The top of the order's very shaky. You can't expect Joe to pull us out of the shit every innings. I actually like Comptons dour doggedness, he values his wicket and is pretty good at holding an end up, which you need in test cricket. Hales has to go, but who for? I think Carberry deserves another chance. Long term that young Asian lad at Lancs looks to have the right temperament, he's capable of building an innings. I like Cook but it doesn't help when the captain's not performing because you can't drop him. On the plus side the middle order's good and we generally bat low down and we've got a good, balanced bowling attack. If we can sort the top order out we could be the best in the world