PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

I'm certain that the panel won't be taking any potential geopolitical consequences into account and I wouldn't want them to either. We are either innocent of the charges after due consideration or we aren't. Why should we get away with something on the basis that our owner wouldn't invest billions in Sizewell if we were punished for example? We as a support base would be outraged if that was the case with a rival club so you have to be consistent.

Obviously I want us to be cleared and for this to finally go away but not on the basis of threats or undue financial pressure. I also think that people are over estimating the influence our owner could bring to bear on the UK government. Yes Abu Dhabi invests in UK projects but the country wouldn't collapse if it didn't.

I couldn’t care less how we win the case as long as we win it.

The whole premise of FFP/sustainability is designed to be unfair. Rivals have attempted to load the dice from day one and will continue to do so.

This is no time to be noble or take a knife to a gunfight.

Just win the case and move on.
 
I couldn’t care less how we win the case as long as we win it.

The whole premise of FFP/sustainability is designed to be unfair. Rivals have attempted to load the dice from day one and will continue to do so.

This is no time to be noble or take a knife to a gunfight.

Just win the case and move on.
Absolutely, the SAS can assault the PL hq on government orders as far as I'm concerned.
 
Have any of our accountants/auditors/sponsors moved to distance themselves from us? You would have thought if there was even a whiff that we may have misled them in any way or engaged in dubious accounting practices they would be queuing up to do so.
we only use them on High street an they need work
 
I couldn’t care less how we win the case as long as we win it.

The whole premise of FFP/sustainability is designed to be unfair. Rivals have attempted to load the dice from day one and will continue to do so.

This is no time to be noble or take a knife to a gunfight.

Just win the case and move on.
Regardless of yours or mine personal views I think the time for getting these charges binned on the back of political and financial pressure on the government has well and truly passed by. If the government was then going to lean on the PL then the time to do that was before '115' charges were laid.

Clearly the PL weren't giving it any consideration and the independent panel will not even entertain it. They will reach a conclusion based on what's before them.
 
As they say the right word in the right ear can make a big difference. Having seen the kangaroo court that Everton have faced mainly because Masters came up with the PL sanctions policy after the tribunal had started as far as I am aware. It is clear that the process we will face will be highly politicised with heavy influence from the clubs that spend a lot of time thinking about the past. For these reasons, City need to talk to whoever they need to talk to to either ensure a fair impartial process happens or that the circus of a tribunal, if that is what it will be, should be shut down. I have no idea who that is, but Khaldoon is very well connected, so I am sure this is something City are managing behind the scenes.
 
I'm certain that the panel won't be taking any potential geopolitical consequences into account and I wouldn't want them to either. We are either innocent of the charges after due consideration or we aren't. Why should we get away with something on the basis that our owner wouldn't invest billions in Sizewell if we were punished for example? We as a support base would be outraged if that was the case with a rival club so you have to be consistent.

Obviously I want us to be cleared and for this to finally go away but not on the basis of threats or undue financial pressure. I also think that people are over estimating the influence our owner could bring to bear on the UK government. Yes Abu Dhabi invests in UK projects but the country wouldn't collapse if it didn't.
This World you inhabit........
 
I get where you are coming from but many things are linked the PL is a massive earner for this country, and seeing it successful is a political and economic priority, that thee is a battle over regulation going on between the government and the PL there can be no doubt
I think that pressure will be put on the government to get the regulator in place before the kangaroo court sits and replace the Premier Leagues disciplinary regime with that of the regulator. This would involve agreeing a sanctions policy with the Premier League clubs but implemented and enforced by the regulatory body.
 
Seeing khaldoon talking about the investment into the UK etc and Hunt saying how vital it is etc then no way we get done for anything imo now.
I’d have to agree, it’s monumentally stupid what the premier league have done under pressure. They really are an embarrassing organisation… I’d imagine Khaldoon sleeps very peacefully at night.
 
I can see your point, and agree that it's daft to suggest we're all apologists for the UAE, but it's surely easier to make the link where the people clearly support just one team, and that team is owned by an entity linked to a state. Sports where the occasional event is held in a state, or where people are "fans" of individuals etc. are very different.

In other sports it's often the players who are the ones getting grief. The LIV golfers certainly got a shitstorm raining down on them (albeit things have got more complex since), and the players who went to Saudi faced plenty of criticism. Bein and Qatar have also been linked to sportswashing repeatedly in the media, but there isn't really a Bein fanbase to attack.

The other key difference in being fans of a team, rather than individuals, a sport, or a TV station, is of course that you have more obvious rivals. Rivalry between supporters is almost entirely based on hypocrisy. Their players are shit, our are great. They get all the decisions, we get hard done to. Their owners are worse than ours.
There's just been the F1 Grand Prix in Abu Dhabi. Did you hear the word 'sportswashing' mentioned at any point over the weekend in relation to that?
 
for people that say we are cheating, it isnt cheating. Cheating would be establishing yourself as a top club then banning other clubs from getting investment to compete while you continue to buy all the best players from anyone else (smaller clubs who need money) giving them no chance of ever catching you.
This is like if a chess player got an extra piece for the next game whenever they won a tournament. And in the case of (man united) one of the chess players got insane media coverage like they are the second coming of Christ. Then when another player came along with another method of getting pieces they quickly came up with some new rules to stop this new player from competing with the established "best".
And moreover, when this new player showed that it wasnt the second coming of Christ that had made the media favourite (man united) so good, it was actually all the extra pieces, they all cried CHEAT ! CHEAT!

Most people are really just parroting each others thoughts with out actually thinking about how modern football works.
 
There's just been the F1 Grand Prix in Abu Dhabi. Did you hear the word 'sportswashing' mentioned at any point over the weekend in relation to that?
I didn't watch it :)

But as someone who isn't a fan of F1 I've heard plenty of stuff about sportswashing. You can google f1 and sportswashing and plenty of stuff comes up. Not very scientific, but if I google Man City and Sportswashing, I get less results.

I watch every Man City match I can't attend in person, and it almost never comes up in the commentary there. Even in the Guardian, for every article that mentions sportswashing, there are hundreds that talk about football.

ps. I'm not saying that City don't get a lot of grief - just that it's often from Liverpool or United fans in the media, or online, whereas there aren't really people who are fans of the British Grand Prix and see the Abu Dhabi one as their sporting rival, so it's going to be more visible in football.
 
There's just been the F1 Grand Prix in Abu Dhabi. Did you hear the word 'sportswashing' mentioned at any point over the weekend in relation to that?
Exactly...if they pulled out of horse racing in this country and that includes sponsorship for our biggest races,100s of people would lose jobs and Newmarket would be in trouble along with the rest of racing...not a peep out of the usual suspects about horse washing...set of twats...
 
I'm certain that the panel won't be taking any potential geopolitical consequences into account and I wouldn't want them to either. We are either innocent of the charges after due consideration or we aren't. Why should we get away with something on the basis that our owner wouldn't invest billions in Sizewell if we were punished for example? We as a support base would be outraged if that was the case with a rival club so you have to be consistent.

Obviously I want us to be cleared and for this to finally go away but not on the basis of threats or undue financial pressure. I also think that people are over estimating the influence our owner could bring to bear on the UK government. Yes Abu Dhabi invests in UK projects but the country wouldn't collapse if it didn't.
To be clear, you're in favor of bringing a knife to a gun fight or more like looking for a bare knuckle brawl against an AK47...not me...
 
Regardless of yours or mine personal views I think the time for getting these charges binned on the back of political and financial pressure on the government has well and truly passed by. If the government was then going to lean on the PL then the time to do that was before '115' charges were laid.

Clearly the PL weren't giving it any consideration and the independent panel will not even entertain it. They will reach a conclusion based on what's before them.
It's not that cut and dried...I'm afraid your opinion is much too narrow for a case of this magnitude...I still get a few gifts every Christmas but I've known there is no Santa Claus for many, many years...
 
It's not that cut and dried...I'm afraid your opinion is much too narrow for a case of this magnitude...I still get a few gifts every Christmas but I've known there is no Santa Claus for many, many years...
I still think the time to do it was before any charges had been laid. Too late now other than to demand a fair process from the panel.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top