Assessment of our business this summer | Poll Added

[oakiecokie]

Well I suppose you have to ask are we stronger or weaker than when the window opened?

Honestly I’d say, at best, the same but we will see. I think we missed most of our primary targets Bellingham Rice Paqueta.

5/10 Average

How good is Oscar Bobb as I’ve only seen a few clips?

P.S Still hoping for a creative midfield and a left back (always) with minutes to go!

If someone else doesn`t want to come to our club then we`ve hardly missed out on them.

 

[RayCTID]

Other than the Cole Palmer departure (although not much more we could have been done with that) it has been a solid transfer window for us. 8.5/10

 

[oakiecokie]

Nabbed off twitter.

Well those figures don`t stack up.

 

[Phil1]

There was someone posting on here 2 days ago, giving it a 3.5/10.

There are an awful lot of idiots in the world.

 

[oakiecokie]

There was someone posting on here 2 days ago, giving it a 3.5/10.

And Cobweb has only given us a 5/10. Utterly bemusing.

 

[oakiecokie]

There are an awful lot of idiots in the world.

And unfortunately quite a few on this forum.

 

[Semper aggressus]

I’d say an 8/10, could be 9 depending on how good Doku and Nunes turn out.

Gvardiol is one of the best young defenders in the world, and will be an upgrade on Laporte.

Kovacic has looked superb so far, adds experience and looks like he’s been with us for years.

Doku hopefully brings serious pace and directness which we’ve lacked since Sterling and Sané were in their pomp.

Nunes is another with international and PL experience and will add much needed squad depth. A good signing.

 

[yeah whatever !!]

Great window.

 

[burning blue soul]

I'd certainly like to see it close as soon as the new season starts

yep, as an absolute minimum. and what's with all the staggered closed window times/dates? the whole this is a mess.

 

[burning blue soul]

No that would be worse! At least when it’s over it’s over. Imagine Bernardo to Barca every day for years.

works both ways, though.

 

[DWIFF]

We’ve obviously brought in a number of quality players and Pep will have a plan.
My worry is replacing the circa twenty five goals that Gundogan and Mahrez got between them last season in all competitions.
It’s the heavy goals that I think we’re really going to miss.
Mahrez with two goals plus a match winning performance against Spurs when we were really struggling.
Gundogan’s goals against Liverpool, Leeds, Everton and the rags really got us over the line last season.
If you add the assists of both players, I think we’re really going to struggle to replicate what they brought.
I’ve gone for an eight out of ten.

 

[Phil1]

We always find a way to score which is why we have been top scorers for the last several seasons.
It’s too simplistic to just state we are losing goals based on who scored what last year.

 

[Cobwebcat]

We’ve obviously brought in a number of quality players and Pep will have a plan.
My worry is replacing the circa twenty five goals that Gundogan and Mahrez got between them last season in all competitions.
It’s the heavy goals that I think we’re really going to miss.
Mahrez with two goals plus a match winning performance against Spurs when we were really struggling.
Gundogan’s goals against Liverpool, Leeds, Everton and the rags really got us over the line last season.
If you add the assists of both players, I think we’re really going to struggle to replicate what they brought.
I’ve gone for an eight out of ten.

This is the plan

 

[GRB]

Has anyone got the net spend figures yet?

 

[kaz7]

I think we are weaker , defensively better , no cover for kev, ffs and gundys goals gone

 

[Phil1]

lolz. Simplistic like I said.

 

[simon23]

Think our squad depth is a bit thin on the ground

Phillips, Gomez, Bobb are now back ups for regular first team players - and realistically how many would start those players in any game baring dead rubber CL matches, early FA cup games (depending upon draw) and maybe the odd home game against lower prem teams.......not many would choose them......

The defensive portion (inc goalkeeper) seems fine.....attacking mid seems very light

We need to have a bit of luck with injuries (Ie not getting them)

 

[Goodlove]

I think it’s one of our better windows. Especially selling wise. The new signings are shrewd in todays market, we look stronger defensively and once the newbies have bedded in and kev is back we will be offensively stronger to for me.

Mines a treble. Again.

 

[MCFC1993]

Poll Added.

I think the Gvardiol and Kovacic signings are great. I'm hoping Doku and Nunes weren't just desperate grabs at bringing more bodies in. I rate Doku highly as I've seen him at the Euro's so hoping he does blend in well here.

Losing Gundogan is a huge blow, Mahrez was a big loss as well. We've got enough to cope with Laporte's departure and I'm not sure Palmer would have got many minutes.

Retaining Bernardo and Walker is as good as signing 2 new players as well.



At a net spend of £75.5m we've done well (figures taken from Squawka).

Another big positive is we've lowered the age profile, Gundogan (32), Laporte (29), Mahrez (32), Palmer (21) to Kovacic (29), Gvardiol (21), Doku (21), Nunes (25).

I think the kind Champions League draw means we'll be able to rotate a fairly thin squad.

I did think we needed to make at least 1 signing before we lost anybody this summer, so to lose 4 and gain 4 1st teamers makes me think we're a touch short. Unless Phillips stays and plays significantly more minutes (doubtful now Nunes is here).

I'm not sure the starting XI or squad in stronger than last season though, my rating is around a 7 I think. 6 seems harsh, 8 too high. The squad depth is nagging at me though, that could drag it to a 6 before the poll closes.

 

[FantasyIreland]

Awesome,cant beat a Pole in the squad,hard as nails and very reliable.