You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Ballotelli appeal (Merged)
- Thread starter meldrew
- Start date
jamiegrimble
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 1 Oct 2009
- Messages
- 2,520
The FA Kangaroo court strikes again.
Matty
Well-Known Member
There was no way the appeal was going to work, it was clearly bookable (which in itself would have been a red card and a one match ban). Can you imagine the scenario at FA Headquarters:-
"Ok, this Balotelli thing, it's not a straight red really is it"
"Nah, it's a yellow card, but it's not a red"
"Ok, but we can't give him a yellow card for it, it's red or nothing at this stage"
"So we give him nothing"
"Can't do that, if he'd been booked then it was a second yellow and he'd have been sent off"
"So if we recind it completely he gets away without any ban at all, when we're all agreed he should serve a one match ban for two yellow cards?"
"Yes"
"Then we uphold the red card, better he serves an unwarrented three match ban then escapes a one match ban totally"
"Doesn't that seem unfair?"
"Yeah, but this is the English FA, fairness doesn't come into it, we just rigidly apply the rules"
"Ok, fair enough, next case, there's a United player sent off for killing an opponent with the corner flag and....."
"Recind it, probably deserved it"
"Agreed"
"Ok, this Balotelli thing, it's not a straight red really is it"
"Nah, it's a yellow card, but it's not a red"
"Ok, but we can't give him a yellow card for it, it's red or nothing at this stage"
"So we give him nothing"
"Can't do that, if he'd been booked then it was a second yellow and he'd have been sent off"
"So if we recind it completely he gets away without any ban at all, when we're all agreed he should serve a one match ban for two yellow cards?"
"Yes"
"Then we uphold the red card, better he serves an unwarrented three match ban then escapes a one match ban totally"
"Doesn't that seem unfair?"
"Yeah, but this is the English FA, fairness doesn't come into it, we just rigidly apply the rules"
"Ok, fair enough, next case, there's a United player sent off for killing an opponent with the corner flag and....."
"Recind it, probably deserved it"
"Agreed"
mcfcPakistan
Well-Known Member
i think it was straight red card, i saw the complete matchphilinho said:mcfcPakistan said:kocieleny will serve 2 match ban and balo will serve 3 match ban, why is that?
Koscielny's was 2 yellows so should be one match ban, however it's his second red this season so gets an extra game on top
pezlington
Well-Known Member
No surprises its been rejected, I dont think he kicked out at the pleb on the floor as the pleb had hold of Balo's leg, but no way of proving it I guess!
mcfcPakistan
Well-Known Member
lmao, very true very trueMatty said:There was no way the appeal was going to work, it was clearly bookable (which in itself would have been a red card and a one match ban). Can you imagine the scenario at FA Headquarters:-
"Ok, this Balotelli thing, it's not a straight red really is it"
"Nah, it's a yellow card, but it's not a red"
"Ok, but we can't give him a yellow card for it, it's red or nothing at this stage"
"So we give him nothing"
"Can't do that, if he'd been booked then it was a second yellow and he'd have been sent off"
"So if we recind it completely he gets away without any ban at all, when we're all agreed he should serve a one match ban for two yellow cards?"
"Yes"
"Then we uphold the red card, better he serves an unwarrented three match ban then escapes a one match ban totally"
"Doesn't that seem unfair?"
"Yeah, but this is the English FA, fairness doesn't come into it, we just rigidly apply the rules"
"Ok, fair enough, next case, there's a United player sent off for killing an opponent with the corner flag and....."
"Recind it, probably deserved it"
"Agreed"
mike channon´s windmill
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 2 Jun 2008
- Messages
- 7,475
Hundredstone gets fook all - they really are coonts of the first order - what do you expect with that bent twat Gill on the panel - we never stood a fookin earthlys - FA corrupt to the core - what an abberation of a body supposedly the guardians of our national game
Gray
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 30 May 2004
- Messages
- 24,839
- Team supported
- ABU & The Bus Wreckers
I expected Fuck All else from the FA.
They are the most corrupt organisation along with FIFA and EUFA, a bunch of clowns.
They are the most corrupt organisation along with FIFA and EUFA, a bunch of clowns.
philinho said:mcfcPakistan said:kocieleny will serve 2 match ban and balo will serve 3 match ban, why is that?
Koscielny's was 2 yellows so should be one match ban, however it's his second red this season so gets an extra game on top
No Koscielny was a straight red for stopping a goal scoring opportunity which carries a 1 match ban, and an extra match for it being his second red card of the season....
Balotelli was sent off for violent conduct (which includes aiming a kick or punch at an opponent, it does not have to connect) which carries an automatic 3 match ban.....
He also has 3 yellow cards (Sundays one still counts towards the 5 yellows before December 31st = 1 match ban)......
Matty
Well-Known Member
Looking at the FA statement it would seem City DID appeal the length of suspension rather than the fact he was actually going to be suspended, no doubt claiming a 3 game violent conduct punishment for that was excessive in the extreme, obviously the FA weren't having any of it:-
'At a Regulatory Commission hearing today, a claim that the standard punishment is clearly excessive from Manchester City’s Mario Balotelli was dismissed. As a result, Balotelli will serve a three match suspension with immediate effect.'