Pep and the club's decision-makers wanted him. They were willing to spend 100m on him, in a Summer where they were also looking to spend even more on Kane.
He was a luxury signing in the sense that he wasn't really plugging a gap. We weren't assessing alternatives or lining up who we'd get if we couldn't get him. We would have done without.
But - a player Pep loves, with a release clause that was due to expire. It was a case of spending 100m last summer or potentially never getting him, because he wouldn't have forced a move from Villa and their owners are rich enough to refuse.
In that context it was hard for him to land with a splash. The fans were crying out for a striker, not an inverted winger.
But, he's been learning his role - which is quite different to what was expected of him at Villa - and he's been improving. Pep still loves him. The dressing room loves him. And he's getting the game time he needs to grow more into the side.
I'll judge his value when he leaves. Who knows what might happen in the interim.