TheMightyQuinn
Well-Known Member
southside blue said:kind of suprised to not see joy division mentioned, certainly they'd have to count?
They were in my list but then I scrapped it as I didnt want to get into the whole 'what is punk/new wave' etc.
Are we classing punk as starting and ending with the pistols? Or can we include the NY CBGB scene? I'm hoping we can instantly dismiss any 'punk' band post 1980?
Then you get into new wave which seems to be a label that most bands who emerged post 1977 fit.
It's a minefield I didnt want to get into as music debates on here usually degenerate into bitter arguments and I cant be arsed going there at the moment.
At uni last year I was working my magic on a young girl who told me she liked 'punk', I was pleasantly surprised and started to tell her of my love for Pistols/Clash/Buzzcocks and the CBGB lot when she said I was 'old school' and she went on to name lots of modern american bands who wear big shorts and shout a lot.