You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Aguero's penalty
- Thread starter robinhood CITY
- Start date
Re: Agueros penalty
The shot was on target. The keeper attempted to save it. The attempt was unsuccessful. Ball ended up in the back of the net. Aguero's goal.
pudge said:Well if Yaya got his against West Ham a few seasons ago it wouldn't surprise me that much to see Aguero get credit for his, and I hope he does.Corky said:pudge said:Hence why Dzeko's was an own goal as it's doesn't go in without hitting the keeper but there's been debates before on here with people claiming it's his.
I look at Aguero's and think it's the same as if Howard parries that shot out and it hits an Everton defender and goes in.
They are on the strikers side though more than they used to be, it wouldn't have been given 10 years ago but I believe it will be given in a month or so's time.
I'll wait and see what the panel says.
The shot was on target. The keeper attempted to save it. The attempt was unsuccessful. Ball ended up in the back of the net. Aguero's goal.
Re: Agueros penalty
But he did save it, hence why it has gone down as a missed penalty for the moment.hgblue said:pudge said:Well if Yaya got his against West Ham a few seasons ago it wouldn't surprise me that much to see Aguero get credit for his, and I hope he does.Corky said:They are on the strikers side though more than they used to be, it wouldn't have been given 10 years ago but I believe it will be given in a month or so's time.
I'll wait and see what the panel says.
The shot was on target. The keeper attempted to save it. The attempt was unsuccessful. Ball ended up in the back of the net. Aguero's goal.
Re: Agueros penalty
The save isn't completed until the ball is in the keeper's hands, it's touched by another outfield player or the ball goes out of play. This will be awrded to Aguero.
pudge said:But he did save it, hence why it has gone down as a missed penalty for the moment.hgblue said:pudge said:Well if Yaya got his against West Ham a few seasons ago it wouldn't surprise me that much to see Aguero get credit for his, and I hope he does.
The shot was on target. The keeper attempted to save it. The attempt was unsuccessful. Ball ended up in the back of the net. Aguero's goal.
The save isn't completed until the ball is in the keeper's hands, it's touched by another outfield player or the ball goes out of play. This will be awrded to Aguero.
Re: Agueros penalty
He missed the penalty and the rebound hit Howard and went in, without the rebound off of him it comes back into play after being diverted off target. Own goal as it stands but history proves it might be changed but I doubt it.
The save is completed when the ball goes off target, which is what happens when it hits the post.hgblue said:pudge said:But he did save it, hence why it has gone down as a missed penalty for the moment.hgblue said:The shot was on target. The keeper attempted to save it. The attempt was unsuccessful. Ball ended up in the back of the net. Aguero's goal.
The save isn't completed until the ball is in the keeper's hands, it's touched by another outfield player or the ball goes out of play. This will be awrded to Aguero.
He missed the penalty and the rebound hit Howard and went in, without the rebound off of him it comes back into play after being diverted off target. Own goal as it stands but history proves it might be changed but I doubt it.
Re: Agueros penalty
We shall see.
pudge said:The save is completed when the ball goes off target, which is what happens when it hits the post.hgblue said:pudge said:But he did save it, hence why it has gone down as a missed penalty for the moment.
The save isn't completed until the ball is in the keeper's hands, it's touched by another outfield player or the ball goes out of play. This will be awrded to Aguero.
He missed the penalty and the rebound hit Howard and went in, without the rebound off of him it comes back into play after being diverted off target. Own goal as it stands but history proves it might be changed but I doubt it.
We shall see.
Re: Agueros penalty
That is results orientated thinking and it doesn't always work. Just because he's not missed one yet doesn't mean he's a good penalty taker and personally his technique doesn't fill me with confidence.
BringBackSwales said:SkyBlueUSA said:It will go down as an OG under the rules. As much of the fuss that Hart gets, Howard had an awful game. Btw I think Yaya should be taking PK's. Dzeko has missed his last couple of PK's, and Aguero sold his too easily today.
Previously Sergio has missed exactly how many penalties for City?
That is results orientated thinking and it doesn't always work. Just because he's not missed one yet doesn't mean he's a good penalty taker and personally his technique doesn't fill me with confidence.
kippaxchris
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Dec 2011
- Messages
- 2,482
Re: Agueros penalty
If a shot is on target the player gets the goal even if its deflected or put in by an opposition player we all know that but should this penalty situation be the same as from my view it was on target and Howard tipped it onto the post it hit him then went in so the original shot was on target or does it change the rule having come back off the post? Anybody know?
If a shot is on target the player gets the goal even if its deflected or put in by an opposition player we all know that but should this penalty situation be the same as from my view it was on target and Howard tipped it onto the post it hit him then went in so the original shot was on target or does it change the rule having come back off the post? Anybody know?
Re: Agueros penalty
Well that's true, but one could argue that Howard wouldn't have been in a position for the ball to rebound off him had he not gotten down to divert the shot in the first place. But oh well, let's just leave it to the panel.
pudge said:The save is completed when the ball goes off target, which is what happens when it hits the post.hgblue said:pudge said:But he did save it, hence why it has gone down as a missed penalty for the moment.
The save isn't completed until the ball is in the keeper's hands, it's touched by another outfield player or the ball goes out of play. This will be awrded to Aguero.
He missed the penalty and the rebound hit Howard and went in, without the rebound off of him it comes back into play after being diverted off target. Own goal as it stands but history proves it might be changed but I doubt it.
Well that's true, but one could argue that Howard wouldn't have been in a position for the ball to rebound off him had he not gotten down to divert the shot in the first place. But oh well, let's just leave it to the panel.
Whitefield Blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 4 Aug 2012
- Messages
- 427
Re: Agueros penalty
I agree with you. He's struck quite a few 'poor' penalties that I call 50/50 ones. I.e. if the keeper goes the right way then he'll save it. Quite fortunate really that the keepers have guessed incorrectly.
SuperYaya said:BringBackSwales said:SkyBlueUSA said:It will go down as an OG under the rules. As much of the fuss that Hart gets, Howard had an awful game. Btw I think Yaya should be taking PK's. Dzeko has missed his last couple of PK's, and Aguero sold his too easily today.
Previously Sergio has missed exactly how many penalties for City?
That is results orientated thinking and it doesn't always work. Just because he's not missed one yet doesn't mean he's a good penalty taker and personally his technique doesn't fill me with confidence.
I agree with you. He's struck quite a few 'poor' penalties that I call 50/50 ones. I.e. if the keeper goes the right way then he'll save it. Quite fortunate really that the keepers have guessed incorrectly.