I've not had the chance to go through all of the thread but for what it is worth here's my thoughts on today's game:
Personally I feel that we played too high defensively today, but that is due to the tactic of pressing high against the opposition. Against some teams this is perfect as it forces those without the necessary ball quality to make mistakes/ concede possession and enables us to dominate both territorially and in possession. Looking at our opening fixtures this is how I envisage us playing against Newcastle, Cardiff and Hull. I don't think that such risky tactics will be employed against teams with the ability to break with the quality of arsenal. If anything, they are the team not to play that way against, but in terms of setting out a plan for the start of the season I feel this was the thinking behind today's tactics. I also feel that against the major teams we will revert to one up front (aguero) and play 3 in behind (jov / silva / navas) with yaya and ferny holding a little deeper and the back 4 dropping off 5-10 metres.
Therefore I would look at today with the next few games in mind; although we defended very poorly for the goals, I wouldn't expect Hull Newcastle or Cardiff to possess the ability to hit us with such quality (especially after chasing shadows for a large part of the game). Obviously, if this is THE tactic we wants to play throughout the season, I'd advise he look at AVBs Chelsea who went from defensive stability to being cut wide open with through balls and over the top balls put in behind their back 4. We shouldn't look to repeat these errors.
Personnel wise:
Silva looks sharp and though the partnership between yaya and ferny requires more understanding it's obvious that both possess great abilitties in winning and maintaining possession of the ball. For me, Garcia shouldn't be back up for either of these being absent; Milner, Barry and Rodwell are my preferred options for central midfield behind these two.
Nastastic is a miss. His positional sense and reading of the game are underrated qualities and there's not a chance the space between clichy and lescott would have been so vulnerable today with his inclusion. It s paramount that he is not rushed back so is ready to assume his partnership with Vinny for the rest of the season.
Negredo has impressed with histenacity, movemennd work rate; at the moment he is my preferred option to Dzeko to start if we play one out and out striker. He will become more clinical with games and can easily see him bagging 3/4 in the opening games; he takes up some excellent positions in and around the box.
Overall, don't be concerned about today's tactics / result etc... If he lines up like that against the better teams come the actual league matches, then yes be worried, but I think he's trying to get a across a high intensity, closing down tactic into his players which will enable us to make the necessary improvements to turn last seasons draws into victories.