Clattenburg (Update p59 - not selected next weekend)

[Prestwich_Blue]

Re: Clattenburg

Chelsea's 9 remaining players on the pitch cost more than the 11 united players on the pitch in terms of transfer fee's and wages so Chelsea still should have won.

No point blaming the ref.

Oy vay!!!!

 

[scotty123]

Clattenburg demoted

Withdrawn from matchday ten

 

[Prestwich_Blue]

Re: Clattenburg demoted

Withdrawn from matchday ten

But I'm sure that was always the plan that he refereed in the Gosforth Sunday School League this weekend.

 

[Paladin]

Are we castigating Clattenburg for the winning goal also, or are we in agreement that this was the fault of the linesman?

 

[bernabias home shirt]

Are we castigating Clattenburg for the winning goal also, or are we in agreement that this was the fault of the linesman?

It was the triads mate!

 

[manimanc]

I blame david icke,those reptiles have been at it again!!!

 

[bert's broken neck]

Re: Clattenburg

young wasnt on a yellow

i think your missing the point

Personally i dont blame Torres for going down, he got caught, he had no where to go.

But if lets say, any simulation would result in a 5 match ban ... i doubt he would of went down

5 match ban only if simulation is proven "beyond reasonable doubt". Torres would have got off on appeal imho, as he was definitely clipped by Evans and at that speed any clip can cause the player to go down - just ask Ashley "Tom Daley" Young!

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Re: Clattenburg demoted

Withdrawn from matchday ten

It's a start, but what about matchdays 11-38?

 

[cibaman]

Re: Clattenburg

i think your missing the point

Personally i dont blame Torres for going down, he got caught, he had no where to go.

But if lets say, any simulation would result in a 5 match ban ... i doubt he would of went down

5 match ban only if simulation is proven "beyond reasonable doubt". Torres would have got off on appeal imho, as he was definitely clipped by Evans and at that speed any clip can cause the player to go down - just ask Ashley "Tom Daley" Young!

It begs the question whether a player that is clipped is obliged to try to stay on his feet at all costs. Often they may be able to stay on their feet but in regaining their balance they could lose control of the ball, make a scoring chance more difficult. If they stay on their feet they end up losing out.

 

[St Helens Blue (Exiled)]

Got a feeling he will get the Derby!


Imagine