I showed the leaked badge and Gavs 'Rose' badge to my brother in law today, who incidentally is a Villa fan. I told him one had been designed by a professional design team commissioned by the club and one had been designed for free by a fan on a message board.
Unsurprisingly he thought the one Gav had done had been commissioned by the club and vice-Versa. He couldn't believe it when I told him. he commented on its 'cartoony' style and lack of 'FC' or 'Football Club' which seems to be a common theme for the 'dislikers'.