A NEW POLL - Hughes, IN OR OUT?

[badge]

You are all soooooooooo right, get a new manager in.

It's a proven strategy, and they must be falling over themselves to take the job, especially with the way they are backed to the hilt, through thick and thin.

squirtyflower, please explain what evidence there is to suggest that mark hughes will come good?

 

[Uwe Rosler's Grandad]

You are all soooooooooo right, get a new manager in.

It's a proven strategy, and they must be falling over themselves to take the job, especially with the way they are backed to the hilt, through thick and thin.

squirtyflower, please explain what evidence there is to suggest that mark hughes will come good?

Yeah - what is Hughes doing right? Which players has he improved during the season? Which players has he bought that have been value for money? Which haven't? etc etc

 

[squirtyflower]

My argument wasn't based on the new owners, but us generally as a club.

The new owners seem to have their heads screwed on Cheesy, which is more than can be said about the way our club has gone about its business in the past.

But I still think you can't build success through constant change.

Our last successful manager was Tony Book, 74-79, and I know he had lots of interim jobs after that when we sacked his army of replacements. Since then no-one has been in the job as long.

 

[squirtyflower]

I'm not here as a Hughes defender.

I'm just pointing out the folly of our ways since 1979.

 

[ConnorMCFC]

You are all soooooooooo right, get a new manager in.

It's a proven strategy, and they must be falling over themselves to take the job, especially with the way they are backed to the hilt, through thick and thin.

squirtyflower, please explain what evidence there is to suggest that mark hughes will come good?

Yeah - what is Hughes doing right? Which players has he improved during the season? Which players has he bought that have been value for money? Which haven't? etc etc

ireland - Hughes stopped him being sold to sunderland and has improved greatly
given - great signing
zab - great signing
SWP - great signing
Kompany - great signing
Ned - improved from previous seasons

berti :-)

 

[Uwe Rosler's Grandad]

I'm not here as a Hughes defender.

I'm just pointing out the folly of our ways since 1979.

You can't have it both ways...on the one hand saying changing managers isn't good but on the other hand not defending Hughes to stay.

The question to you should be...do we persevere with an underperforming manager who looks like he has lost the dressing room or should we change at the end of this season?

 

[badge]

You are all soooooooooo right, get a new manager in.

It's a proven strategy, and they must be falling over themselves to take the job, especially with the way they are backed to the hilt, through thick and thin.

squirtyflower, please explain what evidence there is to suggest that mark hughes will come good?

Yeah - what is Hughes doing right? Which players has he improved during the season? Which players has he bought that have been value for money? Which haven't? etc etc

ireland - Hughes stopped him being sold to sunderland and has improved greatly
given - great signing
zab - great signing
SWP - great signing
Kompany - great signing
Ned - improved from previous seasons

berti :-)

and what about bellamy?

and anyway, if all these players are such great signings, and i happen to agree they are, why is the team still shit? why are we employing two holding midfielders at home to fulham (a team that incidentally increased the number of away goals they've scored this season by fifty percent, in one match!)

 

[hgblue]

You are all soooooooooo right, get a new manager in.

It's a proven strategy, and they must be falling over themselves to take the job, especially with the way they are backed to the hilt, through thick and thin.

Every top manager knows the way of the world, and for you to suggest otherwise is very naive. NOBODY expected Hughes to win the league, or finish top four, this season. What Hughes needed to do was show SOMETHING that the owners could say 'this guy is worth making a central part of our project, and investing many millions of pounds based on his judgement'. He has absolutely failed to do this. The new manager, whoever that may be, will have enough bottle and faith in his own ability to believe that he will be able to improve performances sufficiently (given the right financial backing), to give himself the time needed to bring the stability and success that we all crave.

 

[moomba]

We had a team that demonstrated relegation form in the second half of last season

Our results in 2009 are roughly 0.277778 of a point per game better than the results from the first half of 2008. A point better nearly every 4 games we play, thats certainly £120m well spent.

 

[Rammy Blue]

out out out.