ever wondered what the phrase: form is temporary, class is permanent means?

Please go back and watch all our CL exits, Keep your eyes on Ederson
He was more at fault for the Lyon(19/20) game than sterling blunders upon blunders
Tottenham (18/19) game he was at fault for 2 goals conceded
Liverpool game (17/18) he was a disgrace
Madrid(21/22) last year he came out to grab the ball and he couldn't
I wonder what he'll do this year in the CL
We just concede the first shot on target against teams now

 

[Utter bobbins]

Please go back and watch all our CL exits, Keep your eyes on Ederson
He was more at fault for the Lyon(19/20) game than sterling blunders upon blunders
Tottenham (18/19) game he was at fault for 2 goals conceded
Liverpool game (17/18) he was a disgrace
Madrid(21/22) last year he came out to grab the ball and he couldn't
I wonder what he'll do this year in the CL
We just concede the first shot on target against teams now

Made me laugh

 

[Manc Born & Bred]

Please go back and watch all our CL exits, Keep your eyes on Ederson
He was more at fault for the Lyon(19/20) game than sterling blunders upon blunders
Tottenham (18/19) game he was at fault for 2 goals conceded
Liverpool game (17/18) he was a disgrace
Madrid(21/22) last year he came out to grab the ball and he couldn't
I wonder what he'll do this year in the CL
We just concede the first shot on target against teams now

Think the first shot by Forest went out for a throw in, second went in the top tier. Just saying...

 

[Maly]

Please go back and watch all our CL exits, Keep your eyes on Ederson
He was more at fault for the Lyon(19/20) game than sterling blunders upon blunders
Tottenham (18/19) game he was at fault for 2 goals conceded
Liverpool game (17/18) he was a disgrace
Madrid(21/22) last year he came out to grab the ball and he couldn't
I wonder what he'll do this year in the CL
We just concede the first shot on target against teams now

No thanks :)

Do you also have a dossier of the positive impact he makes pretty much every game he plays or just a negative one? ;)

There is no such thing as a perfect goalkeeper. He has loads of positive attributes, along with some, which I think we would all love to see improved

I certainly think his positive impact every game far outweighs his failings, you’re quite entitled to have a different opinion mate & believe there’s a more suited keeper for how Pep wants us to play

If that keeper exists, I’m yet to see them play

 

[mattcity5]

First to say I don't hate Ederson. I'd like nothing more for him to win us trophies with some excellent keeping. But I am a bit torn on things - I would like to see Ortega get a run of games as he seems comfortable on the ball and a good shotstopper. However, I expect that if he had been playing amazing in training all season then maybe he'd get that chance - I can only assume he hasn't impressed enough.

It's just that Ederson's decision making seems off. While I think the penalty given against him for the foul on Nketiah was bollocks, the fact it was bollocks meant people overlooked that Ederson just didn't need to go to him. He should have stayed on his line.

If Ake hadn't cleared it off the line so that the dogshit penalty got given, everyone would have been wondering what he was doing.

Anyway. I know as a team we're stuttering a little at the moment, but I feel this season we're built for the Champions League. Teams will have a bit of a go at us and maybe Ederson's passing will be able to create openings for us. He can be the difference maker - I just hope it's in a positive way.

 

[super_city_si]

Ah, so this is what happens when Grealish plays well.

 

[Lavinda Past]

Ah, so this is what happens when Grealish plays well.

Actually, it could have been a reasonable debate. Had the 'Ederson defenders' taken the time to actually read some of the comments, rather than leap straight into denouncing any 'doubters' as "haters", they may have realised that few (if any) wanted Ederson out.

The majority of 'negative' views related to perceived weaknesses in Ederson's game, i.e. some very basic goalkeeping skills.

As usual on BM, the 'defenders' resorted to one line responses, mostly indicating that they hadn't read the comments made and blindly throwing around daft comments. Typical BM lack of credible debate.

It's a shame. Much like the Jack Grealish and Riyad Mahrez threads, the lunatics frequently take over the asylum, shout down anything they don't agree with, and reasoned discussion becomes impossible.

Never change BM, never change.

 

[Sir peace frog]

Spot on.

The thinking process behind bumping his thread because two other keepers made mistakes is bizarre.

The thinking process behind bumping his thread because he didn't make a mistake and blaming him is a lot more bizarre don't you think

 

[Bentheblue]

Think the first shot by Forest went out for a throw in, second went in the top tier. Just saying...

I think the poster actually said ’first shot on TARGET”. Just sayin.

 

[Saddleworth2]

Most of that is fair comment. However as soon as we concede now up pops the Ederson thread with clown comments and get rid comments, even on Saturday when he was nothing to do with it. Thats what gets peoples backs up.

Then they should respond to clown comments, not those posters that are making genuinely valid comments about the players performance which after all are what these performance threads are for. You won’t find a bigger Eddie fan than I am but the boys technique is sometimes at fault and he could be better through the right coaching.

 

[Manc Born & Bred]

I think the poster actually said ’first shot on TARGET”. Just sayin.

Well he has just saved their first shot on target

 

[city warrior]

Stupid mistake, but he played well. That was probably his best match of the season for me.

 

[BlueMoonie]

Can't believe he set their goal up by putting that shot out for a corner

 

[Lavinda Past]

MOM tonight for me.

Best game of the season for him. Made a mistake for goal by failing to take responsibility in his 6 yard box. Should have been punching the corner clear, but left it to defenders. Otherwise, two very good sharp saves, kept us in the game.

Credit where it's due. The lad done good.

 

[Trojan1962]

Had a good game tonight.

 

[thanatos]

Good game in making the saves he should be making at this level. Awful on the goal. More of the same.