Kippax Street 1880
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 22 Mar 2010
- Messages
- 8,983
England can play Pope as a wicket keeper and still play all 4 and Bashir
But England will name 3 quicks and Bashir and have Stokes bowling after the ball goes soft
Having the options is the key, the Aussie will play Nathan Lyon's because he's done well at Perth before, so england must have a change-up at both ends after the new ball goes soft and Bashir spin and Stokes mixed up cutters and slower balls.
No way would I be dropping Smith he's been a revelation. If it were up to me I'd have taken the young Leg spinner Renan Ahmed. His stats this year in County Cricket have been great and he's turning into a real genuine all-rounder aswell, but maybe it's a bit too soon for him being so young, a bad away Ashes could ruin him. (Just seen he is injured)
The thing with Bashir is he hasn't shown me he can tie an end down for a long spell, he seems to bowl a lot of 4 balls. I'd rather have the workhorse Carse bowling some short stuff during those periods when the ball goes soft than an ineffective spinner who goes at over 4 an over which is what I think will happen to Shoaib this tour.
What we would do to be able to select Graeme Swann in this side. Been slim pickings for English spinners since he retired and we haven't won a Test in Australia either. I genuinely believe the best off-spinner in England at the moment is Joe Root.
