City Vs Bournemouth Post Match Thread

CaliforniaBlue said:
It's bad enough that reporters often show their ignorance of the rules, but it drives me up the wall when the 'expert analyst' in the commentary booth, who's usually a former professional player, is equally ignorant.
Click to expand...
Many have their own agenda, had this been a united/liverpool goal, it wouldn't even have been mentioned as offside, being a pundit is easy, you just support the agenda you're asked to do.
 
I was a little nervous given our injuries and the fact that many newly promoted teams use a game against us as a cup final and we don't always take them as serious as we should, but we seemed very comfortable for most of the game, and some excellent game management in the 2nd half ensure for a rather boring but effective half, so I am pleased a couple of very tough games coming up now for us now
 
OB1 said:
We still give too many cheap freekicks away and I thought one or two corners were unecessary.
Click to expand...
Totally agree, we'll get punished by better sides.

Listened to a couple of Bournemouth fans on the train coming home, they thought Bournemouth were shite today, picked the wrong formation (I agree there, they were too open at the start), but they thought they should have had more of a go at us, I thought that was their downfall, they should have been more defensive early on for me, allowing us to counter attack was a serious mistake from Howe, who incidentally I have a lot of time for. Interesting that perspectives from both sides can be so different.
 
cleavers said:
Totally agree, we'll get punished by better sides.

Listened to a couple of Bournemouth fans on the train coming home, they thought Bournemouth were shite today, picked the wrong formation (I agree there, they were too open at the start), but they thought they should have had more of a go at us, I thought that was their downfall, they should have been more defensive early on for me, allowing us to counter attack was a serious mistake from Howe, who incidentally I have a lot of time for. Interesting that perspectives from both sides can be so different.
Click to expand...

Yes, it is sometimes interesting to hear how other fans view things.

I thought their pressing caused us some problems but it is very dangerous to come and have a go a City because, despite our perceived defensve frailties, you are more likely to get picked off by City than score against us. I thought their attempts to press us got less effective when Yaya dropped a little deeper: he is very difficult to dispossess and has a high degree of pass accuracy.

Howe is one to watch; although it is hard to envisage an Englishman managing City in the next ten years.
 
OB1 said:
Howe is one to watch; although it is hard to envisage an Englishman managing City in the next ten years.
Click to expand...
Oh I don't think he'll end up here, but I can see him in a top job somewhere.

If I was him (and no disrespect to Bournemouth) I'd be looking for experience in Spain, Germany, or Italy, he's doing a good job on the south coast for now, but there will be plenty looking at him in the next few years, not just in England.
 
The way Howe set up for me today put him in the Rodgers boat for me, naive at best.

However, the way Bournemouth moved the ball, worked and played some tidy stuff, said to me that with better players, he'd do a good job. My doubts about him are exposing his defence, his stubbornness to stick with that style when his team have had to step up a level and you need to be pragmatic, and his obvious "need to be in a happy place which isn't the North" spiel.

I think the experience of Sanchez Flores and the way he set Watford up against us showed which manager had that bit of nous and extra knowledge.
 
First half I felt like we could score every time we went forward, foot off gas in the second, all in all great day out and great curry in the swadesh with BG74 to finish the day, got a smile on my face :)
 
JoeMercer'sWay said:
The way Howe set up for me today put him in the Rodgers boat for me, naive at best.

However, the way Bournemouth moved the ball, worked and played some tidy stuff, said to me that with better players, he'd do a good job. My doubts about him are exposing his defence, his stubbornness to stick with that style when his team have had to step up a level and you need to be pragmatic, and his obvious "need to be in a happy place which isn't the North" spiel.

I think the experience of Sanchez Flores and the way he set Watford up against us showed which manager had that bit of nous and extra knowledge.
Click to expand...
Good points as always, I thought it was interesting that the Bournemouth lads on the train thought he was too defensive today, and picked the wrong formation too, however even off form, we are difficult opponents, if you have a go, because we have too many players who can hurt any side.

Perhaps had they got the penalty, and gone in front, we might have found it a very different game.

I think he's a good manager, and far better than Rodgers, he'll learn a lot from today, Rodgers would just have tried something or someone different, as he didn't understand that Suarez carried them.

I don't think he'll go away to the top clubs again and be as open as that from the start, but we'll see, its a tough learning experience in the PL, but I think he shows an ability to learn.
 
cleavers said:
Good points as always, I thought it was interesting that the Bournemouth lads on the train thought he was too defensive today, and picked the wrong formation too, however even off form, we are difficult opponents, if you have a go, because we have too many players who can hurt any side.

Perhaps had they got the penalty, and gone in front, we might have found it a very different game.

I think he's a good manager, and far better than Rodgers, he'll learn a lot from today, Rodgers would just have tried something or someone different, as he didn't understand that Suarez carried them.

I don't think he'll go away to the top clubs again and be as open as that from the start, but we'll see, its a tough learning experience in the PL, but I think he shows an ability to learn.
Click to expand...

yeah, they're spoiled if they think that was defensive today, far too open considering their defence consisted of a bunch of championship players, a back-up keeper and Distin, who was playing League 1 standard football for Everton last season and can't run.

If they play away like that much more often we won't see them at the Etihad next season, you need to play with what you've got relative to your opposition, not what you want to have. Howe played like he had Arsenal's squad at his disposal, and if we'd had a fully fit side who didn't have bigger fish to fry this week, it could have been much worse.
 
JoeMercer'sWay said:
Howe played like he had Arsenal's squad at his disposal, and if we'd had a fully fit side who didn't have bigger fish to fry this week, it could have been much worse.
Click to expand...
Yes I agree, and he cut a frustrated figure on the touchline, as I said he played into our hands, naive or brave (stupid), but I think he'll learn.

Their away results are mixed, should have won at Liverpool, but lost, won at West Ham, but 3 defeats since that, at Norwich, Stoke, and today, so maybe he isn't learning :)

Their home form will be key to whether they stay up, 1 win, 2 draws, 1 defeat so far.....
 
Prestwich_Blue said:
NO. IT. WASN'T. How many fucking times?

The defender was in play as he left the field without permission. The FA's own rule book makes this abundantly clear.
Click to expand...
Exactly. The TV company were editing it like they don't know the rules to football, as if there was something controversial about it.
 
I think Sagna has had a great season so far, slotting in on the left and making some good runs down the line.

Navas' confidence in front of goal has definitely gone AWOL. Perhaps he should stop practicing with those manikins on the training ground. Otherwise he did his usual good shift.

TV replays show that Bournemouth should have had a penalty.

Kelechi was definitely on side.

Sterling had a good game centrally and worked well with Bony.

De Bruyne was really unlucky with those two shots - shame the goalie decided to make those really good saves.

Nasri reduced us to 10 men. Is he still injured?

Far, far too many silly fouls committed in our half - sort it out MP, quickly.

Other than that a really good result especially considering our injuries.
 
Healdplace said:
It was a shame for Iheanacho - no question - as he took it brilliantly - but what everyone is forgetting is that the first goal was offside (as the defender in front of him was off the pitch) and in the context of the game that wrong decision going in our favour was better than not getting a sixth very late on due to another bad decision.
Click to expand...

You have completely no idea about the offside rule ......!! The first goal WASNT OFFSIDE. Please refrain from posting such rubbish!!
 
Healdplace said:
Yes, as noted above the player who would have played him on was off the pitch at the time the pass was played though came on afterwards. Probably why the linesman missed it. But that went in our favour at a key time. As did the Otamendi tackle where he missed the ball and then handled it on the slide through. Both were accidents but we all know many referees would have given a penalty and that was also a key decision that went for us. So overall we should not complain today about the officiating.
Click to expand...

Still wrong...!! How many people don't understand the laws of the game...!! The linesman didn't miss anything...!
 
Bluearmy said:
Still wrong...!! How many people don't understand the laws of the game...!! The linesman didn't miss anything...!
Click to expand...
I've watched the replay of the first goal a few times and it shows that by the time Bony prodded the ball through the defender was back on the pitch. And if you look closely he didn't appeal for offside as he knew that he was playing Sterling onside.
 
Bluekiwi said:
I've watched the replay of the first goal a few times and it shows that by the time Bony prodded the ball through the defender was back on the pitch. And if you look closely he didn't appeal for offside as he knew that he was playing Sterling onside.
Click to expand...
It doesn't matter if he's back on or not, he left the field without permission. He's still regarded as an active player.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top