Ref Watch

[mattcity5]

The slow motion angle from behind makes it pretty clear Kehrer kicks Haaland’s foot before making any contact with the ball.

By the way, the commentators in the video I posted are saying they think it is a penalty.

I called pen in real time but could kind of see why the ref wasn't sure.

That said, the angle that's clearest is the one the ref had, from behind the play. Contact on the standing foot while on the way to play the ball. Clear.

Happily we're good enough to overcome these decisions and hopefully we stay that way.

Thought the ref managed the general play well. Definitely better than most, but that's not exactly a glowing endorsement these days.

 

[SebastianBlue]

I called pen in real time but could kind of see why the ref wasn't sure.

That said, the angle that's clearest is the one the ref had, from behind the play. Contact on the standing foot while on the way to play the ball. Clear.

Happily we're good enough to overcome these decisions and hopefully we stay that way.

Thought the ref managed the general play well. Definitely better than most, but that's not exactly a glowing endorsement these days.

Agreed. I actually have more issue with VAR deciding not to ask the ref to review the Haaland incident and the ref missing the foul on Stones (and VAR again choosing not to ask the ref to review).

 

[jimharri]

Can you imagine if refs were like this in the Premier League?

 

[SebastianBlue]

Can you imagine if refs were like this in the Premier League?

This is exactly what I have been saying for the past two years.

 

[Bluearmy]

Can you imagine if refs were like this in the Premier League?

The problem arises that our refs are bent… It will never happen here in a billion years

 

[SebastianBlue]

I have to say, I am very surprised that the league would allow Mariner to wear a different colour shirt to his teammates tonight.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Other than the shit decision not to award Haaland a penalty,i thought he was more than fair last night.

More than fair to Timewaster General Fabianski!

 

[SebastianBlue]

Mariner looked absolutely crushed to have to give that penalty against United.

 

[glyncity]

Mariner looked absolutely crushed to have to give that penalty against United.

No body worked harder than Mariner to keep Utd in the game , you could see the crushed disillusionment in his face as he gave that penalty and to see all his work was for nothing..

 

[Bluearmy]

No body worked harder than Mariner to keep Utd in the game , you could see the crushed disillusionment in his face as he gave that penalty and to see all his work was for nothing..

Body language here tells a lot. Walking away from the area despite the ball being played into the middle of it from the corner. He gives it a fleeting look, knowing full well he will never award a pen no matter what occurs.

Unfortunately for him VAR exists

 

[FantasyIreland]

Marriner must be a rag,no other explanation for his inept,almost corrupt,performance last night.

The penalty was out of his hands,it was impossible to reject......he was indeed gutted to see his boys fucked over with the last kick......for the rest of us,it was a thing of fucking beauty.

 

[SebastianBlue]

 

[Gordyola]

Mariner looked absolutely crushed to have to give that penalty against United.

Yeah Seagulls are a nuisance to Mariners

 

[TinFoilHat]

Every fucking game.

We are reffed differently.

 

[blueinsa]

He spent 90 minutes blocking our passing lanes and got closer to Gundog and Kev than any Leeds players did.

 

[simmo]

Something needs to be done about teams going to the touchline. The free kick we should have been allowed to take whilst they messed about and not being ready.

 

[creditunionhero]

Something needs to be done about teams going to the touchline. The free kick we should have been allowed to take whilst they messed about and not being ready.

That really annoyed me. He had no legitimate reason to to force us to retake that kick.

 

[SebastianBlue]

This remains one of the clearest examples of ref corruption in one of our matches (along with the Kane and Alli tackles).

 

[Gray]

I distrust Madley but he was not overly bad yesterday.

Issues were Leeds keeper time wasting which didn’t matter when we went ahead. The two on one tackle on Kev which went unpunished and the additional time at the end of the game.

No VAR issues thankfully.

P.S. Leeds head and shoulders the worse team to appear at the Etihad this season, City strolled through the game barely breaking sweat.

 

[blue b4 the moon]

Apart from just looking at the keeper rather than booking him early on,apparently it falls under 'Eddie's rule' and not flashing a few yellows at the Leeds players, although standards are low he had one of the best performances of a Prem ref at our pad this season.