31 | Ederson - 2022/23 Performances

[Kamaro011]

Id get courtois/neuer in a heartbeat though

Prime Neuer yes, Cortouis no.

 

[Lavinda Past]

Whatever Pep thinks you know better, okay. The suggestion Pep or any top coach for that matter would tolerate him not working hard in training is, frankly ridiculous.

You just keep going round in circles. You're obviously not actually paying attention to my comments, probably because you're closed to any perceived criticism of City players.

I've gone into detail on here about what I see as Ederson's weaknesses as a goalkeeper. I'll say it one last time for the hard of thinking...

I don't think that Ederson works hard enough on the basics. Regardless of what Pep or anyone else thinks, that, in my opinion, is where he needs to improve his game.

Try taking off your blinkers for a while and accept that not every City fan believes that everything is as perfect as you seem to.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

You just keep going round in circles. You're obviously not actually paying attention to my comments, probably because you're closed to any perceived criticism of City players.

I've gone into detail on here about what I see as Ederson's weaknesses as a goalkeeper. I'll say it one last time for the hard of thinking...

I don't think that Ederson works hard enough on the basics. Regardless of what Pep or anyone else thinks, that, in my opinion, is where he needs to improve his game.

Try taking off your blinkers for a while and accept that not every City fan believes that everything is as perfect as you seem to.

Serious question, do you believe that Pep would ever allow a player who he believed had fundamental problems with aspects of his game, application or commitment in training etc, to play on a regular basis in this City team ?

 

[Bluewars]

Serious question, do you believe that Pep would ever allow a player who he believed had fundamental problems with aspects of his game, application or commitment in training etc, to play on a regular basis in this City team ?

Yes, Joao Cancelo.

 

[blueparrot]

You just keep going round in circles. You're obviously not actually paying attention to my comments, probably because you're closed to any perceived criticism of City players.

I've gone into detail on here about what I see as Ederson's weaknesses as a goalkeeper. I'll say it one last time for the hard of thinking...

I don't think that Ederson works hard enough on the basics. Regardless of what Pep or anyone else thinks, that, in my opinion, is where he needs to improve his game.

Try taking off your blinkers for a while and accept that not every City fan believes that everything is as perfect as you seem to.

Not saying he’s perfect, not saying any player is. I’m saying the opposite in fact nobody is perfect, but you think a player at his level and a coaches at the level ours are don’t try and improve every part of the players game and work every day at it, then what exactly do you think they do in training.
No player including Ederson will be great at everything, but to think they and he don’t work hard on all parts of his game and every players game shows a lack of understanding how professional and meticulous our club and it’s coaches are.

 

[Scottyboi]

That Alisson fella looks good.

 

[Lavinda Past]

Serious question, do you believe that Pep would ever allow a player who he believed had fundamental problems with aspects of his game, application or commitment in training etc, to play on a regular basis in this City team ?

Yes. As i see it, Pep Guardiola doesn't see his keeper as a keeper. He sees them as a sweeper.
That's why I think the Golden Glove awards are a reflection of the whole defence rather than Ederson.

 

[Lavinda Past]

Not saying he’s perfect, not saying any player is. I’m saying the opposite in fact nobody is perfect, but you think a player at his level and a coaches at the level ours are don’t try and improve every part of the players game and work every day at it, then what exactly do you think they do in training.
No player including Ederson will be great at everything, but to think they and he don’t work hard on all parts of his game and every players game shows a lack of understanding how professional and meticulous our club and it’s coaches are.

**shakes head in disbelief**

 

[blueparrot]

**shakes head in disbelief**

So you dont beleive players and coaches work hard at improving their games , fair enough, carry on.

 

[Colin Bells Boots]

Yes. As i see it, Pep Guardiola doesn't see his keeper as a keeper. He sees them as a sweeper.
That's why I think the Golden Glove awards are a reflection of the whole defence rather than Ederson.

Ok - not that I agree as Pep is not a manager who imo is accepting of such fundamental matters, but if that is what you believe.