Battle of the Bands Final - Beatles v Rolling Stones 217

[scenecreamer]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

Assuming you're talking about The Clash, You could not be any further from the truth, The Clash, Give 'em enough rope and London Calling are all amazing albums and Combat Rock is good.

Clash - first album OK, Give 'em enough - average, London Calling - A f*ckin double album, with a 'hidden' track.... Do me a favour; overblown self-indulgent shit padding around a couple of good tracks.

Oasis - Best debut album ever. I need say no more.

If you piled all the Clash's 'great' songs onto one album, it wouldn't last much longer than 10 minutes, including the gaps between songs.

BTW - I didn't rate the Clash. Average musicians, middle-class tossers pretending to be 'street' on a major record label.

Irrelevant, White riot alone is better than anything oasis have ever done. oasis have never made a track that could equall borstal breakout, cranked up really high, o bondage up yours, new rose, nasty nasty, orgasm addict etc. I could go on for ever here. I know they aren't clash songs but, the point is, they haven't done anything that can equal the stuff that came out in the 70's. I guess not being in Manc when they were out might effect my judjement but, I couldn't even name 5 of their songs. As for the bloke that said dominated a decade, you've got to get out more mate, maybe in England. They could walk down any steet here without being recognised. They were the begining of the pussyfication of music.

Exactly.

Guns of Brixton vs Champagne Super Nova????? No fucking contest.

"Average musicians, middle-class tossers pretending to be 'street' on a major record label", sure you're not talking about those silly twats in Oasis?

Clash might have made some money, but they're about something. Unlike those idiots singing Wonderwall. "What's the story, morning glory?", blegh! Pap for simpletons.

 

[ElanJo]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

Oasis.

 

[BlueHammer85]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

Clash - first album OK, Give 'em enough - average, London Calling - A f*ckin double album, with a 'hidden' track.... Do me a favour; overblown self-indulgent shit padding around a couple of good tracks.

Oasis - Best debut album ever. I need say no more.

If you piled all the Clash's 'great' songs onto one album, it wouldn't last much longer than 10 minutes, including the gaps between songs.

BTW - I didn't rate the Clash. Average musicians, middle-class tossers pretending to be 'street' on a major record label.

Irrelevant, White riot alone is better than anything oasis have ever done. oasis have never made a track that could equall borstal breakout, cranked up really high, o bondage up yours, new rose, nasty nasty, orgasm addict etc. I could go on for ever here. I know they aren't clash songs but, the point is, they haven't done anything that can equal the stuff that came out in the 70's. I guess not being in Manc when they were out might effect my judjement but, I couldn't even name 5 of their songs. As for the bloke that said dominated a decade, you've got to get out more mate, maybe in England. They could walk down any steet here without being recognised. They were the begining of the pussyfication of music.

Exactly.

Guns of Brixton vs Champagne Super Nova????? No fucking contest.

"Average musicians, middle-class tossers pretending to be 'street' on a major record label", sure you're not talking about those silly twats in Oasis?

Clash might have made some money, but they're about something. Unlike those idiots singing Wonderwall. "What's the story, morning glory?", blegh! Pap for simpletons.

Why are you only judging Oasis on the Morning Glory album ?

Have you never heard Definately Maybe ? Heathen Chemistry ? or the Masterplan ? You really think The Clash could release an album of B Sides that match Oasis ?

 

[Anonymous]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

Funny. This one is potentially all about the number of POP tunes in which case Oasis wins hands down. However if we talk about artistic integrity, then The Clash win hands down. Ultimately, if you are asking my opinion, then as I own more Oasis than The Clash, then Oasis win on that basis.

 

[shootmeifipost10k]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

I've not looked at the voting since page 25 but if Oasis are beating the Clash then my thoughts on members sanity on here will be drastically changed and that's still accounting for Oasis being a manchester band.

The Clash by a country mile

 

[BlueHammer85]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

I've not looked at the voting since page 25 but if Oasis are beating the Clash then my thoughts on members sanity on here will be drastically changed and that's still accounting for Oasis being a manchester band.

The Clash by a country mile

The Clash had one major hit .... Oasis had countless

why is it such a suprise people would vote Oasis ?

 

[shootmeifipost10k]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

I've not looked at the voting since page 25 but if Oasis are beating the Clash then my thoughts on members sanity on here will be drastically changed and that's still accounting for Oasis being a manchester band.

The Clash by a country mile

The Clash had one major hit .... Oasis had countless

why is it such a suprise people would vote Oasis ?

I'm not surprised people would vote for them I quite like some of the stuff Oasis have done but to compare them the Clash IMO is a no contest, maybe it's an age thing with me being an older git.

My next nightmare in the contest will be The Jam up against someone like fucking Boyzone and losing out with the way people are voting ;0)

 

[cityspud]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

Oasis all day.

 

[Barcon]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

I've not looked at the voting since page 25 but if Oasis are beating the Clash then my thoughts on members sanity on here will be drastically changed and that's still accounting for Oasis being a manchester band.

The Clash by a country mile

The Clash had one major hit .... Oasis had countless

why is it such a suprise people would vote Oasis ?

Fuck me, boney m had more hits than the new york dolls, get a grip man.

 

[MCFC BOB]

Re: Battle of the Bands - The Clash v Oasis page 25

The one contest I won't enter. Rock the Casbah is better than everything Oasis have ever done, though.