It's Quiet 18 - Wanna ring the bell?

[Kamaro011]

the question why Wirtz and Barella were not the first choice from the beginning , It would ve been exceptional transfer window

Coz the City have their own list of priority and the probability if they can be signed or not?

 

[Kamaro011]

The pile-on on Kalvin Phillips is so unnecessary. Can we keep this thread for discussion about potential signings, rather than a constant slagging off of a player who has been injured, had an operation, and has played very few minutes?

Yeah it's been boring same shit over and over again, talks about it elsewhere where the hateboner for him will be piled on there.

 

[Rammy Blue]

Bit like your post mentioning how you like Kelvin and then use, but are happy to follow the others who keep digging him out.

That makes no sense either.

 

[MichaelBBack]

I don’t understand comments like this, it isn’t a “pile on”, it’s just stating a fact that our manager is not interested in playing him.

It absolutely is a pile-on.

We get it. A lot of people want him gone. It doesn't need to come up this many times in a thread which is primarily supposed to be about rumoured incomings and outgoings. The lad's own "Player Performance" thread is approaching 100 pages, for crying out loud, despite him not playing a minute, mostly made up of people having a go and making inferences about his intelligence, for some reason. It's embarrassing, frankly, to have so many people repeating the same old stuff over and over and over again and often appearing to take such joy in bringing one of our own players down. I pray for his own mental health that the lad never actually takes a look on the forum to see what people have said about him.

And fair enough, there's a discussion to be had about KP and why we bought him and what we're gonna do with him. Of course there is, but when I repeatedly see him called thick, a "dimwit", a "moron", insulted for laughing, insulted for not laughing, insulted for sitting on the bench, insulting for not being subbed, and so on, ad bloody nauseam, in almost every thread on the forum, then yes, it falls into "pile-on" territory.

It isn't his fault we bought him. It isn't his fault we potentially made a mistake and wasted the money. At the end of last season, he seemed committed to getting in shape, listening to Pep, and trying to work his way into contention. By any measure, surely that deserves respect, and he's well within his rights to want to try to play for us. He had one injury-ravaged season, and by the time he was in a physical condition to possibly play, we were chasing a history-making treble and he had next-to-no shot of getting in the team. He's allowed to have a bit of hope that his second season might be better, isn't he?

Maybe not. Maybe after a friendly and two league games "the penny should drop" and he should "fuck off for the sake of his career, the dimwit". Honestly...

Back on the actual topic (sorry), very interested that Barella's name has apparently come up. He's a player I've really rated the past couple of years, like a lot of people. Seems very consistent and versatile, which are obviously qualities that we tend to enjoy a lot.

Time's a tickin' away though now... Frankly, I'll be glad to see the end of this transfer window and just focus on the football. It's been a mess, let's be honest. I don't think it's been a bad window, necessarily, but it hasn't been a world-beater, either. Still time for it to get better though, and even if we end up with what we've got, I always have faith in Pep to figure out a way to make it work.

 

[sd33]

if club is going for barella or wirtz they better be ready to pay for them

 

[Barcon]

It absolutely is a pile-on.

We get it. A lot of people want him gone. It doesn't need to come up this many times in a thread which is primarily supposed to be about rumoured incomings and outgoings. The lad's own "Player Performance" thread is approaching 100 pages, for crying out loud, despite him not playing a minute, mostly made up of people having a go and making inferences about his intelligence, for some reason. It's embarrassing, frankly, to have so many people repeating the same old stuff over and over and over again and often appearing to take such joy in bringing one of our own players down. I pray for his own mental health that the lad never actually takes a look on the forum to see what people have said about him.

And fair enough, there's a discussion to be had about KP and why we bought him and what we're gonna do with him. Of course there is, but when I repeatedly see him called thick, a "dimwit", a "moron", insulted for laughing, insulted for not laughing, insulted for sitting on the bench, insulting for not being subbed, and so on, ad bloody nauseam, in almost every thread on the forum, then yes, it falls into "pile-on" territory.

It isn't his fault we bought him. It isn't his fault we potentially made a mistake and wasted the money. At the end of last season, he seemed committed to getting in shape, listening to Pep, and trying to work his way into contention. By any measure, surely that deserves respect, and he's well within his rights to want to try to play for us. He had one injury-ravaged season, and by the time he was in a physical condition to possibly play, we were chasing a history-making treble and he had next-to-no shot of getting in the team. He's allowed to have a bit of hope that his second season might be better, isn't he?

Maybe not. Maybe after a friendly and two league games "the penny should drop" and he should "fuck off for the sake of his career, the dimwit". Honestly...

Back on the actual topic (sorry), very interested that Barella's name has apparently come up. He's a player I've really rated the past couple of years, like a lot of people. Seems very consistent and versatile, which are obviously qualities that we tend to enjoy a lot.

Time's a tickin' away though now... Frankly, I'll be glad to see the end of this transfer window and just focus on the football. It's been a mess, let's be honest. I don't think it's been a bad window, necessarily, but it hasn't been a world-beater, either. Still time for it to get better though, and even if we end up with what we've got, I always have faith in Pep to figure out a way to make it work.

Nobody likes a talker.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

That makes no sense either.

Then put me on ignore ffs

 

[Kamaro011]

It absolutely is a pile-on.

We get it. A lot of people want him gone. It doesn't need to come up this many times in a thread which is primarily supposed to be about rumoured incomings and outgoings. The lad's own "Player Performance" thread is approaching 100 pages, for crying out loud, despite him not playing a minute, mostly made up of people having a go and making inferences about his intelligence, for some reason. It's embarrassing, frankly, to have so many people repeating the same old stuff over and over and over again and often appearing to take such joy in bringing one of our own players down. I pray for his own mental health that the lad never actually takes a look on the forum to see what people have said about him.

And fair enough, there's a discussion to be had about KP and why we bought him and what we're gonna do with him. Of course there is, but when I repeatedly see him called thick, a "dimwit", a "moron", insulted for laughing, insulted for not laughing, insulted for sitting on the bench, insulting for not being subbed, and so on, ad bloody nauseam, in almost every thread on the forum, then yes, it falls into "pile-on" territory.

It isn't his fault we bought him. It isn't his fault we potentially made a mistake and wasted the money. At the end of last season, he seemed committed to getting in shape, listening to Pep, and trying to work his way into contention. By any measure, surely that deserves respect, and he's well within his rights to want to try to play for us. He had one injury-ravaged season, and by the time he was in a physical condition to possibly play, we were chasing a history-making treble and he had next-to-no shot of getting in the team. He's allowed to have a bit of hope that his second season might be better, isn't he?

Maybe not. Maybe after a friendly and two league games "the penny should drop" and he should "fuck off for the sake of his career, the dimwit". Honestly...

This, is not about criticizing about his footballing skill anymore. It's now become an obsession and hatred for some people in internet against Philips.

 

[ElMago_DSilva]

I'd rather Wirtz. Barella is your run of the mill all round good midfielder. He is Kovacic with a shot. Wirtz is special. Him and Foden as the future of AM is mouth watering

I'd absolutely love Wirtz, but the chance of getting him this window is like 1%.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

I'd absolutely love Wirtz, but the chance of getting him this window is like 1%.

Better than 0 chance then

 

[Ehza]

I'd absolutely love Wirtz, but the chance of getting him this window is like 1%.

So you're saying there's a chance?

 

[Roachy]

The pile-on on Kalvin Phillips is so unnecessary. Can we keep this thread for discussion about potential signings, rather than a constant slagging off of a player who has been injured, had an operation, and has played very few minutes?

Stop preaching mate. If I could be arsed looking they'd be plenty of your comments bearing no relevance to the thread they're posted on. The comment about Kalvin was directly linked to the lack of cover in that area and it's ramifications.

 

[Kamaro011]

Stop preaching mate. If I could be arsed looking they'd be plenty of your comments bearing no relevance to the thread they're posted on. The comment about Kalvin was directly linked to the lack of cover in that area and it's ramifications.

Because when one starting comment about Philips the other starting to comment about it too starting chains of post dicussing Philips and none of it about transfer anymore.

 

[Gigant]

Need spacing and crossing

Grealish ,Walker , Bernardo , Foden when playing on the wing ,cant cross even if they life is on it

 

[Fordyboy46]

I don't think Pep will be at all happy if we fail to bring anybody else in this window

 

[Roachy]

Because when one starting comment about Philips the other starting to comment about it too starting chains of post dicussing Philips and none of it about transfer anymore.

Just like this post.

 

[KingGeorge]

I don't think Pep will be at all happy if we fail to bring anybody else in this window

I think we will win the league again if we can find some depth.

 

[SoulFood009]

Just the 350m on two players eh! Easy this transfer lark.

Neither was coming here. They both wanted different teams. Some fans are in cuckoo land

 

[Fordyboy46]

I think we will win the league again if we can find some depth.

Attacking midfielder, right winger and we're good to go. Laporte, Cancelo and I reckon Palmer to go

 

[oldius]

Stop preaching mate. If I could be arsed looking they'd be plenty of your comments bearing no relevance to the thread they're posted on. The comment about Kalvin was directly linked to the lack of cover in that area and it's ramifications.

It isn't only about where they are, it is the constant negativity directed at him. As I said, it is as much about tone as anything else.